Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Marketing Finance › Budgeting

Reforecasting a Marketing Budget Mid-Year

How to reforecast a marketing budget mid-year: actuals and commitments, an estimate to complete for each line, timing or permanent changes and a submission.
Tutorialintermediate12 min readUpdated

What a reforecast is for

The original budget was a set of guesses made before the year started: which campaigns would run when, what each line would cost and what it would buy. By mid-year some of those guesses are wrong. Campaigns slip, events are cancelled, prices move and some channels do better than planned. A reforecast replaces the guesses with knowledge, so the company's full-year forecast reflects what marketing will actually spend and achieve.

The guide to tracking spend against budget explains why reforecasts matter to finance: they are the formal points at which permanent variances are raised, money is moved between lines and money that will not be used well is returned. Its reallocation rules, agreed at the start of the year, say who may move what and whether underspends can be carried. The budgeting hub puts reforecast points on the four-date calendar every marketer should learn from finance. This tutorial does not restate those rules; it builds the figures they are applied to.

A reforecast has a second job that is easy to forget: it updates the outcome forecast alongside the spend. Kaushik's measurement model, as the page on a missed marketing forecast applies it, sets a target against every key measure, so a forecast is that set of targets. A reforecast that changes the spend and leaves the outcome targets alone guarantees a miss later in the year. A reforecast that changes both tells finance what the money will now buy. The academy exercise on reforecasting a pet treat maker's marketing budget after a product recall practises rebuilding the year line by line, separating timing changes from permanent ones.

Some lines reforecast more often under their own rules. Where paid media follows results within agreed limits, the target-led paid media budget tutorial closes each month and reforecasts the quarter as a range; carry its latest figures into this reforecast rather than rebuilding them. Campaign media plans feed in the same way: the tutorial on managing a media plan while it runs logs credits not re-spent, cancelled lines and unspent reserve, and hands those changes to the reforecast in the week they happen.

Before you start

  • Finance's reforecast instruction. The date, the template or format, the level of detail, who approves and whether underspends may be carried or must be returned. Ask your finance business partner; these differ between companies.
  • The latest reconciled month. The tracker with every closed month reconciled to the ledger, including accruals, as the tutorial on estimating marketing accruals describes. If the tracker is not yet in shape, the tutorial on setting up a marketing budget tracker builds one.
  • The commitments log. Every open order, booking and contract with its remaining value and the months it covers.
  • The approved budget and its outcome targets. The signed-off version from the budget-building tutorial, including the scenarios and the outcome measure for each line.
  • Outcome actuals to date. Leads, orders, new customers or whatever each line was budgeted to buy, by month, from the same reporting the tracker uses.
  • Marginal return estimates. Whatever the team has for the main paid lines: step tests, spend-response curves or past reallocations, as the marginal returns and forecasting guide describes.
  • Line owners' time. Each owner knows what their line still needs. Book them before the build, not after.

The steps

  1. Start from the latest reconciled month

    Take actual spend to date for every line from the tracker, up to and including the latest month that has been closed and reconciled to the ledger. Use reconciled figures, with accruals in place, not platform spend or invoices received: the reforecast must start from the same number finance sees, or every later figure will be argued about. If the most recent month has not closed yet, either wait for it or include it as an estimate and label it clearly. The budget month-end close checklist lists what a closed month includes.

  2. Add open commitments line by line

    From the commitments log, add everything already promised for the rest of the year on each line: retainers, booked events, signed media orders, contracts that run to year end. These cannot easily change, so they form the floor of each line's remaining spend. Note each commitment's next break point beside it, because the options for closing a gap later depend on which commitments could end and which cannot. Where a commitment covers months beyond the year, include only the part inside it and flag the rest. How such a commitment is approved, split by budget year and carried into the following budget is set out in the guide to committing marketing money beyond the budget year.

  3. Estimate what each line still needs to the year end

    For each line, ask the owner what the rest of the year will actually cost beyond what is committed: the campaigns still planned, media still to buy, production still to commission. This is the estimate to complete. Build it from the plan for the remaining months, adjusted for what the first half taught: prices that moved, campaigns that grew or shrank, Seasonality that turned out stronger or weaker than assumed. Actuals to date plus commitments plus the estimate to complete is the line's latest estimate for the full year. Avoid two shortcuts: assuming the second half will cost what the budget phased for it, and extrapolating the first half's run rate. Both ignore what the owner knows.

  4. Mark every change as timing or permanent

    Compare each line's latest estimate with its budget and explain every difference in the tracking guide's terms: timing or permanent. A campaign that moved from one quarter to the next is timing; if it still happens within the year, the full-year figure is unchanged. A cancelled event, a price increase or a channel that cannot absorb its planned spend is permanent and changes the full year. A campaign that slips past the year end is permanent for this year, even though it may return next year. Write one line per difference: which line, how much, timing or permanent, full-year effect.

  5. Forecast the outcomes the remaining spend should buy

    For each line, forecast the outcomes the remaining spend should produce, using the same measure and key performance indicator (KPI) the budget set. Do not divide the new spend by the average cost so far; use marginal estimates, because the last share of spend buys less than the average, as the marginal returns guide's scenario table shows. Where you have a marginal return on ad spend (marginal ROAS) estimate, use it; where you do not, use a cautious range. Check the first half's miss or beat against the forecast-missed page's split into volume, rate and timing, so the second-half forecast corrects the assumption that failed rather than the total.

  6. Find the gap against budget and the options to close it

    Add up the latest estimates. The difference from the total budget is the spend gap: an underspend or an overspend for the year. Set it beside the outcome gap: the difference between the outcomes now forecast and those the budget promised. Then list the options. An underspend can be returned, moved to a line with evidence it can spend well, or held against a named need if finance's rules allow it. Before choosing, the diagnosis for an underspent marketing budget checks how much of the gap is only phasing, missing accruals or unlogged commitments and how much is activity that did not happen. An overspend can be closed by cutting variable lines first, then commitments at their break points, following the guide to cutting a marketing budget, or by asking for more money with the outcomes it would buy. An outcome gap may need money moved even when spend is on budget. Where the cut falls on a signed campaign media plan, the tutorial on replanning a media plan after a budget cut separates the booked lines that can still move from those that cannot and marks each saving as timing or permanent.

  7. Propose moves, returns and requests with evidence

    Turn the options into specific proposals. Each move between lines goes on a budget reallocation memo with its amount, the evidence of marginal return on both lines and the outcome it should change; the budget allocation guide explains why the comparison is between marginal returns rather than averages. Each return says how much and from which line. Each request for more says what it would buy and why the evidence supports it. The scenario planning framework helps present a request as a lower and a higher case with the conditions under which each applies, rather than a single figure. Propose fewer, better-evidenced moves rather than many small ones.

  8. Submit in finance's format with the assumptions written down

    Put the figures into finance's template, at the level of detail finance asked for, and add a short note. The note states the full-year latest estimate against budget, the main timing and permanent changes, the proposed moves, returns and requests, the revised outcome forecast and the assumptions behind it: prices, dates of slipped campaigns, marginal estimates and anything still uncertain. Written assumptions are what let the next reforecast, or a review of a later miss, check which one failed. Keep the original budget unchanged in the tracker and add the approved reforecast beside it as the latest forecast.

  9. Track the new forecast month by month

    Once finance approves the reforecast, report each month's actuals against both the original budget and the new forecast. Variances against the forecast are now the ones that matter for decisions, because they show whether the reforecast's assumptions are holding. Record each approved move in the tracker with its memo and save a dated version of the reforecast. With few conversions or short periods, read monthly outcome differences as the guide to reading small numbers advises and do not rebuild the forecast on one month's noise. The next reforecast starts from this one, with its assumptions to test.

The line-by-line reforecast table

Each row is one budget line. The columns build the latest estimate from what is known to what is estimated, then set it against the budget and the outcomes.

ColumnWhat goes in itWhere it comes from
Budget for the yearThe approved figure, unchangedThe approved budget
Actual to dateReconciled spend including accruals, to the last closed monthThe tracker, after reconciliation with the ledger
Open commitmentsPromised spend for the rest of the year, with break pointsThe commitments log
Estimate to completeFurther spend the line still needs beyond commitmentsThe line owner, from the remaining plan
Latest estimateActual to date plus commitments plus estimate to completeCalculated
Variance against budgetLatest estimate minus budgetCalculated
Timing or permanentThe cause of each part of the varianceThe line owner
Outcome target and forecastThe budgeted outcome and the outcome now expectedThe budget and the marginal estimates
ProposalMove, return, request or none, with the memo referenceThe reforecast discussion
AssumptionsWhat the estimate depends onThe line owner

For quick checks on the new full-year total, such as how a proposed return changes the year, the marketing budget calculator is enough; the line-by-line work stays in this table.

A candle maker's mid-year reforecast (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Orlamby Candles reforecasts at the half year

Orlamby Candles, an invented online candle and home fragrance brand, has an annual marketing budget of £540,000. At the half year, reconciled spend is £230,000 against £270,000 phased, an underspend of £40,000.

The line owners explain it. The influencer programme slipped a quarter because the autumn range arrived late: £20,000 of first-half spend moves into the third quarter and the full year is unchanged, so it is timing. A pop-up shop budgeted at £24,000 for June was cancelled when the unit was withdrawn and will not be replaced: permanent. Paid search costs rose, so the search line, already £4,000 over in the first half, will need £129,000 against its £120,000 budget to buy the same volume of orders in the peak months: a permanent overspend of £9,000.

Before any proposals, the latest estimate for the year is £525,000: the budget, less the pop-up, plus the search increase. The team proposes two things on reallocation memos. It moves £8,000 to paid social, where a step test in May showed a further £8,000 over the second half would buy orders at a marginal return still above target, which takes the latest estimate to £533,000. It returns the remaining £7,000 to finance, so the revised budget and the latest estimate agree. The search increase is absorbed within the year's total rather than funded by a request for new money.

On outcomes, it lowers the second-half order forecast from 21,000 to 19,500: the influencer programme now has less peak-season time to work, and the search increase buys the same volume at higher cost rather than more orders. The submission lists every assumption, including the third-quarter influencer dates and the search cost per click it assumed, so the next reforecast can test each one.

Verify it worked

  • Actual to date matches the tracker and the ledger for the last closed month, so finance sees the same starting number.
  • Each line's latest estimate equals actual to date plus commitments plus the estimate to complete. In the Orlamby example, the forecast is the plan less the cuts plus the additions, and it reconciles exactly.
  • Every difference from budget is marked timing or permanent. The influencer slip leaves the full year unchanged.
  • The outcome forecast moved wherever the spend moved. Orlamby lowered its second-half orders from 21,000 to 19,500.
  • The submission note lists every assumption, beside the unchanged original budget.

If it goes wrong

  • Finance disputes your starting point. Actuals are probably unreconciled or accruals are missing. Reconcile the last closed month to the ledger.
  • A line looks underspent but turns out to be promised. The commitments log is probably incomplete. Add the missing commitments, then rebuild that line's estimate.
  • The latest estimate copies the budget phasing or the first half's run rate. Ask the line owner for the estimate to complete instead.
  • A slipped campaign was returned as an underspend. It was timing, not permanent. Recheck each difference against what still happens within the year.
  • The outcome forecast misses early. It probably used average cost, or reacted to a small count. Switch to marginal estimates or a cautious range.

Next steps

Common mistakes

  • Starting from unreconciled figures. If actuals to date do not match the ledger, finance will argue with the starting point instead of the proposals.
  • Leaving out commitments. A line that looks underspent may already be fully promised; check the log before offering money back.
  • Extrapolating the first half. A run rate ignores seasonality, slipped campaigns and what the owner knows about the rest of the year.
  • Not separating timing from permanent. A slipped campaign is not an underspend to return, and a cancelled one is not a timing difference to wait for.
  • Changing spend without changing outcomes. The outcome targets must move with the money, or the second half will miss by construction.
  • Using averages for the outcome forecast. The last share of spend buys less than the average; marginal estimates give an honest forecast.
  • Holding underspends without a plan. Unused money held to the year end tends to be spent badly; return it or move it with evidence.
  • Not writing down the assumptions. Without them, the next review cannot tell which part of the forecast failed.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a budget, a forecast and a reforecast?

The budget is the plan approved before the year started and it stays fixed as the baseline. A forecast is the current best estimate of where the year will end. A reforecast is the formal point at which that estimate is rebuilt and submitted to finance, with money moved, returned or requested. Variances are then reported against both the budget and the latest forecast, so everyone can see what changed and why.

Should we keep an underspend in case we need it later in the year?

Only if there is a specific, evidenced use for it. Holding money without a plan is how year-end rushes start, and the tracking guide is clear that late, hurried spending buys poor results and teaches finance that marketing budgets are padded. Whether an underspend can be carried forward or must be returned is finance's rule, so ask; where the rule allows a choice, return what you cannot spend well and say so early.

How do we forecast outcomes when the numbers so far are small?

Use ranges rather than single figures, and lean on more than the last few months: the same period last year, the marginal estimates you have, and what the plan assumed. With few conversions, a month's swing is often noise, so read the figures as the guide to reading small numbers advises and say in the submission how uncertain each line's outcome forecast is.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Part of these learning paths

Sources

  1. Digital Marketing and Measurement Model — Avinash Kaushik

Related