What changes between sign-off and the end of a campaign
The building a media plan tutorial ends by freezing a baseline, holding a reserve and agreeing how changes during the campaign will be proposed, approved and recorded. The post-campaign analysis guide compares the finished buy with that baseline. This tutorial covers the weeks in between.
Three kinds of change arrive. Delivery changes: a radio spot is bumped, an out-of-home site is not posted on time, a digital line under-paces or a guaranteed buy falls behind. Evidence changes: a line responds better or worse than planned, or a test reads early. Context changes: a competitor launches, stock runs short, a date moves. Each tempts the team to change the plan. Some changes should happen; others are reactions to noise. The routine below separates them by deciding, before launch, what will be measured, how often, by whom and what would trigger action. That is management by exception applied to a media plan: each line's tolerance and the person who acts are agreed before launch, drift inside it needs no escalation, and the weekly note names the lines outside it.
The tutorial does not restate platform mechanics. How a daily budget is spent and paced in search is in the guide to Google Ads budgets and pacing, and pacing modes and under-delivery in programmatic buying are in the guide to DV360 bidding and pacing. Here, those platforms are lines in a wider plan, and their Budget PacingHow fast a campaign spends its budget across the flight compared with the plan. is one input to a weekly check that also covers airtime, posters and print.
Before you start
- The frozen baseline. The signed plan saved as it was, with line-level weight, dates, cost and expected delivery.
- The insertion ordersThe contract for a direct or guaranteed media buy, recording what will run, where, when, at what price and what happens if it does not run.. For each line, the counting source, make-good and cancellation termsThe terms in a media booking or insertion order that set how late it can be cancelled or changed without penalty, and what is non-cancellable., as the negotiation and insertion orders guide sets out.
- The measurement plan. Which source reports each measure and when, on the pattern of the measurement plan framework.
- The reserve and its owner, as shown in the signed plan.
- The budget tracker, as the guide to tracking spend against budget describes, so committed and spent money are visible.
- A named owner for the weekly check and a named approver for changes beyond the planner's limits.
The steps
Agree the counting source and the weekly cadence
For every line, name the source that counts delivery: the independent ad server, a verification report, the station's log, the posting report, the platform. The media auditing and verification guide explains why an agreed counting source matters and notes that the Media Rating Council in the United States, and comparable bodies elsewhere, accredit measurement services against published standards; where an accredited source exists, it is the stronger basis. Then agree when each source reports and set a weekly day when every line's figures are collected together. Offline sources often report more slowly than digital ones, so note which figures will lag.
Set the tolerances before launch
Decide, before the first spot airs, how far a line may drift from its baseline before someone acts, and what the action is. Tolerances depend on the line: a guaranteed buy with a make-good clause, a non-guaranteed digital line and a fixed sponsorship each behave differently, and a line's tolerance late in its flight is tighter than early on. This tutorial gives no figures; the team sets them from its own experience and writes them into the plan beside each line, with the person who acts. Tolerances agreed in advance turn a mid-campaign debate into a decision already taken before launch. For television, radio, print and outdoor lines, the offline media flight launch checklist confirms the counting sources and tolerances are written down before the first spot airs.
Collect delivery by line each week
On the agreed day, collect for each line: weight delivered to date (impressions, spots, sites, insertions), spend to date, dates live, placements reported, and where relevant ViewabilityShare of measured ad impressions that had a real chance to be seen. and invalid traffic from verification. Use one sheet with the same columns for every medium, so a radio line and a video line can be read side by side. Record the source and the date of each figure. Where a source has not reported, record that rather than estimating; a gap is information.
Compare it with the frozen baseline
Set each line's delivery to date beside what the BaselineAn estimate of what a metric would have done without a given change, campaign or promotion, against which the effect is measured. said it should have delivered by now, and mark any line outside its tolerance. Look at the plan as well as the lines: is the combined weight on track for the reach goal? Weekly ReachUnique people who saw an ad. and FrequencyAverage times a person saw an ad. readings are estimates, and the cross-platform reach and frequency guide explains why totals across platforms cannot simply be added. The reach and frequency calculator gives a rough check of whether a line's delivery to date is consistent with its reach contribution. Never edit the baseline; record the comparison.
Chase under-delivery and make-goods while they still help
For every line behind its tolerance, ask the seller why and what it will do, citing the order. The negotiation guide notes that the IAB publishes standard terms for interactive media that many buyers and sellers use as the base contract, and that other media carry their sellers' own terms; either way, make-good and cancellation rights are read from the order, not assumed. Ask for make-goods that run inside the period the plan needs, on comparable placements and audience. If they cannot run in time, say so in writing and ask for the credit or refund the order allows. A shortfall chased early can be recovered; one found at wrap-up can only be credited.
Decide what may move without re-approval
Write down, before launch, which changes the planner or buyer can make alone and which need the budget holder. A common pattern lets the planner move money between lines with the same role, or within a medium, within a stated limit, and sends back anything that changes the total, adds or removes a medium, moves money between brand and performance lines, or breaks a commitment in an order. The table after these steps sets out a typical split of decisions. Agreeing it in advance keeps small optimisations fast and large changes visible.
Release the reserve against a rule
The reserve exists for under-delivery recovery and for evidence that a line deserves more. Set the release rule before launch: what evidence, from which source, over what period, releases how much of the reserve to which kind of line, and who approves it. When the rule is met, release the money and record it; when it is not, leave the reserve alone, however tempting an early result looks. For a larger move, write it up on the budget reallocation memo template, which records the evidence, the guardrails and the review date.
Log every change with its reason
Keep a change log beside the weekly sheet: the date, the line, what changed (weight, dates, placement, creative, money), the reason, the evidence, who decided and who approved. Log make-goods agreed, credits claimed and reserve released. The log is what lets the post-campaign analysis separate what the plan assumed from what the team decided during the campaign. Without it, every difference between baseline and delivery looks like a planning error or a seller's failure, and neither may be true.
Hand budget changes to the reforecast
Moves inside the plan's total stay in the plan. Anything that changes the total, such as a credit that will not be re-spent, a line cancelled or an increase approved, also changes the marketing budget, and belongs in the tutorial on reforecasting a marketing budget. Tell the budget owner in the same week, with the change log entry, so committed and expected spend in the budget tracker stay true. When the total is cut from outside the plan, the tutorial on replanning a media plan after a budget cut decides which lines go and freezes the replanned version as a new baseline beside the original.
Close each week with a short note
End the weekly check with a short written note to the budget holder and the team: delivery against the baseline by line, lines outside tolerance and what is being done, make-goods claimed, money moved and reserve remaining, and anything that may need a decision next week. Keep it to what changed. The notes, the weekly sheets and the change log together become the record the post-campaign analysis starts from. For digital accounts, the monthly paid media review checklist covers the deeper monthly check of tracking, pacing and returns.
In-flight decisions and who makes them
The split below is a common pattern rather than a rule; the point is to agree one before launch. Each organisation sets its own limits.
| Decision | Who usually makes it | What it needs | Where it is recorded |
|---|---|---|---|
| Adjust bids, pacing or targeting inside a digital line | Buyer or platform specialist | Line stays within its budget and role | Change log |
| Swap creative versions already approved | Planner or buyer | Approved creative, same message | Change log |
| Chase under-delivery and agree make-goods | Buyer | The order's make-good terms | Change log and weekly note |
| Move money between lines with the same role, within the limit | Planner | Evidence, within the stated limit | Change log |
| Release part of the reserve | Planner, approved by budget holder | The pre-agreed rule is met | Change log, reallocation memo if large |
| Move money between brand and performance lines | Budget holder | Written case | Reallocation memo and change log |
| Add or drop a medium, or cancel a booked line | Budget holder, with the buyer on cancellation terms | Written case and the order's terms | Reallocation memo, change log, reforecast |
| Change the plan's total | Budget holder and finance | Reforecast | Reforecast and change log |
The media planning framework lists the planning decisions behind each line, and the media measurement hub keeps delivery, verification and effectiveness apart; the in-flight routine is about delivery, and effectiveness belongs to the analytics guides.
A bathroom retailer runs its spring plan (illustrative)
Wexparra Bathrooms manages a spring plan week by week
Wexparra Bathrooms, an invented bathroom retailer with showrooms, runs an eight-week spring plan of £260,000 across radio, out-of-home, online video and paid search, with a £20,000 reserve. Before launch, the team writes the tolerances into the plan: a guaranteed line more than 10% behind its baseline to date triggers a call to the seller; a non-guaranteed line more than 15% behind triggers a review of targeting. The reserve rule: if paid search is limited by budget for two consecutive weeks while cost per showroom booking stays below £45, up to £10,000 is released to it, approved by the marketing director.
In week three, the station logs show 34 of 220 radio spots did not air because of a schedule change. The buyer cites the order's make-good clause and the station runs 34 comparable spots in weeks four and five, before the sale weekend in week six. Out-of-home posts on time; online video paces 6% behind, within tolerance, and recovers by week five.
From week four, paid search is limited by budget while cost per booking runs at £38 and then £41. The rule is met, the marketing director approves, and £8,000 of the reserve moves to search for weeks five to eight. Each move goes into the change log with its date, reason and approver. That move stays inside the plan's total, so it stays in the plan. In week eight the unspent £12,000 of reserve does change the total, so it is logged and handed to the budget reforecast as an underspend that same week.
The post-campaign analysis later shows radio delivered against its baseline after make-goods, and the change log lets the planner explain why search spend ended above plan.
Common mistakes
- No counting source agreed. If the seller's count and the ad server disagree and nothing says which wins, every weekly check turns into an argument.
- Tolerances invented mid-campaign. A threshold chosen after a line falls behind is a reaction, not a rule. Set them before launch.
- Editing the baseline. Updating the signed plan to match delivery destroys the comparison the post-campaign analysis needs. Keep the baseline frozen and log changes beside it.
- Chasing make-goods at wrap-up. Shortfalls found at the end can only be credited; found weekly, they can be made good while they still help.
- Releasing the reserve on a hunch. An early strong week is noise more often than signal. Release against the rule agreed before launch.
- Changes nobody wrote down. Without a log, the post-campaign analysis cannot tell a planning error from a decision.
- Keeping budget changes inside the media team. A credit not re-spent or a line cancelled changes the budget; hand it to the reforecastA rebuild of the full-year view of the budget from actual spend and what marketing now knows, done at the points finance sets; not a fresh budget. the same week.
