When to run this checklist
Run it at the monthly review, after the month's spend and conversions are closed and the reporting pack is out. Running it on the first working day, before late conversions and offline imports have landed, makes the last week of every month look worse than it was and invites the wrong decisions.
The review works best with search, social and programmatic reviewed side by side rather than in separate meetings. Separate meetings let each channel claim the same customers and each channel owner argue for more budget; one meeting forces the question of where the next pound does the most good. The chair is whoever owns the paid media budget. Channel owners bring their numbers; the analyst brings the reconciliation.
Run a shorter version when a large budget shift or a new campaign launched mid-month, but keep the data group in every version. Where the digital accounts are lines in a wider campaign with radio, out-of-home or print, the tutorial on managing a media plan while it runs covers the weekly delivery check across every medium that sits between these monthly reviews.
Before you start
- The monthly reporting pack, frozen, with spend and conversions by channel and campaign.
- The budget plan by channel and campaign, with the month's targets for cost per result and return.
- The reconciliation of platform conversions with analytics and the CRM, prepared by the analyst.
- Each channel's notes: search term review, frequency and fatigue by ad set, bid strategy status, placement and brand safety reports.
- The test log, with tests due to finish this month.
- Last month's decision log, to check what was agreed was done.
The checklist
Work through the groups in order and do not skip ahead to results. A review that starts with return on spend before checking the tracking can spend an hour explaining a change that was caused by a broken tag.
Data first
Spend
Results
Channel health
Decisions
Where each check is explained
The widget above keeps the lines short so they can be ticked; the reasoning lives in the guides. Each check links to the page that explains it.
| Check | Explained in |
|---|---|
| Conversion tracking ran without gaps | Marketing data quality |
| Platform conversions reconciled with analytics and the CRM | Why platforms and analytics disagree |
| Spend compared with budget by channel and campaign | Tracking marketing spend against budget |
| Underspend, overspend and budget-limited campaigns | Budgets and pacing |
| Cost per result and return against target | Performance marketing reporting and reviews |
| Campaigns where extra spend buys little | Marginal returns and spend forecasting |
| Retargeting and brand search claiming demand | Retargeting and brand search take all the credit |
| Search terms reviewed and negatives added | Negative keywords |
| Frequency and creative fatigue on social | Frequency and creative fatigue |
| Bid strategies out of learning | Smart bidding strategies |
| Placement and brand safety reports for programmatic | Brand safety and viewability |
| Finished tests read out and decided | Testing and scaling performance campaigns |
| Next month's budget split with reasons | Budget allocation across channels |
| Each decision with an owner and a date | Paid search account management playbook |
If an item fails
A failure in the data group changes the rest of the meeting. If tracking broke for part of the month, mark that period in every chart and do not judge any campaign on it; if the reconciliation shows a gap that nobody can explain, review results on the source the business already agreed to trust, usually the CRM or the order system, and park platform-reported ROASRevenue generated per unit of ad spend. until the gap is explained. Fix the tracking first and record the fix as a decision with an owner. For Google Ads, the tutorial on reconciling conversions with sales records sizes each cause of the gap and keeps a monthly ratio that shows when it moves. For Meta, the tutorial on reconciling Meta results with your orders does the same with Meta's own rules, from purchase events received against orders to a ratio under one attribution setting.
Spend failures need a reason before they need a correction. Underspend may be a budget-limited campaign starved by a low bid cap, or simply a lack of demand; overspend may be a pacing setting or a budget raised without approval. Read each campaign's budget pacingHow fast a campaign spends its budget across the flight compared with the plan. across the month before moving money.
Results failures, such as a CPACost of each conversion. above target, lead to the question the results group exists to ask: is the campaign poor, or is it being asked to spend past the point where extra money buys much? A campaign with healthy average returns and a poor marginal ROASExtra revenue returned by the last increment of ad spend. should be capped, not scaled; a campaign whose return is mostly retargeting or brand search may be harvesting demand other channels created.
Channel health failures usually become actions for the channel owner, logged with a date. Creative showing creative fatigueThe decline in an ad's response as the same people see it again and again. goes into the next creative brief; a bid strategy still learning after a month needs fewer changes or more conversions, not another strategy switch.
Decisions are the only group that cannot fail. If the meeting runs out of time, cut the discussion, not the decision log.
An online telescope retailer's October review
An online telescope retailer reviews its October paid media: £18,000 across search, social and a small programmatic test. The data group fails first: the analyst shows that purchase tracking was missing for four days after a checkout update, and the CRM has 41 orders the platforms never saw. The team marks those days and moves on. Spend is within budget overall, but the generic search campaign was budget-limited for most of the month while social underspent. Search's average return looks strong, yet the analyst's marginal view shows the last £1,000 of generic search spend bought far less than the first; on social, frequency in the prospecting ad set has doubled and click-through has fallen. The decisions: fix the checkout tag (developer, by the fifth), refresh social creative (designer, by mid-month), move £1,500 from social to generic search with a cap, and read the programmatic test in November when it finishes. Each decision goes in the log with its owner and date.
Common mistakes
- Starting with results. Return on spend reviewed before tracking is checked can turn a broken tag into a strategy discussion.
- Separate reviews per channel. Each channel looks good on its own platform's numbers, and the combined total claims more conversions than the business recorded.
- Treating average return as the case for more budget. The average says how the spend did; the margin says what the next pound will do.
- Changing bid strategies every month. A strategy that never leaves learning is usually being changed too often, not wrongly chosen.
- Ending without owners. Decisions without names and dates come back next month as the same discussion.
- Ignoring last month's log. The first five minutes should check that last month's decisions happened.
The cross-channel performance planning guide explains how the channels fit together, and the checklists library holds the rest of the lists.
