Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Glossary term

Make-Good

Replacement delivery a media owner provides when a booked spot, insertion or placement fails to run as agreed, offered under the order's terms.
Paid MediaconceptUpdated

Definition

A make-good (often written makegood, and usually used in the plural) is replacement delivery that a media owner provides when part of a direct booking falls short. The shortfall can take several forms: a radio or television spot that never aired, a spot that aired outside the agreed daypart, a poster site that was unavailable or posted late, a print insertion that ran in the wrong position, or creative that ran in the wrong version. The replacement is meant to give the advertiser what it paid for, in a comparable slot and within an agreed window.

The word describes a remedy, not a favour. A make-good is claimed under the terms of the booking, and the seller's own delivery evidence is the basis for the claim. That is what separates it from added value, which a seller offers during negotiation as bonus inventory on top of the paid schedule.

Where make-good terms are written and what they cover

Make-good terms belong in the order before anyone signs it. The guide to buying out-of-home advertising lists them among the booking terms to settle with the site owner: what happens if a site is unavailable, posted late or showing the wrong copy, whether the remedy is a replacement or a credit, and the window in which a replacement must run. The guide to planning a first television campaign asks the same question of a broadcaster before the first booking: what happens on under-delivery, how long the make-good window is and whether the buyer has the right to a credit instead.

A complete clause usually answers a short set of questions. What counts as under-delivery (missed, moved, misplaced or wrong copy)? What evidence will settle it? How soon must the replacement run, and in what kind of slot? And when may the buyer refuse the replacement and take money back?

In practice: claiming from the seller's own evidence

Claims rest on what the media owner supplies to prove delivery: station logs for radio, proof of posting or play for posters and screens, tear sheets for print, spot-level reports for broadcast. The guide to buying radio advertising reconciles the station's log line by line against the schedule and the invoice, then claims make-goods or credits for spots that were missed, moved outside their daypart or run with the wrong script, and it does this while the campaign is still running, because a replacement that arrives after the flight is over buys little.

Wrong-copy claims depend on the advertiser's own paperwork. The tutorial on delivering creative and copy instructions to media owners files the instructions, confirmations and first-appearance checks for each media owner, and that file is what supports a make-good when the wrong execution ran. Afterwards, make-goods change what a line actually cost and delivered, which is why the guide to keeping a media cost history records them in the conditions of each row and uses reconciled delivery rather than first reports.

Make-good or credit: when a replacement is worth less

A replacement is not automatically as good as the original. Many campaigns are timed around a season, a launch date, a sale period or a planned burst in the Flighting pattern, and the same airtime weeks later may reach people after the moment that mattered. A replacement offered in a weaker daypart or a less visible site is also not like for like. When the replacement cannot match the original in timing or quality, a credit against the invoice, or against a future booking, is often the better choice, and an order that names the buyer's right to choose makes that choice easy rather than a negotiation.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A summerhouse maker takes the credit instead

Grilkeld Summerhouses booked a six-week radio schedule of 84 spots to cover its spring selling season, with an order that allowed make-goods within two weeks of a missed spot or a credit at the buyer's choice. In week five a station outage took out 11 drive-time spots. The station's log, checked at the weekly review, showed the gap the same week. The station offered replacements in weeks seven and eight, after the schedule's end and after enquiries for spring installation usually tail off. The marketing manager judged that airtime that late would be worth less than the original spots, took the credit of £1,320 against the invoice, and noted the outage and the credit in the media cost history.

A make-good is written into the Insertion Order, the contract that records what will run and what the seller owes if it does not. It is claimed from the Media Owner, the business that sells the airtime, space or impressions and supplies the evidence of delivery. And its value depends on the Flighting of the campaign: a replacement that falls outside the planned burst or season may not be worth having.

Common confusions

  • A make-good is the same as added value. Added value is bonus inventory agreed in negotiation; a make-good replaces paid delivery that fell short and is claimed under the order's terms.
  • Make-goods can be agreed after the problem appears. Without a clause written in beforehand, the remedy becomes a negotiation at the moment the buyer has least leverage.
  • Any replacement is a fair replacement. A slot in a weaker daypart, a less visible site or a week after the season is not like for like; the order should define a comparable slot.
  • The final invoice settles what ran. Delivery is checked against the seller's evidence and the schedule, and make-goods are claimed while the campaign can still use them.
  • A make-good always beats a credit. When timing is the point of the booking, money back can be worth more than airtime that arrives late.

More terms to look up

Where this term is used

Related