Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Media Planning & Buying › Media Buying

Hiring and Evaluating a Media Planning and Buying Agency

Choosing a media agency: what stays in your name, written questions on trading status, rebates and audit access, a plan test and reports you can check.
Guideintermediate18 min readUpdated

What a media agency is hired to do

Planning decides which people the money should reach, how many times, through which media and over what period. Buying converts each line of the signed plan into a booking, at a price and on terms agreed beforehand. An agency can be hired for either job or both, for some media or all of them, and for one buying route or several: direct with media owners, through the agency's own trading, through programmatic deals or by self-serve inside a platform. Decide which of these is wanted before any agency is asked to propose. A proposal that plans and buys across all the media and one that buys television alone cannot be compared, and a request for "media" with no remit gets answers to different questions.

The money is what separates a media agency from other agencies. Most of the sums it handles are not its fee. It places the advertiser's budget with outside parties under contracts the advertiser may not see, and the value of the result depends on prices and conditions negotiated by the agency and the seller. That is why the agreement guide gives media terms of their own, and why a business choosing an agency should put the same points to each candidate in writing before any contract exists.

The general process for an appointment, from the long list and the shared request to the scope and the exit, is laid out in the agency selection and review guide. Its companion hiring guides for search, social, email and other specialisms each add what is particular to that work, and this one does the same for planning and buying media. Fee levels, commission rates and legal terms are not covered here; the contract is a matter for the business's legal advisers.

Choosing the agency is one decision inside the wider buying cycle that the media buying hub sets out, from routes and pricing models to negotiation, orders and delivery.

Dividing the work between agency and business

The sorting rule comes from the in-house and agency comparison: keep strategy, brand, data and measurement in the business, and buy in specialist depth, flexible scale and buying relationships from an agency. It names media buying as a place where agencies hold relationships and tools across clients, and the media buying hub observes that many advertisers run platform buying in-house and send television or out-of-home buys to an agency. The table applies that rule to a media plan, and a row that no site guide settles is general practice.

WorkWhat an agency can offerWhat the business holds on to
The objective and the briefA challenge to the brief and an argument for a different mixThe business problem, the media objective, the budget and what it covers, written as the brief the agency plans from
The planAudience sources, planning tools, combined reach estimates and the line-by-line scheduleThe approval, given by someone with authority over the money, after a review of the reach claim and the cost assumptions
Buying television, radio, press and outdoorTrading relationships and pooled volume, negotiation, orders and make-goodsThe order's terms read before commitment, the cancellation terms and the proof of what ran
Platform buying in search, social and retail mediaSet-up and optimisation where the business lacks the depthThe account and the decision to move budget
Programmatic buyingPlatform operation, deals and ad servingThe ad server, its history and the audience lists
Delivery evidenceChasing shortfalls, reconciling invoices, preparing reportsAn independent counting source, access to the raw data and the files of proof
The recordLine-level costs and delivery supplied after each campaignThe cost history, the frozen baselines, the signed orders and the post-campaign analyses

Record the split in a RACI matrix, one row to a decision from the brief through to approving invoices, and a single role accountable for each row. As general practice, give the accountable role to a named person in the business even where the agency does the work, so that when an approval, a cancellation or a credit is disputed nobody is left guessing who decides. Whoever holds those roles still has to judge work they cannot do themselves. The page on managing specialists whose work you cannot do suggests judging results by the business's own records, asking for the reasoning behind a proposal and the options set aside, and borrowing a written standard. Where a creative agency also works on the account, the join between creative and media (formats, sizes, durations, versions and delivery dates) needs one owner, and the guide to coordinating several agencies shows how.

What stays in the business's name

The agreement guide wants the first four items in the table below in the advertiser's own name, or else with full export and transfer rights. For the ad server and verification accounts the reason is evidence: an independent view is worth having because the party under check should not hold all of the evidence. The table lists what to put in the request for proposals and what each candidate is given; the last column is general practice, built on that rule.

ItemReason to keep it in the business's nameWhat the agency receives
Platform accounts for search, social and retail mediaThey hold the spend history, the audiences and the structure the account has builtAccess to build and change campaigns within the limits set in the scope, with spend visible to the business
The ad server and verification accountsThey count delivery independently of the sellers and the agencyAccess to configure and to read, with raw data available to the business
The programmatic seat, or the business's data and reporting inside itThe history and the audience lists would otherwise leave with the agencyAccess to the extent the agreed work needs
Audience lists and first-party dataInformation handed over for one job is not free for anotherUse for the purposes the agreement names
The plans, orders and proofThey are the record of what was bought and what ranWorking copies, while the business holds the masters in its own storage
The cost historyIt is the business's own evidence for the next plan and negotiationA duty to supply line-level costs and delivery after each campaign

The agency onboarding checklist turns this into the first weeks of a new appointment, and access set up at the start costs less effort than access recovered at the end. What each platform allows by way of ownership, access and transfer is a matter for that platform's own documentation; this guide describes no platform's account rules. As general practice, ask each candidate where it would build, and treat an agency that wants to open accounts in its own name as a candidate whose history the business would not hold.

Written questions to ask before proposals are weighed

Send each shortlisted agency one written request and the same background, drawn from the agency request for proposal template, after which the replies can be laid next to each other in the business's own layout. The questions below are the part specific to media, drawn from what the agreement guide, the negotiation guide and the auditing guide say a media relationship has to settle. Ask for plain answers.

QuestionWhat a specific answer covers
Which media and which buying routes will you handle, and which will you not?A remit by medium and route, with the work the advertiser keeps named
Do you trade as agent, as principal or both, and for which media?A status stated for each part of the buy and a rule for disclosure and approval before any move to principal trading
How are you paid, and what else do you or your group earn from our spend?The fee basis, whether media is billed gross or net, and how rebates are defined, who benefits and how they are reported
Which technology and data fees will we carry?Each fee listed and shown on its own invoice line; the buying models and pricing guide covers what sits outside a quoted rate
Do you or your group hold an interest in anything you would recommend?Disclosure before the recommendation is acted on
How is the plan's reach figure made, and how are lines combined?The audience source, an allowance for overlap, and the inputs shown on request
What needs our approval, and from whom?Plans and buys above a stated value, with approvers who match the business's spending authority, as the guide to setting spending authority covers
How do you handle make-goods, credits and cancellation?Remedies secured under the insertion order, each shortfall reported and each credit passed on, and the cancellation terms of a significant buy shared before it is committed; the negotiation guide covers make-goods and cancellation, and notes that many buyers and sellers adopt the IAB standard terms for digital media as the base contract
Which source counts delivery, and who holds the evidence?A named counting source, ad server and verification access for the business, and proof of delivery for offline lines
What will we receive, and when?Plan delivery set beside the plan, spend set beside the budget, cost per thousand for each line, make-goods and credits received, fees charged, and any rebates or incentives earned
What audit access will we have, and for how long after we part?Access to media owner invoices and contracts, and how long it lasts after exit
Which named people will staff the account, and can we meet them?The people by name, the share of their time the account gets and who covers when one of them leaves

Some of these answers can be tested before any meeting. Why an agreed counting source settles disputes, and what an audit can examine, is in the media auditing and verification guide. The agreement can ask for any of these points after appointment, but, as general practice, an agency that cannot answer them in writing while it is still pitching is telling the business something.

Warning signs in a proposal

None of the signs below proves bad faith, and each has an innocent version. Each is a reason to ask a follow-up question in writing.

  • Trading status that is unstated or "to be confirmed". The business cannot know which relationship it is buying.
  • A combined reach figure that is the sum of each medium's or platform's reach. The same people are counted more than once. The page on reach and frequency across platforms shows why a combined figure is an estimate that has to be deduplicated.
  • Rebates described as not applicable. Rebates and incentives defined narrowly, or not at all, leave an auditor little to check.
  • A fee that rises only with spend. A commission on spend rewards spending rather than effectiveness, so ask what the agency is being paid to do.
  • Cost assumptions taken from benchmarks or rate cards. A plan should start from what the business has paid, which is what the cost history tutorial builds. An assumption with no named source earns a question.
  • Verification and ad serving held only by the agency, with no access to the raw data. The party under check then holds the evidence.
  • An audit right that stops short of media owner invoices. The right is empty without the records it needs.
  • A plan that starts from channels rather than from the brief. The brief asks the planner to solve a problem, and a plan that opens with a solution has not answered it.
  • A fee set below what the agency can sustain. The agreement guide warns that the shortfall tends to be made up in ways the advertiser cannot see.
  • Senior people at the pitch and others on the account. The selecting guide asks the business to meet the team who will do the work.

Testing an agency's thinking before appointing it

A written answer shows what an agency says it does. A brief shows how it thinks. Give each shortlisted agency the same media brief, as the selecting guide asks. As general practice, write it on the pattern in the media brief tutorial: the business problem, the work the media must do, who it should reach in buyable terms, the budget and what it covers, and the dates, marking which choices are already made and which are left open. Leave the channels open, because a brief that names them asks the agency to execute a solution and removes the argument for a different mix.

Then read what comes back as an approver would read a plan, using the steps of the plan review tutorial: does each line trace to an objective and a measure, does the reach claim allow for overlap, does a cost assumption look like anything the business has paid, and what would alter the plan if it went wrong. That tutorial points out that a reviewer need not understand the agency's planning tools; where an answer depends on a tool, ask for the inputs and for what would move the output. As general practice, keep the task short, give each agency the same information and the same date, and pay for it where the task is more than a sketch. The selecting guide records that the IPA has long encouraged proportionate processes, a short list of pitching agencies and consideration of payment for speculative work.

References add one more test. Ask a referee how the agency handled a shortfall, a cancellation or a disputed invoice, rather than whether the campaign went well, because how problems are handled is what the selecting guide asks references to show.

Weighing proposals and appointing

Agree the criteria before the proposals arrive, and apply them with a weighted scoring matrix. Two kinds of criterion belong in it. Must-haves are gates, passed or failed before any scoring: for a media appointment, as general practice, a stated trading status for each part of the buy, audit access that reaches media owner invoices, and accounts opened in the business's name. An agency that fails a gate leaves the process whatever else it scores. Weighted criteria cover the rest: the quality of thinking in the response to the brief, the fit with the remit, the team, the openness of the terms, service, and the cost of the proposal on a common basis. Put fees and any technology charges into the cost per thousand with the cost per thousand calculator, so that a low media price with high fees is not mistaken for a saving.

Seat a person from the in-house team that will be working beside the agency on the panel, as the selecting guide asks, and, as general practice, someone from finance, because approvals and invoices pass through both. Agree and date the weights before the proposals are read, and record any later change with its reason. The IPA material that the agreement guide describes says fair pay gets better work than squeezing an agency, and the same guide points to negotiation that ends in a deal both sides can deliver, so treat the final round as agreeing a fair and workable arrangement, not as a last chance to take a point from the agency.

Once the choice is made, the agency scope of work template has a field for each of the services and deliverables, approvals and spending, and reporting and reviews, and covers a media agency only partly, so the agreement guide takes over for the terms the contract should carry. The scope should say whether the agency is paid a retainer, a fee for the project or another basis, and the statement of work or its equivalent should say so in terms the business can check against its invoices.

Reports the business can check

The agreement guide wants reports that rest on figures the advertiser can verify, not on the agency's own summaries alone, and the answer to the question above on what the business will receive is a sound shape for them, with cost per thousand for the target audience (CPM) the figure to recalculate line by line. Three comparisons turn that answer into a habit.

The first is against the business's own orders and invoices. Delivery and spend in the agency's report should reconcile with the insertion orders, the delivery evidence and the invoices, line by line, and the auditing guide's reconciliation section describes the three documents to compare. The second is against the business's own history: the cost per thousand in the report, recalculated on verified delivery, goes into the cost history beside earlier campaigns, where a line that looks cheap against a rate card may look different against what the business has paid. The third is against the business's own results. When an agency's report looks good and sales do not move, the troubleshooting page on strong agency reports beside flat sales separates what a report counts from what the business needs.

While a campaign runs, the weekly routine for managing a media plan gives the business a weekly delivery check by line against its frozen baseline, from the agreed counting sources.

When to judge the agency's work

Judge the work after the first campaign has run, delivery and invoices have been reconciled and the post-campaign analysis has set the result beside the plan as signed. The analysis uses reconciled figures, because delivery reports from the early weeks often change after make-goods and credits are settled. Write down in advance what the first campaign must show: delivery within the tolerances agreed, shortfalls reported and made good, credits passed on, costs on a common basis that the business can place beside its history, and reports that reconcile.

Separate what the agency controls from what it does not. Creative the business supplied after the media owner's deadline, a brief that changed in the middle of the plan and an approval that took too long are the business's share, and the selecting guide points out that some agency difficulties start on the client side. A season of buying also gives the business evidence about the media owners the agency placed it with, which the media owner review tutorial reads owner by owner. The yearly look at the relationship itself, timed ahead of the notice date, is the renewal review tutorial.

Changing agency without losing the record

The agreement guide wants the exit terms written down in advance. A business that has kept its plans, orders, proof and cost history in its own storage since the first campaign already holds much of what a handover has to move. The agency offboarding checklist works through the handover, including media commitments and insertion orders that are still running, and where the agency holds the programmatic seat, the programmatic account move guide sets out what to settle. The best time to decide how the relationship can end is before it starts, while the questions above are being answered.

A marquee hire firm appoints its first media agency (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Murkemond Marquees appoints a media agency

Murkemond Marquees, an invented marquee hire firm, plans to spend £360,000 on media over the year. An agency will buy radio, local press and roadside posters for the first time, about £240,000 of the plan, and the remaining £120,000 goes to paid search and paid social, which stay in-house. The marketing manager writes a media brief that names the problem, the audience and the dates and leaves the channels open.

Three agencies receive the brief, the same twelve written questions and a short paid task. Agency A's answers leave trading status "to be confirmed" for posters and describe rebates as not applicable. Agency B states its status and defines rebates broadly, but its plan claims a combined reach of 57% for the radio, press and poster lines, found by adding each medium's reach, and it cannot show an allowance for overlap. Agency C trades as agent for all three media, lists each technology and data fee, defines rebates to include credits and free inventory, offers audit access to media owner invoices for a stated period after exit and shows the inputs behind a more cautious reach figure.

The firm's gates are a stated trading status for each part of the buy, audit access that reaches media owner invoices and accounts in its own name. Agency A's written follow-up still leaves trading status open, so it fails the first gate and leaves the process. The remaining two pass all three gates and are scored out of 5 on weights agreed beforehand: quality of thinking 30%, fit with the remit 20%, the team 15%, openness of terms 20% and cost on a common basis 15%. Agency B scores 3, 4, 3, 4 and 3 on those criteria in that order, a weighted 3.4, and Agency C scores 4, 4, 4, 5 and 4, a weighted 4.2. Murkemond appoints Agency C on a fixed fee, records the scope in the scope of work template alongside the media terms from the agreement guide, keeps the signed plan, orders and proof in its own folder and starts a cost history with the first reconciliation. It sets the first review for after the first campaign, once it has been reconciled and compared with the frozen baseline.

Common mistakes

  • Asking for "media" with no remit. Proposals for different jobs cannot be compared. Settle the media, the routes and the work the business keeps before asking for any.
  • Putting the questions in a meeting rather than in writing. Written answers can be set side by side, as the request for proposal template intends, and a meeting leaves nothing to set beside them unless someone writes it down. Send the same written questions and keep the answers.
  • Accepting a reach figure with no working. Combined reach made by summing the reach of each medium or platform is overstated. Ask for the inputs and the overlap allowance.
  • Letting the agency set up the accounts. The ad server, verification and audience history then sits with the agency. Open each under the business's own name and give the agency access.
  • Scoring must-haves as weights. A trading status that is not stated cannot be offset by a good plan. Apply must-haves as gates before any scoring.
  • Choosing on the lowest fee. A fee that cannot be sustained tends to be recovered elsewhere, and a commission rewards spending. Compare cost on a common basis with fees included.
  • Leaving audit access for the contract stage. Asked for in the first round, audit access is part of the comparison; asked for after appointment, it is a negotiation with an agency already hired. Put it in the written questions.
  • Judging the first weeks. Early reports often change after make-goods and credits are settled. Wait for the reconciled campaign and the post-campaign analysis.
  • Keeping the record only with the agency. The cost history, the baselines and the orders are the business's evidence for the next appointment. Keep the masters in the business's own storage.

Frequently asked questions

Is the agency with the lowest fee the best choice?

Not on the fee alone. Compare what each fee covers, what the cost per thousand for the target audience comes to once fees are counted, and what the agency earns from the account besides its declared fee. The site's agreement guide warns that a fee below what the agency can sustain tends to be made up in ways the advertiser cannot see, and the selecting guide warns that a commission on spend rewards spending rather than effectiveness. Ask what each fee is for, and weigh the answer with the quality of the thinking and the openness of the terms.

Should one agency plan and buy all the media?

Only if the remit says so. The media buying hub notes that many advertisers keep platform buying in-house and pass television or out-of-home buys to an agency. The agreement guide's remit table adds that planning can be separated from buying so that advice stays apart from execution. As general practice, whatever the split, keep one plan, one measurement framework and one accountable person in the business across all of it, and name each piece of the split in the scope with an owner beside it.

When can a new media agency's work be judged fairly?

After its first campaign has run and been reconciled, and a post-campaign analysis has set the result beside the plan as signed. Early delivery reports describe a campaign in progress, and they often change after make-goods and credits are settled. Judge against the measures written down at appointment, and separate causes the agency does not control, such as creative the business supplied late or a brief that changed, from the ones it does.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Sources

  1. Institute of Practitioners in Advertising — IPA
  2. IAB — Interactive Advertising Bureau

Related