What a reviewer is checking and why the planner cannot check it alone
The building a media plan tutorial takes a planner from objectives to a signed plan, and its last step asks for explicit approval from the budget holder, the business owner and the buyer. This tutorial is written for the first two of those people. It does not repeat how a plan is built; each review step names the building step it checks.
The planner cannot review the plan alone for an ordinary reason: the plan is made of the planner's assumptions, and nobody tests their own assumptions as hard as somebody else does. An agency planner may also be working from tools, audience sources and cost tables the advertiser never sees. The reviewer brings three things the planner may lack: the brief as the business meant it, the business's own record of what media has cost and delivered, and the authority to say that a reach goal should be smaller or a line should go.
A review is not a second planning exercise. The reviewer is not choosing the channels or rewriting the schedule. The job is to find the claims in the plan that have no stated source, the lines that cannot be judged, and the places where the plan would fail quietly, and to send them back as written questions. Most plans survive a good review with a few changes; the ones that do not were not ready to buy.
Before you start
- The brief the plan answers. If the business wrote one on the pattern in the writing a media brief tutorial, have it open beside the plan. Without a brief, the review has nothing to measure the plan against except taste.
- The plan on a known template. The media plan template holds a summary, channel roles, a line-level schedule, a measurement plan and the assumptions and risks. If the plan arrives as slides alone, ask for the schedule as a spreadsheet before reviewing.
- Your own cost evidence. Previous orders, invoices and post-campaign analyses showing what each medium cost on a common basis and what it delivered, as the post-campaign analysis guide produces them.
- The objectives guide. The media objectives and reach goals guide sets out what a media objective, an audience definition and a reach goal should look like.
- The calculators. The reach and frequency calculator and the cost per thousand calculator, for re-running the plan's arithmetic.
- Time with the planner. A slot to ask questions in person after reading, and agreement that answers come back in writing.
The steps
Read the plan against the brief
Read the brief first, then the plan's summary, and compare them line by line before looking at any channel. Is the media objective the one the brief asked for, or has it drifted towards something easier to deliver? Is the audience the brief's audience? Does the budget cover what the brief said it must cover, and are committed lines shown as committed? Are the fixed dates respected? A plan that answers a slightly different question can be excellent and still be the wrong plan. Write down every difference, because some will be improvements the planner should explain and some will be misreadings.
Trace every line to an objective and a measure
This checks the building tutorial's objectives and channel roles steps. Go through the schedule and, for each line, find the objective it serves and the measure it will be judged on. A line with no measure cannot be judged after the campaign, and a line judged on the wrong measure will be cut or kept for the wrong reason. Where the plan carries a brand objective and a performance objective, check that each line belongs to one of them and is measured accordingly, as the guide to brand and performance marketing explains. Work published through the IPA, as the site's media guides report it, describes brand and activation effects building on different timescales, so a brand line measured only on short-term response is set up to fail.
Test the audience definition and its source
This checks the audience and reach goal step. Find the buying audience each line is priced against, the target audience the objective is about, and the source of the audience size. If the size has no source, ask for one, because every reach percentage in the plan is a share of that number. Then look at the breadth of the target. The Ehrenberg-Bass Institute's published work, as the objectives guide reports it, argues that brands grow mainly by reaching light and non-buyers across the whole category; a plan aimed narrowly at today's best customers may report efficient numbers while missing the people growth comes from. Ask the planner to state the gap between the buying and target audiences and the assumption made about it.
Challenge each channel's role
This checks the channel roles and mix steps. For each medium, ask what it does that no other medium in the plan does: build reach, build frequency, drive consideration, capture demand or provide a context. Two channels with the same role need a reason to coexist, and a channel with no clear role needs a reason to stay. Ask which channels were considered and dropped, and why; the template has a place for them. Use the marketing funnel to check that the plan does not crowd every line into the stage closest to purchase, and the media planning framework to check that each decision has been taken rather than assumed.
Re-run the reach and frequency check
This checks the reach and frequency step. Take one or two major lines, their budget, their cost assumption and the audience size, and run them through the reach and frequency calculator. If your result is far from the plan's, ask how the plan's figure was reached. Then look at the combined ReachUnique people who saw an ad.: if it has been found by adding each medium's or platform's reach together, it is overstated, because the same people are reached more than once. The cross-platform reach and frequency guide explains why combined totals are estimates and how they are deduplicated. Check that the FrequencyAverage times a person saw an ad. sits in the effective frequencyThe number of exposures a media plan assumes a person needs before an ad has its intended effect. range the plan set, and that the range has a stated basis.
Test the cost assumptions against your own buys
This checks the budget split step and the buyer's part of sign-off. For each line, compare the plan's cost assumption, converted to cost per thousand of the target audience (CPMCost per 1,000 impressions.), with what the business has actually paid for the same medium and audience, from its orders, invoices and post-campaign analyses. The buying models and pricing guide explains the conversion and the fees, commissions and charges that sit outside a quoted rate. An assumption far below anything the business has paid is not necessarily wrong, but it needs a reason: a negotiated deal, a different audience, a different season. This tutorial gives no benchmark ranges; the business's own record is the comparison, and where it has none, the planner's source should be named.
Check the flighting against the purchase cycle
This checks the flighting and phasing step. Lay the schedule against the business's own calendar: when people buy, when they start thinking about buying, the fixed dates in the brief, and any dark periods. Is the weight there before the decisions are made, not only on the days of purchase? Does the FlightingScheduling advertising in bursts separated by periods of little or no activity. pattern leave gaps that matter? Are the reach builders running before the demand capture lines rather than alongside them at the last minute? Ask how competitor activity was taken into account, and whether the plan addressed the loudness question with a Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. view. Work published through the IPA describes share of voice above share of market as tending to go with growth; it is a tendency, not a law, and the reviewer is checking the question was asked.
Read the measurement plan and the reserve
This checks the plan document and sign-off steps. The measurement plan should say how each objective will be reported, from which source, when, and who reads it; the measurement plan framework sets out what a complete one contains. If a line's measure depends on a study or a test, check it is budgeted and scheduled. Then find the reserve. It should be visible, not hidden inside the lines, with a stated rule for what releases it. Ask how money will move between lines during the campaign and who approves the move; the budget allocation guide covers the principle for shifting budget between channels.
List the risks and what would change the plan
Read the plan's assumptions and risks section and add to it. Which assumption, if wrong, would most damage the plan: the audience size, a cost assumption, the overlap allowance, a creative format that is not yet made, inventory that may sell out? For each major risk, ask what the planner would do if it happened and what signal would show it early. A plan with no risks listed has not been thought about hard enough. The aim is not to remove risk but to agree in advance what would cause the plan to change, so a change during the campaign is a decision rather than a scramble.
Record questions, changes and the decision
Send the questions back in one written list, numbered, with a date for answers. When the answers arrive, record which led to changes and which were accepted as explained. Then make the decision in writing: approved, approved with named changes, or returned. Attach the decision to the version of the plan that was approved, so the frozen baseline the building tutorial describes is the reviewed version. When buying later returns with a media ownerThe business that owns and sells advertising space, airtime or placements, such as a broadcaster, radio station, publisher, poster site owner or website.'s order, the insertion order sign-off checklist checks it against this signed plan.
Review questions by plan section
The table turns the steps into questions against each section of the plan template. It is a prompt for the written list, not a form to fill in.
| Plan section | Questions to ask | What a weak answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Summary | Is this the objective, audience, budget and period the brief asked for? What changed, and why? | The plan answers an easier question than the brief asked |
| Audience | What is the buying audience, the target audience, the size and its source? How broad is the target? | No source for the size; target drawn around existing customers only |
| Channel roles | What does each medium do that the others do not? What was dropped, and why? | Two lines with the same role; a line kept because it ran last year |
| Schedule | What does each line cost on a common basis, and how does that compare with what we have paid? | Cost assumptions with no source and far from the business's own record |
| Reach and frequency | How was combined reach estimated? What frequency range, on what basis? | Platform reach figures added together; frequency quoted as an average only |
| Flighting | Where is the weight relative to when people decide and buy? What happens in the gaps? | Weight concentrated on purchase days with nothing before them |
| Measurement plan | Which source reports each measure, when, and who reads it? Is any study budgeted? | Lines with no measure; a lift study mentioned but not paid for |
| Reserve | How large, held where, released by what rule and by whom? | No reserve, or one buried in the lines |
| Assumptions and risks | Which assumption matters most? What would change the plan? | No risks listed, or risks with no response |
Where the plan comes from an agency, the review of a single plan sits inside the wider relationship. The guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies covers scorecards and periodic reviews of the agency itself; a pattern of plans that fail the same review question is evidence for that conversation.
A tea subscription firm reviews its agency's spring plan (illustrative)
Marlequoy Tea reviews a spring media plan
Marlequoy Tea, an invented loose-leaf tea subscription business, receives a spring plan from its media agency for an £85,000 working budget over ten weeks. The brief asked the agency to reach 50% of adults who buy speciality tea online, at least three times, while holding cost per new subscriber near the previous spring's figure.
The head of marketing reads the plan against the brief and traces every line. Two lines, a sponsorship of an online recipe series and a set of influencer posts, have no measure in the measurement plan, so she asks what each will be judged on. The plan claims 62% reach; the agency has added the reach of online video, paid social and the recipe series together. Re-running the video line in the reach and frequency calculator and allowing for overlap, her own estimate for the combined plan is closer to 45%.
She then compares cost assumptions with Marlequoy's own records. The paid social line assumes a target cost per thousand of £3.20, while the business's last three campaigns on that platform cost between £6.80 and £8.10 per thousand target impressions on full cost. The agency explains that the figure excluded its platform fee and assumed a broader audience.
The revised plan drops the influencer posts, gives the recipe series a measure of completed views and branded search, restates the paid social cost at £7.20 per thousand, and sets the reach goal at 44% at three or more exposures, stated openly as lower than the brief asked. The head of marketing signs that version and attaches her eleven questions and the answers to it.
Common mistakes
- Reviewing the presentation, not the schedule. The slides say what the plan intends; the schedule says what will be bought. Review the schedule.
- Accepting a reach figure without asking how it was combined. Added-up platform reach overstates the plan and hides a shortfall until the post-campaign analysis.
- Judging cost assumptions by feel. Without the business's own cost record, a reviewer cannot tell a good deal from an optimistic guess. Start keeping one.
- Letting lines without a measure through. A line that cannot be judged will survive or be cut on argument rather than evidence.
- Rebuilding the plan instead of reviewing it. The reviewer's job is to test the planner's claims and send back questions, not to choose the channels.
- Asking questions out loud only. Spoken questions get spoken answers that nobody can find later. Write them down and attach the answers to the signed version.
- Signing a version nobody froze. If the approved plan is edited afterwards without a record, the post-campaign analysis compares the result with the wrong baseline.
The media planning fundamentals hub shows where the review sits between the brief and the signed plan.
