Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Checklists

Insertion Order Sign-Off Checklist

A sign-off checklist for a media insertion order: match to the plan, buying model and price, cancellation and make-goods, verification, tracking and approval.
Checklistadvanced6 min readUpdated

When to run this checklist

Run it before any insertion order or direct media contract is signed: a sponsorship with a publisher, a fixed placement on a website or in a newsletter, an audio or out-of-home booking bought direct, or a programmatic guaranteed deal whose terms are set in an order before the line items are built. Run it after the media plan is approved and the publisher has sent its order, and again whenever the publisher sends a revised version, because revisions are where terms quietly change.

The buyer, in-house or at the agency, runs the list. The budget holder is needed for the approval group, and finance should see the signed order, because finance will later reconcile invoices against it. If an agency signs on the business's behalf, the business should still see the order before signature, since the commitment is the business's money. What happens to the order after signature, from raising the purchase order to matching each invoice against it, is the tutorial on raising purchase orders and approving marketing invoices.

Auction-based buying through a demand-side platform has its own pre-flight for setup and targeting, the DV360 campaign launch checklist. This list is about the contract, not the campaign build.

Before you start

  • The approved media plan, with placements, dates, audiences and the delivery goal for each line.
  • The negotiated terms in writing: the buying model, the price unit and any added value agreed by email or on a call.
  • The publisher's order and its standard terms and conditions, including anything incorporated by reference.
  • The media objective, so the delivery goal can be checked against it.
  • The budget line the order draws from and its remaining balance.
  • The ad server and verification set-up the business uses, if it has one.

The checklist

Work through the groups in order. Matching the order to the plan comes first because every later term refers to what is being bought; approval comes last because the budget holder should sign something whose terms have already been read.

0/13

Match to the plan

Terms

Verification

Creative and tracking

Approval

Where each check is explained

The widget above keeps the lines short so they can be ticked; the reasoning lives in the guides. Each check links to the page that explains it.

CheckExplained in
Placements, dates and audiences match the approved planBuilding a media plan step by step
Buying model and price unit match the negotiationMedia buying models and pricing
Delivery goal ties back to the media objectiveMedia objectives, audiences and reach goals
Cancellation terms and notice periods readNegotiating media buys and insertion orders
Make-goods or credits agreed for under-deliveryNegotiating media buys and insertion orders
Whose ad server counts are used for billingAd serving basics
Viewability and invalid traffic standards in the orderViewability and attention metrics
Third-party verification and brand safety agreedMedia auditing and delivery verification
Creative specifications and deadlines confirmedCM360 trafficking workflow
Tracking tags and campaign parameters plannedCM360 trafficking workflow
Order total checked against the budget lineTracking marketing spend against budget
Sign-off from the budget authorityMarketing approvals and compliance reviews
Signed order filed for invoice reconciliationTracking marketing spend against budget

If an item fails

Do not sign. Every failure on this list is cheaper to fix before signature than after, and publishers expect orders to be marked up; a buyer who returns an order with changes is doing the job, not being difficult.

A mismatch with the plan goes back to the publisher with the plan attached. If the order says a different price unit from the one negotiated, for example a flat fee where a CPM was agreed, the negotiated terms in writing settle it. If the delivery goal does not tie to the objective, such as a buy priced on impressions for a plan whose objective is reach among a defined audience, the question is whether the plan or the order is wrong, and the answer may be to renegotiate rather than sign.

Missing terms are added, not assumed. If the order is silent on cancellation, ask for the notice period in writing. If it is silent on make-goods, agree what happens when delivery falls short: extra impressions, a credit, or a refund. If billing is based on the publisher's own counts with no reference to the buyer's ad server, agree which counts govern before the first invoice arrives, because that is when the disagreement otherwise starts.

Verification standards that cannot be agreed are a reason to reconsider the buy. A publisher that will not accept any viewability or invalid traffic standard, or any third-party measurement, is asking to be paid on its own word.

Creative and tracking failures can be resolved after signature if the deadlines in the order allow it, but write the creative deadline into the order now. The tutorial on delivering creative and copy instructions to media owners then works from that deadline to the material and instructions each media owner receives. Approval failures stop the signature outright: an order that exceeds its budget line needs the budget moved, or the order reduced, before anyone signs.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A sailmaker's sponsorship in a sailing website's newsletter

A sailmaker agrees an eight-week sponsorship of a sailing website's weekly newsletter plus homepage takeovers on two race weekends, negotiated at a flat £4,800. The publisher's order arrives and the buyer runs the list. Three items fail. The order prices the homepage takeovers by impressions at a £14 rate rather than as part of the flat fee; the cancellation clause allows the publisher to move race-weekend dates without notice; and billing uses the publisher's own counts. The buyer returns the order with the flat fee restored, a clause requiring a week's notice and a matching make-good for any moved date, and the sailmaker's ad server named as the source for billing on the takeovers. The publisher accepts two changes and offers a credit instead of a make-good on moved dates. The marketing director signs, and the signed order goes to finance with the budget line it draws from.

Common mistakes

  • Signing the publisher's paper unread. Standard terms incorporated by reference often carry the cancellation and billing clauses that matter most.
  • Agreeing terms on a call. Added value and price concessions agreed verbally do not exist when the invoice arrives. Put them in the order.
  • No make-good clause. Under-delivery then becomes a negotiation after the fact, when the buyer has no leverage left.
  • Billing on the seller's counts. The publisher's ad server counts what the publisher served; the buyer's counts what was delivered to the buyer's tags. Agree which governs.
  • Verification as an afterthought. Standards added after signature are requests, not terms.
  • Not filing the order with finance. Invoices then cannot be reconciled against anything, and over-billing goes unnoticed.

The guide to media auditing and delivery verification covers what happens after the order runs, and the checklists library holds the rest of the lists.

Terms used on this page

Where this page is used

Also related

Sources

  1. Media Rating Council — Media Rating Council
  2. IAB — Interactive Advertising Bureau

Related