Buying routes across media
Every line in a plan reaches the media owner by one of a handful of routes. The route is often decided by the medium, but many media can now be bought more than one way, and the choice changes what the advertiser controls and what it pays for.
| Route | How it works | Typical media | What the buyer controls | Trade-offs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct with the media owner | The buyer negotiates with the owner's sales team or sales house and signs an insertion order | Television, radio, print, out-of-home, publisher sponsorships | Placement, package, added value, terms | Time-consuming; scale depends on relationships |
| Agency trading | An agency or its trading desk buys on the advertiser's behalf, often pooling volume | Television, out-of-home, large multi-media buys | Brief and approval; the agency negotiates | Access to pooled rates and expertise; fee and transparency questions |
| Programmatic deals | Inventory is bought through software under a pre-agreed deal with a publisher | Display, online video, connected television, audio, digital out-of-home | Inventory selection, targeting, pacing | Platform fees; setup work |
| Programmatic open auction | Impressions are auctioned in real time across many sellers | Display, video, audio | Targeting and bids | Scale and efficiency against brand safety and quality risk |
| Platform self-serve | The advertiser buys inside a platform's own interface | Paid search, paid social, retail media | Targeting, bids, budgets, creative | Platform-reported measurement; auction pricing |
| Specialist and sponsorship deals | Bespoke agreements with a property, event or creator | Sponsorships, partnerships, branded content | Association and access | Hard to compare and measure |
The programmatic versus direct buying comparison weighs the two routes most often set against each other; this hub treats them as two options among several.
Pricing models in brief
Each medium has a native pricing model, and a plan made of several media will carry several models at once. Display and video are usually sold per thousand impressions (CPMCost per 1,000 impressions.). Paid search and some social buys are priced per click (CPCAverage cost of each click.). Affiliate and some performance deals are priced per action (CPACost of each conversion.). Online video may be priced per completed view. Television is traded on ratings, radio on spots, out-of-home on sites or panels over a period, print on pages or insertions, and sponsorships on a fixed fee.
None of these can be compared directly. The buyer's job is to convert every line to a common basis, usually cost per thousand of the target audience, so that a radio package and an online video buy can be judged on the same scale. The buying models and pricing guide covers the models, the difference between guaranteed and non-guaranteed buys, offline pricing conventions, the conversion to a common basis and what fees and commissions sit inside a quoted price. The cost per thousand calculator handles the arithmetic for any line. The cost history tutorial records every buy on a common basis, so the next quote is judged against what the business actually paid and got rather than a rate card.
Negotiation and insertion orders in brief
Outside the auction routes, price and terms are negotiated. The buyer briefs media owners through a request for proposal, compares the responses, negotiates on rate, placement, added value and terms, and records the agreement in an insertion order: the contract that says what will run, where, when, at what price and with what remedy if it does not.
The guarantees in that contract matter as much as the rate. A buy that promises a delivery level should say what happens on under-delivery, usually make-good inventory or a credit. A buy with tight cancellation terms leaves the advertiser exposed if plans change. The negotiation and insertion orders guide covers the request for proposal, vendor evaluation, negotiation levers, the terms worth fighting for, make-goods and cancellation, and the handover to the people who traffic the creative and reconcile the invoices.
The IAB publishes standard terms and conditions for interactive media buys that many buyers and sellers use as a starting point, which narrows the negotiation to the commercial points that genuinely differ between deals.
On direct and offline buys, the copy delivery tutorial gets the finished material and written copy instructions to every media owner on time, with confirmations and live checks.
Further guides
Further guides take the buying conventions of particular media in turn and cover the choice of agency, the agreement, the delivery and the records around a buy:
- Buying out-of-home advertising — choosing sites by audience and proximity, classic and digital formats, creative for a glance and proof of posting.
- Buying radio advertising — choosing stations and dayparts, spots and packages, frequency, writing for the ear, proof of airing and reading the result.
- Buying print and press advertising — space in newspapers, magazines and trade titles: choosing titles by readers, sizes and positions, copy deadlines, labelling and checking results.
- Planning a first television campaign — how a first-time advertiser approaches television: whether it fits, linear and connected TV, regional buys, production, buying routes and measuring effect.
- Hiring and evaluating a media agency — a guide to choosing an agency to plan and buy: how the work divides between agency and business, the accounts and records that stay in the business's name, written questions on trading status, rebates, fees and audit access, a test on the business's own brief, and reports the business can check.
- Setting up a media agency agreement — what the agreement should settle: remit, fees, agent or principal trading, rebates, approvals, audit rights, account and data ownership, and exit.
- Delivering creative and copy instructions to media owners — a tutorial for getting the right ad to every media owner on time: specification sheets, copy instructions, rotation, approvals, delivery confirmations and live checks.
- Keeping a media cost history from your own buys — a tutorial for recording every buy on a common basis so plans and negotiations start from what you paid and got, not from rate cards or borrowed benchmarks.
- Reviewing your media owners after each season — a tutorial for judging every media owner bought from on delivery against orders, make-goods, proof and invoices, price against the cost history, audience evidence and service, then deciding whom to keep, renegotiate with, re-tender or drop.
- Moving media buying to a new agency or in-house — a tutorial for changing agency, or taking buying in-house, with bookings still live: every booking and its notice date, the decision for each booking through the handover and what its media owner will allow, the records that change hands, credits and rebates owed each way, a last reconciliation, the letter to each media owner and the first weeks of delivery checks.
Where programmatic fits
Programmatic is a buying route, not a medium. It uses software to buy display, video, audio, connected televisionProgrammes and streams watched through an internet-connected television, with advertising in the breaks, usually sold on impressions rather than rating points. and digital out-of-home inventory, either in real-time auctions (RTBAuction per impression in milliseconds.) or under deals agreed in advance with particular publishers. The buyer works through a demand-side platform (DSPSoftware advertisers use to buy programmatic inventory.), sets targeting and bids, and lets the platform buy impression by impression.
For a media plan, the questions about programmatic are the same as for any route: which lines does it suit, what does it cost once fees are included, what can it guarantee, and how will delivery be verified? It tends to suit lines where audience targeting, frequency control and fast optimisation matter, and to suit less well lines where a specific placement, a sponsorship or a premium context is the point.
Everything inside the route belongs to the programmatic hub: how auctions clear, how private marketplaceAn invitation-only programmatic auction a publisher runs for selected buyers through a deal ID. and programmatic guaranteed deals are set up, and how the Google Marketing Platform tools operate. This hub takes those as given and asks only where the route fits the plan.
Agency and in-house buying
Advertisers buy media through an agency, in-house, or with a mix of the two. The choice is about skills, scale, access and accountability rather than ideology.
Agencies bring trading relationships and pooled volume with media owners, specialist teams for television and out-of-home, planning tools and audience data, and the capacity to run large multi-media buys. The questions to settle are how they are paid, whether they trade inventory as principal (buying media and reselling it) or purely as agent, how rebatesA volume-based discount or payment from media owners to an agency or large advertiser, which the agency agreement should assign and report. and volume incentives are handled, and what audit rights the advertiser holds. Industry bodies on both sides of the market publish guidance on agency remuneration and contract practice, and it is a sensible starting point for those terms. The guide to choosing and evaluating a media agency puts questions on those terms to each candidate in writing before appointment, and the media agency agreement guide works through what the agreement should settle, from remit and fees to trading status, rebates, audit rights, account and data ownership and exit.
In-house teams bring direct control, faster decisions and full visibility of data and costs. They suit advertisers whose spend sits mostly in self-serve and programmatic channels and who can hire and keep the skills. Many advertisers run a hybrid: platform buying in-house, television and out-of-home through an agency, with a single plan and a single measurement framework across both.
A homeware brand splits its buying routes
Linnetgable Home, an invented homeware brand, has a £1.2 million annual media budget. Paid search, paid social and retail media, about £650,000, are bought in-house through self-serve platforms. Connected television and out-of-home, about £450,000, go through an agency on a fee of 6% of spend, acting as agent with full audit rights. A £100,000 publisher sponsorship is negotiated directly. All three routes report into one plan, and every line is converted to cost per thousand of the target audience for the quarterly review.
Common buying problems
Most buying problems show up as a symptom in the plan, the invoice or the report. The table routes each to the guide that covers it.
| Symptom | Usual cause | Guide |
|---|---|---|
| Lines cannot be compared on cost | Each medium reported on its native pricing model | Buying models and pricing |
| The quoted rate turns out not to be the whole cost | Fees, commissions or platform charges outside the quote | Buying models and pricing |
| Under-delivery with no remedy | Insertion order without make-good terms | Negotiation and insertion orders |
| Proposals are impossible to compare | Request for proposal did not specify audience, format and pricing basis | Negotiation and insertion orders |
| Invoices do not match delivery | No reconciliation against the insertion order | Negotiation and insertion orders |
| Uncertainty over programmatic or direct | Route chosen by habit rather than by the line's role | Programmatic versus direct buying |
| Plan and buy drift apart | Buyers not given the objectives and audience definitions | Media planning and buying |
| Quotes judged against rate cards with no history | No record of what past buys cost and delivered | Keeping a media cost history |
| The wrong ad runs on a direct buy | Copy instructions missing or ambiguous; first appearance not checked | Delivering creative and copy instructions |
| Rebates or principal trading the advertiser cannot see | Agreement silent on trading status; rebates left undefined | Setting up a media agency agreement |
| An agency is appointed on its pitch, and its trading terms, rebates or audit access turn out to be unclear | Appointment without written questions on trading status, rebates, fees and audit access, and without a test on the business's own brief | Hiring and evaluating a media agency |
| The same media owner under-delivers or mis-bills season after season and is rebooked anyway | No review of media owners across campaigns; each booking judged on its quote alone | Reviewing your media owners |
| The business changes agency or takes buying in-house and bookings are still live | No list of bookings, notice dates and amounts owed; records held only by the outgoing agency | Moving media buying to a new agency or in-house |
