Definition
A reason to believe is the evidence that a brand's claim is true. The brand strategy guide lists its usual forms as product facts, process, guarantees, track record and third-party evidence, and sets one standard for all of them: each point must be specific, checkable and current. Its example makes the difference plain. "Quality" is a claim; "every batch tested twice and the results published" is proof.
The term always points at something else. A reason to believe is evidence for a particular position, promise or proposition, so it cannot be judged on its own; the question is whether it makes that claim credible to the customer the claim is aimed at.
Where it sits
Three kinds of document carry it, at different levels.
- Positioning. The guide to positioning builds the position from a segment, a category and a point of difference, and the reason to believe is what keeps the last of those from being wishful. Its evidence test is to list the proof: a short or vague list means the position is a hope.
- Brand strategy. The strategy keeps a short list of reasons to believe, each with an owner, beside the position, the promise and the boundaries. Where proof is weak, the guide says the strategy should name the product or operations work needed to create it, because advertising cannot supply credibility the product lacks.
- Briefs. A campaign brief states the one thing the audience should take away together with the reason to believe it, and the creative brief template gives reasons to believe a field of their own, noting that specific proof (a demonstration, a named guarantee, a real review) convinces more than description.
Pricing carries it too. The guide to pricing and packaging observes that the reason to believe shows in what is included at each level, and that when pricing contradicts positioning, buyers believe the pricing.
In practice
Writing reasons to believe is mostly a matter of replacing adjectives with facts. Each candidate is checked against three questions: is it specific enough to be wrong, could a customer check it, and is it still true today? The brand strategy guide adds the maintenance step most teams skip: retire any proof that has stopped being true, so that an old award or a discontinued guarantee does not keep appearing in new work.
Once a reason to believe is used in public it becomes a claim in its own right, and it needs the evidence file and approval any other claim needs. In creative work it usually becomes the proof points, while the point of difference becomes the hook.
A paint maker swaps an adjective for a test
Snorlith Paints, an invented maker of interior emulsion, briefed a campaign on the proposition "the easiest wall paint to apply". The only support in the brief was "smooth, easy formula". The creative team could not build an ad that a rival's paint could not also have run. The brand team went back to the lab notes and rewrote the reason to believe as a test customers could repeat: one 2.5-litre tin, one roller and one coat covering a 12 square metre wall with no visible streaks, filmed in a real living room in 40 minutes, and repeated by 8 trial customers who sent their own photos. The proposition stayed; the proof under it changed, and every cut of the ad now shows the same coverage test.
Related terms
Social ProofEvidence that other people have chosen, used or approved something, used to reduce a buyer's doubt. is one family of reasons to believe, the evidence that other people chose or approved something, such as reviews and ratings. SubstantiationThe evidence a business holds, before a claim is published, that the claim is true; advertising rules in most markets expect claims to be capable of it. is the evidence a business holds before any claim is published, which a reason to believe also needs once it appears in an ad. A Creative BriefA short document telling the people making creative work what it must achieve, for whom, with which message and within which limits. is where reasons to believe are handed to the people making the work. A Claims LibraryA record of every marketing claim in its exact approved wording, with the evidence behind it, the conditions and markets it is approved for and the approver. stores the approved wording of claims, proof points included, with their evidence and approver.
Common confusions
- The reason to believe is the benefit. The benefit is what the customer gets; the reason to believe is why they should accept that they will get it.
- More reasons are better. A long list of generic points is weaker than a few specific ones. The strategy guide's discipline is fewer, checkable facts with owners.
- It is a line for the copywriter. It is evidence first. If the product cannot support it, the fix is in the product or the operations, not the wording.
- Once written, it stays. Proof goes out of date. A reason to believe that is no longer true is a liability, not an asset.
