Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Meta Ads › Campaign Structure

Hiring and Evaluating a Meta Ads Agency

Choosing a Meta Ads agency or freelancer: the portfolio assets you keep, questions on creative and the Conversions API, warning signs, reports and handovers.
Guidebeginner14 min readUpdated

What a Meta Ads provider is hired to do

Whether the provider is a paid social agency, a freelance media buyer or a creative studio that also runs ads, ongoing work follows the routine the paid social account management playbook lays out: a steady flow of concepts into tests, choices about audiences and budget, patience while ad sets learn, tired ads replaced and reports on a fixed rhythm.

What the provider does with its hours has shifted. The Advantage+ audience guide explains that with that option on, the audience inputs an advertiser enters, beyond a few hard controls, act as suggestions rather than limits, and the campaign structure hub's governing principle is consolidation: fewer ad sets, each with enough budget and events to learn, rather than a tidy ad set per segment. A provider that sells clever targeting is selling a part of the job that delivery now does much of itself. The durable parts are the inputs the Meta Ads pillar names (objective, signal, creative and budget) and the discipline with which they are changed.

Some of those inputs rest on figures only the business can supply, and on Meta they steer delivery as well as reporting, because the optimisation event and the attribution setting decide what the system learns from. So the business writes down its objective, the Break-even ROAS its margin allows and the value it places on a sale or a qualified lead before a provider builds anything, and changes them only by its own decision. If it is still undecided whether to buy the work in, the case for in-house work against an agency comes first; the contract and scorecard around a Meta provider then follow the guide to choosing and reviewing any agency.

What stays in the business's portfolio

Each Meta asset the ads depend on belongs in a business portfolio, with the records around them kept in the business's own storage, and the portfolio setup tutorial builds the portfolio so that the business owns each asset and gives outsiders access to what their work needs. Ask every provider where it would build, because assets built in the provider's own portfolio have to be recovered at the end rather than simply kept.

AssetWhy it stays with the businessWhat the provider gets
The business portfolio and its adminsIt is the container every other asset depends on, and its admins decide who else gets inPartner access through the provider's own business, never a personal or shared login
The ad accountIts past results, its audiences and its settled ad sets are what make it worth keepingAccess to build and change campaigns, within agreed limits
The Facebook Page and the Instagram accountThe ads run under their names, so they stay with the business whoever manages the accountAccess to publish ads from them and, where agreed, to answer comments and messages
The datasetIts event history is what delivery has learned from; a fresh one would start emptyAccess to read events and, where agreed, to manage the server route
The verified domain and the catalogThe portfolio tutorial places both in the business's portfolio beside the datasetAccess to diagnostics, with changes agreed in advance
The payment method and the account spending limitBilling and the ceiling on total spend are finance decisionsVisibility of spend, not control of billing
Creative files, raw footage and rights recordsThe business paid for them and may need them after the provider leavesWorking copies while the engagement lasts
The naming convention, the creative report and the test logThey are the memory that lets the next person read the accountWrite access while the engagement lasts

Rights records need a check of their own. Creative made by creators carries Usage Rights that say where, for how long and in what form the business may run it, and the hooks guide's section on rights asks for that permission in writing, kept with the asset. If the provider commissions creators, check that the written permission described there covers the business's own use of the content after the provider leaves. The agency onboarding checklist then records the access granted, and a dated Access Review keeps it current as people join and leave the provider's team.

Meta questions for every shortlisted provider

QuestionWhat a specific answer covers
Who will make the ads, and who will brief them?Whether creative comes from the provider, from creators or from the business, and the person who writes the briefs
How will you structure the account, and why that number of ad sets?Consolidation as the default, with a separate ad set only for a stated reason such as a separate budget, a language or a retargeting pool
Which edits do you hold back while an ad set is learning?The edits Meta treats as significant, batched together, and large changes tried on a copy rather than in place
How much new creative will arrive, and at what pace?A pipeline of distinct concepts and hooks, briefed from evidence, with replacements ready before the current ads tire
How do you test creative?A clear line between a controlled test and several ads sharing one ad set
Which event will the campaigns optimise for?The event closest to the business outcome that the budget can feed, with the reasoning written down
Is the Conversions API in place, by which route, and who owns it?A named route, browser and server events deduplicated, and an owner on the business's side
Which attribution setting will the reports use?One setting, held, and stated on every report
Who checks ads against Meta's Advertising Standards, and who approves them?A named check by the provider and one accountable approver in the business
Which changes need our sign-off?The objective, the optimisation event and the attribution setting, because each changes what delivery learns from

The answers on structure, testing, the signal and policy can each be checked against a guide on this site. On structure and edits, the learning phase guide lists the edits Meta's documentation treats as significant, from a new optimisation event or bid strategy to changed creative and large budget moves, and the Learning Phase they restart is where an impatient provider spends the business's money. On creative testing, the creative testing guide shows that ads sharing one ad set do not make a test: delivery picks a favourite early, so a provider who calls rotation a test will declare winners that were never compared. On the signal, the guide to server events shows how events sent through the Conversions API join pixel events in the same dataset and are deduplicated by a shared event ID; a provider who cannot say which route the account uses, or who owns it, cannot vouch for the numbers it will report. On policy, the ad review and rejections guide sets out the pre-launch check and the single sign-off in the business.

The table's questions can go straight into the request for proposal template, and a weighted scoring matrix can group the answers into Meta rows such as measurement, creative supply, structure and testing, and reporting. Where the ad account and dataset will live is not one of those rows, because the matrix framework removes an option that fails a must-have whatever else it scores.

Warning signs in a Meta proposal

  • A plan to build in the provider's own portfolio. An ad account or dataset opened there sits under the provider's control, and the portfolio tutorial warns that such assets have to be moved out when the relationship ends, which is slow.
  • A new pixel or dataset as the opening move. The website migration tutorial explains that a new dataset starts with no events, so anything that relied on the old one, from ad sets to custom conversions and audiences, would have to be moved across. Replacing a working dataset needs a reason the provider can state.
  • Targeting sold as the secret. Under Advantage+ audience, as the Advantage+ audience guide sets out, included audiences and detailed targeting guide delivery rather than limit it, and delivery can expand beyond them. A pitch built on hidden interests leans on inputs delivery treats as suggestions.
  • An ad set for every segment. A plan with many small ad sets splits budget and events so thinly that each struggles to leave learning, and its tidy reports are read from ad sets that are still learning.
  • A rebuild as the first deliverable. Each new ad set starts in learning, so a proposal that opens with a new structure should name the audit finding that calls for it.
  • Rotation presented as testing. Several ads in one ad set, with the first to gather spend announced as the winner, is not evidence.
  • A thin creative plan. A plan with no stated flow of new concepts leaves nothing to replace the current ads when they wear out, whatever the targeting.
  • A target return quoted in the pitch. A target return on ad spend comes from the business's margin and its reconciled figures, and a number written before the provider has seen either has nothing behind it.
  • Reports that move their own goalposts. A window that changes between reports, view-through results counted without saying so, or modelled results presented as exact counts make the account's figures look larger or firmer than they are.

When Ads Manager keeps improving while orders stay flat, the troubleshooting page for agency reports that look strong while sales stay flat lines the agency's figure up against the business's own and then works through the causes in order.

Audit, setup, creative or management first

Price an audit, a setup or rebuild, creative production and ongoing management as separate lines, so that each can be bought, judged and ended on its own.

Piece of workWhat is handed overWhat to check before paying
Account auditThe scorecard's band and its fixes in ranked order, each with an ownerThat the dataset and server events were scored before structure
Setup or rebuildPortfolio, dataset, server route, catalog and first campaignsThat every asset was created in the business's own portfolio
Creative productionAn agreed flow of concepts, hooks and formats to brief, with files and permission records handed overThat the files and written permissions are in the business's storage
Ongoing managementReports and the change log from the routine the playbook sets out, within agreed limits on changesThat the change log dates each significant edit

Hold any audit proposal against the Meta Ads account audit scorecard and ask which of its rows the provider would leave out. Where creative production and account management go to different suppliers, the agency scope of work template gives each its own deliverables and exclusions, so that nobody assumes the other is making the ads.

Meta reports that tie back to orders

Ask for these from the start of the engagement:

  • One attribution setting, named on every report, and the same setting across any ad sets being compared. As the attribution settings guide explains, the setting shapes what delivery learns from as well as the number reported, so a change of window mid-engagement is a decision for the business, not a reporting choice.
  • Results reconciled with orders or leads for a closed period. The reconciliation tutorial compares events received with orders, checks duplicates and test orders, and turns the gap into a ratio tracked from one closed period to the next. Targets are then set on the reconciled number and carried to Meta's figure through the ratio.
  • Creative read by concept and hook. The tutorial on reporting on Meta creative labels each ad with its concept, hook and format and finishes with briefs for the next round, which is the evidence that a creative pipeline exists.
  • A dated change log. Each edit that Meta counts as significant, with its date, since each one sends the ad set back into learning and the figures after it are read in that light.
  • Return against the threshold. The ROAS calculator works out break-even ROAS from the margin beside the return itself, so the reconciled figure and the threshold sit side by side.

When Meta results can fairly be read

A result is readable only when the ad sets behind it have left learning or reached the end of its window, the period has closed with its late conversions in, and the period it is compared with used the same attribution setting and event definitions. A provider can also be blamed for things outside its control: the guide to troubleshooting performance drops separates measurement breaks, learning resets, auction shifts, Creative Fatigue, policy problems and site changes, and some of those belong to the business or the market rather than the account. Read the provider's explanation of a drop against that sequence before deciding whose fault it is.

If the work is falling short, the turnaround tutorial for an agency that is falling short sets out how to gather evidence against the scope, check the client's own share of the cause and agree a written plan, ending in a choice to continue, rescope or exit.

Changing provider without losing the account

The Meta part of a handover is an inventory: admins on the portfolio who all work for the business, the partner access on the ad account, Page, Instagram account, dataset and catalog, the creative files and rights records, the naming convention, the creative report and test log, the audience definitions and a written description of the server route with its next owner. Keep that inventory current from the start of the engagement; the agency offboarding checklist then supplies the order to work through it in.

The troubleshooting page on results that drop after an agency change shows what a change of provider can still undo inside the same account: rebuilt campaigns back in learning, tracking broken in the handover and exclusions quietly dropped. Where the outgoing provider holds the ad account or the dataset in its own business, the page on an agency that will not hand over the ad accounts covers what to export and how to recover what can be recovered.

Weighing Meta proposals for a sundial workshop (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Pruxemvald Sundials weighs three Meta proposals

Pruxemvald Sundials, an invented workshop that casts brass sundials and sells them online, runs its Meta ads from an ad account in its own portfolio at about £3,500 a month and wants outside help. Before any answer arrives the owner fixes the weights below and decides that a plan to open the ad account or dataset anywhere but the workshop's portfolio rules a proposal out; an agency, a freelance media buyer and a creative studio then receive the same written request, and every answer in a proposal that clears that rule is marked between 1 and 5.

Criterion and weightAgencyFreelance buyerCreative studio
Measurement (35%)4: audit of events and the server route first2: no plan beyond the pixela new pixel on day one
Creative supply (25%)3: four new ads a month from the workshop's photos2: reuses the current adstwelve filmed concepts a month
Structure and testing (20%)4: two ad sets, A/B test tool for concepts4: one broad ad setan ad set per interest, rotation called testing
Reporting (20%)5: one attribution setting, monthly reconciliation with orders3: platform ROAS onlyROAS under a window that changes
Weighted total (of 5)3.952.60ruled out at the gate

The studio's concepts are the best of the three, but its plan would put a new ad account and dataset in its own business, so its management proposal is ruled out before scoring. The owner asks instead whether it would make creative only, under its own scope, with the files and the creators' written permissions kept by the workshop. The agency's first piece of work is an audit, bought on its own. The audit finds 81 purchases being sent twice, once by a platform integration and once by a hand-built server route, so Events Manager receives 212 purchase events in a closed month against 131 orders, and the reported ROAS of 5.1 falls to 3.2 once reconciled, set against break-even at 2.5. In the trial that follows, the agency runs the account, the studio supplies creative under its own scope, and both are judged on reconciled orders.

The campaign structure hub gathers the portfolio, bid strategy and budget guides that any provider will be working within.

Common mistakes

  • Buying targeting instead of inputs. Objective, signal, creative and budget are the inputs the pillar names; a pitch built on audience tricks speaks to none of them.
  • Leaving creative to whoever has time. Ads in an account run well still tire as the same people see them again; price and agree the creative flow as its own deliverable.
  • A window chosen by the provider. The attribution setting shapes both delivery and the reported number, so it is the business's decision and stays fixed between reports.
  • Taking Ads Manager's column as the result. Until the reconciliation ratio is known, nobody, the provider included, knows what the account earned.
  • Forgetting the rights. Keep the written permission for creator content with the business's own files, so whoever runs the account next can see what each piece may be used for, where and until when.
  • No handover list until the handover. Put the Meta objects and records from the ownership table into the scope of work, so the ending starts from a written list rather than a search of the account.

Frequently asked questions

What should a Meta Ads agency be responsible for, and what should stay with us?

The agency runs the work: building and changing campaigns, briefing or making creative, reading results and proposing what to do next. The business keeps the business portfolio and what it holds: the ad account, the Page and Instagram profile the ads run from, the dataset, any catalog and the domain verified there, and it sets the value of each sale or lead and the return its margin needs, which the agency then works towards. The agency works through access granted to its own business, so the ad account, the dataset and their history stay in the business's portfolio whichever agency holds that access.

Should the agency make our ad creative as well as run the account?

Making ads and running the account are different jobs, so price and judge them separately even when one provider does both. Creative does a large share of the targeting on Meta, so an agency that runs the account well but supplies a trickle of new ads can stall once the existing ads wear out. Ask how many distinct concepts and hooks it will deliver, who films or designs them, and whether the files and the written permission for any creator content will stay with the business. A separate creative studio can also supply the ads under its own scope while the agency runs the account.

When can a new Meta Ads agency's results be judged fairly?

They can be judged fairly once the ad sets have left the learning phase or passed its window, the period being judged has closed with its late conversions in and the attribution setting matches the period you compare with. Read them through the ratio between Meta's figure and your reconciled orders or leads, tracked from one closed period to the next.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Sources

  1. Meta Business Help Centre — Meta Business Help Centre
  2. About the learning phase — Meta Business Help Centre
  3. About the Conversions API — Meta Business Help Centre
  4. About attribution settings — Meta Business Help Centre

Related