Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

YouTube Marketing › Channel Strategy

Hiring and Evaluating a YouTube Channel Agency

Which YouTube channel jobs to hire out, what the business keeps in its own name, what to ask an agency or freelancer and how to read the reports it sends.
Guideintermediate17 min readUpdated

What a YouTube provider is hired to do

A business channel is run through a chain of jobs. The channel strategy hub fixes the decisions made once for the whole channel, the video brief tutorial turns them into a plan for each video, filming, editing, packaging and publishing carry the plan out, and the analytics section reads what followed. Bringing in an agency, a freelancer or a production company therefore comes down to choosing which jobs leave the building. As general practice, the table below is a starting point, and it follows the in-house comparison's rule that strategy, accounts and measurement stay with the business. Posting and replies on a brand's other social accounts belong to the guide to hiring a social media agency.

JobWhat an outside provider can handleWhat remains with the business
Strategy and promiseDraft the audience, promise, pillars, formats and cadence for the owner to decide, working from the channel's own reports and the strategy document templateThe decision, the written strategy and the person who owns it; a cadence set from capacity, counting the provider's hours and the business's own
Briefs and queriesResearch searches, read the results page for each, propose a primary query and write the briefThe register of primary queries, approval of what each video promises, and the facts and people the video needs
Filming and editingScript to the brief, film and edit, and cut Shorts from long footage as the Shorts cutting tutorial walks throughKnowledge of the subject, the people and places on screen, consent from anyone shown, and the original files
Titles, thumbnails and chaptersWrite each title and thumbnail as one pair, draft descriptions and chapters, and prepare captions for the business to reviewSign-off on any claim, price or comparison, and the visual system the thumbnails follow
Publishing and the channel pageWork through the publishing checklist, tag links to the channel's convention and set up the channel pageThe link convention, the setting that declares paid promotion, and the record of sign-off
Library careAudit the back catalogue and change it in logged rounds, as the library audit tutorial lays outThe change log, the audit record and any decision to correct or replace a video
Reading and reportingPrepare the weekly review and draft the monthly note from the exports the business holdsThe goals, what each figure means, and the business's own exports and history

Drawn up as a RACI matrix, the rows above each get one accountable role, and for what the right-hand column lists, that role sits with the business. Videos bought as advertising are set up in Google Ads; the Google Ads agency hiring guide covers account ownership and access for a paid search provider, and the YouTube ads hub covers the video campaigns. Influencer marketing covers creators who publish on their own channels, and its guide to hiring an influencer agency covers hiring for that.

This page quotes no prices, names no agency or outside tool, and gives no legal advice. The site's YouTube guides do not say how a channel's roles work, what the rules on music and copyright allow, or what the platform's declaration of paid promotion asks; those questions go to the YouTube Help Centre and to whoever advises the business.

What stays in the business's name

The items below are records the site's YouTube guides rely on. As general practice, the business holds each of them itself, no matter who does the work. Draw up the list before any approach is made.

ItemWhy the business holds itWhere it is covered
The channel and who may enter it, recorded in an account registerA channel that sits under a provider's login can be lost when the contract ends; the register records who holds each access and when it is next reviewedSecuring social media accounts
The strategy document and the format sheetsWhoever comes next reads these first, and each brief and series is measured against themStrategy document template; planning a series
The briefs with their results, and the register of primary queriesTogether they show what each video was for and which search it owns, so no second video is built for a search already takenVideo briefs; the search diagnosis
The footage, project files and original exportsReframing a long video into a Short crops the image, and an already compressed copy leaves the editor less pictureCutting Shorts from long-form footage
The thumbnail files and the visual systemWith a typeface or two, a palette, framing and a fixed place for text written down, a new editor's first thumbnails already look like the channel'sThumbnails and click-through
The change log and the library audit recordThey say which video changed, in what way, when and why, so a shift in the numbers can be matched to what was doneAuditing a video library
The link convention and the tagged linksLinks tagged with UTM values show which video and which placement a visit came from, apart from the other sourcesTraffic sources; naming conventions and UTMs
The analytics access and the exportsA provider's report that holds the only copy of the results gives the business no way to test what the provider saysIn-house or agency comparison, on data and measurement
Permissions and disclosure recordsConsent to appear is recorded and limited to stated uses, paid use needs a permission of its own, and a review shows the business's tie to the productsFeaturing employees; influencer contracts and disclosure; product review videos

Each of these belongs in the written scope as a duty of the provider. The request for proposal template has a field for ownership, access and exit, and the scope of work template gives accounts, data and ownership a section of its own, with exit and handover in another. Where the provider supplies footage or graphics, the agreement should say who may use each piece, for what purpose and for how long, in the way the influencer contracts guide treats usage rights.

Where the platform gives each person separate access, a provider that must work inside the channel receives its own, granted from the business's account on the narrowest role that covers the work, and no one passes a shared login across. The securing tutorial sets this rule and, for a provider that already holds a password, puts access of the proper kind first and the password change after.

Questions for every shortlisted provider

As general practice, send each shortlisted provider the same written list and read the replies together.

Accounts and access. Which access to the channel do you need, under what role, and who on your side will hold it? Would you open a channel or a handle under your own name?

Strategy and the promise. What do you do when we ask for a video that does not suit the promise? The diagnosis for a sudden fall in views lists uploads that wander from what subscribers came for among its causes, so a provider that makes whatever it is told has shown you something. Whose hours would set the cadence?

Briefs and queries. Can we see a brief you wrote for another client, with the details removed? How do you pick a primary query, and how do you confirm that no video on our channel already owns it? What would you do when the brief wants a short talking-head video and the results page shows only long demonstrations, a case in which the video SEO hub says that kind of video does not win? Where the website aims at some of the same searches, how would you plan videos and pages together, as the tutorial that pairs videos with web pages does?

Filming, editing and the opening. Who writes the script, who films and who edits? How do you shape the opening so that it delivers what the title and thumbnail promised? The retention curves guide cuts the recap, puts any sponsor read after the first payoff and counts a greeting or a request to subscribe as a slow start. When a Short is cut from a long video, how does it make sense alone, and which video does it send viewers to? Who keeps the originals?

Titles, thumbnails and older videos. Do you write each title and thumbnail as one pair, and who checks that the pair promises only what the video delivers? How do you compare thumbnails: with YouTube's own comparison where the channel is eligible, or by swapping one and reading the result beside the impressions chart, as the thumbnails guide advises? When you change an old video, how many things change at once?

Next steps and links. What does each video offer when it ends: an end screen, a playlist, a particular next video or nothing? The diagnosis for views without subscribers explains what a video that stops at its answer costs in returning viewers.

Reviews, permissions and disclosure. If a video reviews or compares products, how is the business's connection to them said? Before someone appears on camera, how is their permission asked for and recorded?

Measurement. Who holds the exports? What does the report open with, how does it read formats and traffic sources apart, and what is each result compared with? How would you separate views that paid promotion bought?

People and continuity. Which named people would do the work, and how many other channels does each carry? Who steps in when one is away? As general practice, a freelancer is one person, so ask for a named deputy before signing. The key-person risk guide adds that cover from a supplier depends on the supplier already holding the access and the procedure.

Warning signs in a proposal

Read each item as a prompt for a more specific question, not as a verdict on the provider.

  • A promised number of views or subscribers, or a date for the channel to take off. The site's pillar for YouTube marketing says YouTube gives no timeline for traction and no promise of distribution.
  • Ranking secrets, or a best hour to publish sold as a method. The video SEO hub says YouTube describes groups of signals and not their weights, and it treats claims about keyword density, tag numbers or the hour of upload as folklore among practitioners. The audience reports guide adds that YouTube documents no effect of upload time.
  • Views and subscribers presented as results. The contribution guide accepts them as figures for running the channel but, offered to the business as results, calls them vanity metrics.
  • Targets from published figures, a blended click-through rate as the headline, or Shorts and long-form pooled. The site's guides read each video against the channel's own earlier videos of the same age and traffic source, and the Shorts and long-form comparison says that an average across both formats tells you nothing.
  • Silence about exit. Ask for the exit and handover terms that the scope of work template provides for.

Where to start: audit, briefs, a trial video or a series

Do not buy the whole programme in one go. As general practice, split the engagement into five parts, start with one, and price and judge each part on its own.

  1. A library audit. The audit tutorial is a contained piece of work: it gives each video a job, sets it beside the channel's own baseline and ends in logged rounds of change.
  2. Strategy and briefs. The provider drafts the strategy document and the first briefs, and the business decides on them and keeps them. One brief for a real video tests the provider better than a pitch does.
  3. A trial video, or Shorts cut from footage the channel already has. The test is whether packaging, opening and originals arrive on time with little rewriting.
  4. A series pilot. The series tutorial fits the first run to capacity, writes the review criteria beforehand and closes with continue, change or stop.
  5. Ongoing production and reporting. The standing work, with the exports held by the business.

Begin with whichever piece tests your biggest doubt. As general practice, the business owes the provider hours as well, for approvals and for access to people who know the subject. The weighted scoring matrix fits the choice between proposals, and its steps carry over: agree criteria and weights before any proposal is opened, write anchors for each score and run the totals again under a sceptical set of weights. If the leader does not survive, treat the result as a tie and settle it with more evidence, such as a trial on the business's own data. As general practice, make ownership of the channel, and delivery of the originals, the project files and the exports of results to the business's own storage, gates that a proposal passes or fails instead of weights.

Reports the business can check

Treat a provider's report as a set of claims, and find a record the business already holds for each one.

What the report saysHow the business can check it
What was published and changedThe channel's own list of uploads and the change log, which gives each change's video, date, old version and reason
A video did well or badlyThe business's own export from YouTube Analytics, read against the channel's earlier videos of that format, job and age, and not against figures from elsewhere
Click-through rose or fellImpressions and click-through for each traffic source. A blended rate moves with the mix, and a dip while more people are shown the video can mean it reached a wider audience, not that its packaging weakened
Search views came from the new titlesThe video's search terms list set beside its title and the register of queries, with the date of the change taken from the log
Visits and enquiries came from YouTubeThe business's own visit and enquiry records, matched to links tagged to the convention. Untagged clicks arrive as referrals or direct traffic, so the figure stays approximate
The channel moved because of the providerThe channel's views reported twice, once whole and once without its single biggest video, so that a breakout is not read as the channel's new level
The channel is worth its costA range with its limits: tagged outcomes at the lower end, customer answers and supporting signs above them, and the production cost recorded alongside

When the provider's figures improve and the business's own sales do not, begin with the diagnosis for reports that improve while sales stay put.

When the work can fairly be judged

As general practice, a fair yardstick is a record made before the provider started. So, before the provider changes anything, export the channel's videos with their traffic sources from Advanced mode, as the first step of the audit tutorial does, and store the export where the business holds it. That file is the record from which the baseline for each later reading is built.

YouTube gives no timeline for traction. The pillar's first ninety days section treats the opening months as time for learning what works, with videos compared with each other and not with outside benchmarks, so a fair review waits until the provider has published enough for a pattern to show. Put the review date in the scope. Read each change by the audit tutorial's rules: at a fixed age, against the stretch of equal length before it, as a before-and-after comparison and not a controlled test, one change at a time. Choose the indicator that suits what the channel is for before the engagement begins. If the review goes badly, the page on improving an underperforming agency is the next page to read.

Changing provider without losing the channel

The agency offboarding checklist owns the sequence for confirming ownership, collecting assets and removing access; as general practice, this page adds four points that are particular to a channel.

  1. Collect the working knowledge before the outgoing provider's access ends. The briefs and their results, the query register, the format sheets, the visual system, the originals and the change log are as much the channel as its login is.
  2. Read the outgoing provider's changes before judging the new one. Date any fall in results against the handover and the logged changes, as the diagnosis for results that fall after an agency change does, and let a series in progress reach its gate with its criteria already written.
  3. Start the newcomer from the outgoing provider's documents. With the same inputs the two can be compared.
  4. Repeat the access review that the securing tutorial ties to the start and end of an agency engagement, record the date, and use the agency onboarding checklist for the newcomer's first weeks.

Weighing proposals for a wheelwright's workshop (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Hakrufond Wheelwrights chooses help for its restoration channel

Hakrufond Wheelwrights, an invented workshop that builds and restores wooden cart wheels, runs a restoration channel whose views come mostly from search. The owner films at the bench on weekends, and a part-time assistant edits when there is time. She wants help with briefs, editing and the older videos. First she exports the channel's long-form videos and Shorts, with traffic sources, from Advanced mode and files the export with the business's records. She then sends one request, unchanged, to a regional production company, a freelance producer and a small agency, and she fixes the scoring before opening any reply. Two conditions are gates and not weights: the channel stays in the business's name, and the originals, the project files and the exports of results reach the business's own storage at stated points. The 100 points go to briefs written from the search results page (30), packaging and care of old videos (25), reports she can test (15), fit with her weekend filming (15), cover for absence (10) and clarity of scope (5).

The agency's reply keeps raw footage and project files on its own drive and hands over only the finished videos, so it fails the gate. The other two replies already meet both conditions as sent. She asks in writing whether the term can change, and the agency amends its proposal to deliver all three each month. Scores use a scale of 1 to 5, each point defined by anchors written beforehand. The agency earns 3 for briefs, 4 for packaging and old videos, 5 for reports, 4 for filming fit, 5 for cover and 3 for scope: 390 out of 500. The freelance producer earns 4, 3, 3, 5, 2 and 4: 355. The production company earns 2, 3, 2, 5, 4 and 4: 300. Her assistant thinks the agency's reports were scored generously and proposes sceptical weights: briefs 40, packaging 15, reports 10, filming fit 15, cover 10 and scope 10. Under them the agency and the freelancer both reach 370 and the production company 300, so the totals cannot separate the leaders and she treats the result as a tie.

She breaks the tie on reports she can test, the score her assistant had questioned: the agency's 5 had come from a sample report, not from her own data. Each of the two leaders receives last month's export and writes the monthly note for two videos, and she checks every sentence against it. The agency's note opens with one click-through rate for long videos and Shorts together and credits a rise in views to the channel's packaging, while the export shows the rise sitting in a single video whose views came from suggested videos. The freelancer's note reads the formats apart, says which views came from search and which from suggested, and shows the totals both with and without the one biggest video. On that evidence she lowers the agency's reports score from 5 to 2, so its totals become 345 and 340 against the freelancer's 355 and 370. She chooses the freelancer for briefs and editing, asks for a named deputy before signing, keeps the register of queries and the change log herself, and has the originals reach the business's storage each week. The freelancer receives its own access, granted from the business's account. The first review falls at the end of a four-video series, with the continue, change or stop criteria written before the first video, and the review date goes into the scope. The agency's amended proposal stays on file for later.

Common mistakes

  • Giving the promise away with the production. A provider that takes the decisions on audience, promise and cadence also sets the engagement brief it will be judged against.
  • Letting the provider open the channel. The channel is then under the provider's login, which the securing tutorial rules out.
  • Scoring before the weights are written down. The weighted scoring matrix page warns that weights drift towards the qualities a favourite happens to have.
  • Taking the provider's report at its word. Test each claim against the business's own export, format by format.
  • Forgetting the footage. Originals and project files left on a provider's drive are out of reach when the business wants them for Shorts or for the next edit.
  • Changing everything in the first round. Changing one element per video in each round, and logging it, is what makes it possible to say what worked.
  • Waiting for the outgoing provider to leave before collecting anything. The briefs, the register and the log are the channel's working knowledge, so ask for them while the provider is still reachable.

Frequently asked questions

Which parts of a YouTube channel can an agency run for us?

As general practice, a provider can research searches, draft briefs for the owner's approval, then script, film and edit to them, put each title and thumbnail together as a pair, publish by the checklist, work through the library in logged rounds and draft the monthly note from exports the business holds. The business keeps the channel and who can enter it, the strategy and the promise, the query register, the briefs with their results, the originals and project files, the change log, the link convention and the results exports. It also signs off any video that states a claim, quotes a price or makes a comparison, and holds the consent for anyone shown.

Can a YouTube agency guarantee views or subscribers?

The YouTube guides on this site report that YouTube gives no timeline for a channel to gain traction, makes no promise of distribution to any channel and describes groups of signals without giving their weights. Treat a promised figure or date as a warning sign. Ask instead what the provider will do, how each change will be logged and how results will be read against the channel's own record.

When can the work of a YouTube provider fairly be judged?

As general practice, a fair review waits until the business holds an export of the channel's results taken before the provider began and the provider has published enough for a pattern to show. Compare videos of the same format and job, read at one fixed age and on one traffic source. The site treats the early months as time spent finding out what works, and it reads a change to a live video at a fixed age against the same interval before it. Put the review date in the scope so that it is scheduled instead of argued over.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Sources

  1. YouTube Help — YouTube Help

Related