Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

YouTube Marketing › Channel Strategy

Changing a YouTube Channel's Focus

How to change what a YouTube channel is about: judge how far it moves, read who it serves now, sort the library, pilot the new subject and read the transition.
Guideintermediate16 min readUpdated

A change of focus is a decision, not drift

The diagnosis for a sudden fall in YouTube views treats a change of subject, format or tone as a fault. When recent uploads stray from what subscribers came for, the subscription and home feeds put the channel in front of its existing viewers less, and returning viewers are the first reading to fall. Its fix is to return to the core format, and its prevention habit is to run experiments as a labelled series beside the core output rather than in place of it. That advice is right when the drift was accidental. It does not help a channel whose business has moved on, where returning to the old format would mean serving viewers the business no longer needs.

The channel strategy hub anticipates this. It says the strategy is revisited rather than set once, and names the moments to revisit it: when the business starts selling something different, when the analytics reveal viewers other than the ones the channel planned for, and at a regular review against the library it has built. A change of focus is what happens when one of those reviews concludes that the promise itself has to change. The difference from drift is that it is chosen, planned, written down and read on purpose.

Three situations call for it on a business channel:

  • The business sells something else. A product line has been dropped or added, a service has replaced a product, or the business has moved from consumers to trade buyers, and the channel still talks to the old customer.
  • The audience is not the one the business needs. The channel grew around a founder's hobby, an entertaining format or one breakout subject, and the people it gathered are not the people who buy.
  • The subject has run its course. The questions the channel answered have been answered, the searches behind them have faded, or the format has stopped earning views even when it is done well.

Each of these is a reason to change the promise. None of them is a reason to change it all at once, or to abandon what the existing library and subscribers still do for the business.

Sharpen, stretch or move: how far the channel is changing

The guide to refreshing a positioning separates three degrees of change for a brand, and they apply to a channel's promise with little adjustment. The degree decides how much of the library still serves, how much of the existing audience is likely to come along and how carefully the change has to be staged.

DegreeWhat it means for a channelWhat the existing library doesWho comes alongHow carefully to stage it
SharpenThe same subject for a narrower viewer or a more specific jobStill fits; packaging and channel page changeThe existing audience, because the promise still covers themLightly: a new promise line, a new trailer, a revised set of sections
StretchThe subject extends to an adjacent viewer or need the business now servesThe core still fits and becomes one Content Pillar of severalThe core audience, if the new pillar sits beside the old one rather than replacing itWith a pilot series and the old pillar kept running, at a rhythm decided before the run
MoveA different subject, viewer or kind of videoLittle fits the new promise, though it may still earn search viewsPlan as if the existing subscribers will not follow; the refresh guide names losing existing buyers before new ones arrive as the riskAs a one-way decision, piloted before the channel page or name changes

Place the change honestly. A move described as a stretch is a costly mistake, because the plan counts on an audience that may not follow. A useful test is to write the old promise and the proposed new one side by side, using the positioning statement framework for both, and ask whether a viewer who subscribed for the first would recognise themselves in the second. If they would, the change is a sharpen or a stretch. If they would not, it is a move.

A move is costly to reverse. The framework of one-way and two-way doors treats changes that reset what customers expect as decisions that deserve a test or a pilot before full commitment, and it offers two ways of making such a door smaller that suit a channel well: run the old and the new side by side for a period, and change the inside before the outside. On YouTube the inside is the videos; the outside is the banner, the about section, the trailer and the name.

Refocus the channel or open another

Before refocusing an existing channel, decide whether the new subject belongs on it at all. The guide to structuring social accounts treats one account per platform as the default and opens a separate account only when a different audience, language or offer calls for it, someone is available to run it and there is material to fill it. The same questions settle a YouTube channel.

The case for refocusing the existing channel is everything it already has: a library that still answers searches, subscribers who may follow part of the way and a channel page visitors already find. The case for a second channel is an audience Segmentation sharp enough that the two groups would get in each other's way: a trade audience that would be put off by consumer videos, or viewers in a second language who would be offered videos they cannot follow. A second channel also doubles the work, and the strategy hub's rule of setting cadence from what the team can sustain then has to hold for each channel separately.

Where the old subject still earns views and the business has no use for them, the choice is not between the two channels but between keeping the old library live under the new promise and setting it aside. The library section below handles that.

What the audience reports say about who the channel serves now

A refocus should start from the audience the channel actually has, not the one the team remembers. The guide to reading YouTube audience reports sets out what each report can and cannot answer, and four readings matter here.

Returning and new viewers, by format and pillar. Split the views by format and pillar before reading returning against new. A pillar whose views come from returning viewers is the part of the channel the current subscribers value; a pillar whose views come from new viewers is doing the reach work. The refocus will cost the first group something and may not touch the second at all.

Where the views come from. The traffic sources guide ties browse features and notifications to the relationship with existing viewers and YouTube search to the words in titles and descriptions. A pillar that lives on browse and notifications depends on its subscribers; a pillar that lives on search depends on what people type, and the guide describes a channel built on search as steady and resilient to a single weak upload.

Which channels the audience also watches. The other-channels report places the channel among its neighbours as viewers see them. If the neighbours sit squarely in the old subject, the existing audience is a different group from the one the business now wants, which is evidence that the change is a move rather than a stretch.

Geography and broad demographics, as a check. Read them only to test an assumption, as the audience guide advises, and never as a description of individuals.

Treat each group the reports reveal as a Cohort to follow through the change: the returning viewers of the old pillar, the new viewers arriving from search and the subscribers gained in the latest periods. Write down the readings with their dates. They are the Baseline the transition is judged against, and without them nobody will be able to say later what the change cost or gained.

Sorting the library against the new promise

The existing library does not have to change with the promise, but each video needs a decision. The library audit tutorial already gives each video a job and a set of checks; for a refocus, add a column for its fit with the new promise and sort the library into four groups.

GroupWhich videosWhat happens to themWhat not to do
Carries the new promiseVideos that already serve the new viewer or subjectLead the new channel page sections; packaging revised in logged roundsLeave them buried among the old pillar's videos
Bridges the twoVideos that serve both audiences, or could with a new title or a closing lineA playlist that takes an old viewer towards the new subjectRetitle them so far that the old audience no longer finds them
Still earns, no longer leadsVideos on the old subject that still bring search or suggested viewsKept public, kept in their own playlists, moved off the sections that introduce the channelDelete them, cutting off the links, playlists and end screens aimed at them
Out of date or wrongVideos about products, prices or offers the business no longer hasA correction under the description's opening lines and in a pinned comment, a pointer to a newer video, or a replacement on the production planLeave them leading the old playlists unchanged

The bridging playlist in the second row is general practice rather than something the site's guides set out.

The groups are not a ranking. A video in the third group may have the largest view count on the channel, and keeping it live lets it go on answering the searches that bring it views. What changes is its place on the channel page and in the playlists a newcomer sees first. The channel page tutorial already leaves out of the page's sections the videos that no longer represent the channel; the sort above decides which those are.

Keep the sort in the same record as the audit, with the date and the reason for each decision. The library will be read against it again at the next review.

Piloting the new subject as a labelled series

Change the inside before the outside. For a stretch or a move, before the banner, the about section or the trailer says anything new, make a first run of videos in the new subject and publish them as a named series beside the channel's existing output. This is the shape the views-dropped diagnosis gives experiments, as the opening section describes. For a refocus it does two jobs at once. It tests whether the channel can earn views for the new subject, and it tells existing viewers, in the videos themselves, what the channel is adding.

The series planning tutorial covers the mechanics: choosing the format from evidence, writing the series promise inside the channel's promise, the format sheet, a title marker and thumbnail template, a playlist and a first run sized to what the team can make. The series tutorial already writes the gate criteria before the run; for a new focus, name in them the readings from the audience reports that would count as the new subject working. As general practice, also decide in advance what happens to the old output during the run, whether it continues at its usual rhythm or a slower one, so that a fall in the old pillar's views is expected rather than a surprise.

Brief every episode with the YouTube video brief tutorial, recording the job, the viewer and the primary query or feed idea. Where an episode can serve both audiences, say so in the opening and the close; a viewer who came for the old subject should hear why the new one is relevant to them, and a viewer who came for the new one should not need the old videos to follow.

Record the decision to pilot, its expected effect and the conditions for continuing in a Decision Log. The marketing decision log template asks for the reversibility of each decision as well as the evidence, which is where a move is marked as the one-way door it is.

Changing the channel page, and the name only if it must

When the pilot passes its gate, or, for a sharpen, once the new promise is written, change the outside. Work through the channel page tutorial's steps with the new promise: the promise line in the banner and the opening of the about section, a trailer that introduces the refocused channel to someone arriving for the first time, a featured video for subscribers that bridges from the old subject to the new, and sections ordered so that a visitor meets the new promise first and the old pillar's playlists further down. The sort from the library section decides which playlists lead.

Tell the existing audience in the videos rather than by surprise. As general practice, a short explanation at the start of the first episodes after the change, and a closing line on the bridging videos, does more than a banner, because returning viewers meet new uploads in their feeds and notifications, the sources the traffic source readings above tie to existing viewers.

Change the name or handle only if the old one works against the new promise; the channel strategy hub wants the promise recognisable in the name or handle as well as the banner, about section and trailer, so where the name stays, those three carry the new promise. A new name is a rebrand rather than a refocus, and the tutorial on rolling out a rebrand across digital channels sequences it across every profile the business runs, from reserving handles to the searches that keep using the old name. YouTube Help is the record for what a name or handle change involves on the platform itself; this page does not restate it.

Update the written strategy at the same time. The YouTube channel strategy document template holds the viewer, the promise, the pillars and the review dates; a refocus changes all of them, and a strategy document that still describes the old channel can end up briefing the next video.

Reading the transition

A refocus is read on two sets of readings at once: what the channel is losing from the old audience and what it is gaining from the new one. Read both against the baseline recorded before the pilot, at a fixed age per video, and by format and pillar rather than as one channel total.

What the old audience does. Returning viewers on the old pillar, views from browse features and notifications, and subscribers gained on the old pillar's videos. Some fall is the expected price of a stretch or a move; the question is whether it stays within what the plan assumed. A fall that spreads to the pillars the business meant to keep is a reason to read those pillars by format against the baseline before the change goes further.

What the new subject earns. New viewers on the new series, views from search for its primary queries, subscribers gained per view on its episodes against the old pillar's, and, where the new focus exists to send viewers to the business, tagged visits to the pages the series points to, read as the guide on measuring what a YouTube channel contributes sets out.

What the business set the change up to do. The channel's lead KPI should change with its promise, and the new one is the measure the refocus answers to. A channel that has moved from entertaining hobbyists to helping buyers choose equipment should no longer be judged on total views.

Where counts are small, as the audience guide warns they can be on a business channel, the guide to reading small numbers applies: read only large movements, and resist calling the change a success or a failure on a short run of weeks. Log the dates the pilot started and the channel page changed in the same change record the library audit keeps, so that a step in the readings can be traced to its cause. The diagnosis for views without subscribers adds one habit worth carrying over: ask, in every brief after the change, which part of the new promise the video serves.

A lapidary supplier refocuses its channel (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Eblokrath Lapidary moves its channel from trips to workshop

Eblokrath Lapidary, an invented supplier of rock tumblers, cabbing machines and polishing supplies, built its channel over six years on the founder's rock-hunting trip diaries. The library holds 186 long-form videos: 131 trip diaries, 38 equipment how-tos and 17 unboxings of stone lots the business no longer sells. Equipment now brings in most of the revenue, and the owner wants the channel to serve people cutting and polishing stones at home.

The audience and traffic source reports for the last quarter show trip diaries taking 71% of long-form views, 68% of those from returning viewers and arriving mainly through browse features and notifications. The how-tos take 22% of views, 81% from new viewers and mostly from search. The other-channels report lists travel and rock-hunting channels, not workshop channels. The marketing lead places the change as a stretch for the how-to viewers and a move for the diary audience, and records the baseline.

The library sort puts the 38 how-tos in the first group, 24 diaries that end with stones being polished in the second, 107 diaries in the third and the 17 unboxings in the fourth, each corrected under the description's opening lines and in a pinned comment pointing to the current range. The pilot is an 8-episode series, "First Polish", published fortnightly for 16 weeks beside monthly diaries, with gate criteria written in advance: episodes averaging at or above the channel's 28-day baseline of 2,900 views, at least half of their views from new viewers, more subscribers gained per thousand views than the diaries, and tagged visits to equipment pages at least double the diaries' total over the same weeks.

At the gate the episodes average 3,400 views at 28 days, 74% from new viewers and 46% from search, with 4.1 subscribers gained per thousand views against 2.2 on diaries, and 610 tagged visits against 90 from the diaries over the same weeks. Returning viewers on the diaries fall from 68% to 61% of their views. The owner logs the decision to proceed, rebuilds the channel page around a new trailer and a "Start polishing here" section, keeps the diaries playlist lower on the page, leaves the name unchanged and moves the channel's lead measure from views to tagged visits to equipment pages. Six months later channel views are 8% below the same period a year earlier and tagged visits to the equipment pages, now the lead measure, are above the baseline recorded before the pilot.

The numbers above are invented. The part to reuse is the sequence: read the audience reports, place the change honestly, record the baseline, sort the library rather than delete it and, for a stretch or a move, pilot the new subject as a labelled series with criteria written in advance and change the channel page only after the gate; then judge the result on the measure the new promise answers to.

Common mistakes

  • Treating a move as a stretch. A plan that assumes the old audience will follow a different subject is built on viewers who may not arrive; write both promises side by side and place the change honestly.
  • Changing the banner before the videos. A new channel page with nothing behind it promises what the channel cannot yet show; for a stretch or a move, pilot the subject first and change the outside after the gate.
  • Switching the whole output at once. Replacing the old pillar overnight costs its returning viewers before the new subject has an audience; run the two side by side for a period.
  • Deleting the old library. Videos on the old subject may still answer searches, and removing them breaks the links and playlists that point to them; move them off the introductory sections instead.
  • Opening a second channel by default. A new channel starts with no library or subscribers and doubles the work; open one only when the audiences genuinely differ and the team can fill both.
  • Judging the change on total views. A refocus away from an entertaining format can lower views while raising what the business needs; move the lead measure with the promise.
  • No baseline and no record. Without the readings taken before the pilot and the dates of each change, nobody can say what the refocus cost or gained.

The YouTube channel strategy hub sets this change beside the channel's other decisions: the audience, the promise, the pillars, the cadence and the split between Shorts and long-form.

Frequently asked questions

Will changing what my channel is about lose subscribers?

Expect some of the people who subscribed for the old subject to watch less. The site's YouTube guides explain why: viewers subscribe to an expectation, and when uploads change subject the subscription and home feeds offer the channel's videos to its existing viewers less readily, with returning viewers the first reading to fall. A planned change aims to keep that cost in proportion by piloting the new subject as a labelled series beside the old output and reading returning viewers by format rather than as one channel total.

Should I start a new channel instead of changing the existing one?

Only when the new subject serves a genuinely different audience that would not follow the existing channel, and when the team can staff and fill a second channel without starving the first. The site's guide to structuring social accounts treats one account per platform as the default and asks whether the audience, language or offer differs, whether someone can staff the account and whether it has enough to say. If the old and new viewers overlap, or the second channel would repeat much of the first, refocusing the existing channel keeps its library and its subscribers, some of whom may follow the new subject.

How do I tell subscribers that the channel is changing?

In the videos rather than only on the banner. As general practice, say what is changing in the opening and close of the first episodes after the change and on the videos that bridge the old subject and the new, because the site's traffic sources guide ties feeds and notifications to the channel's existing viewers. Explain why the new subject matters to the people who came for the old one, keep the old playlists available so nobody loses what they subscribed for, and afterwards read returning viewers by format to see who stayed with the channel.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Sources

  1. YouTube Help — YouTube Help

Related