Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Social Media Marketing › Social Media Strategy

Hiring and Evaluating a Social Media Agency

How to choose and judge a social media agency or freelancer: what to outsource, the accounts and records you keep, questions, warning signs and reports.
Guideintermediate18 min readUpdated

What a social media provider is hired to do

The strategy hub splits social work into three jobs that, in a small team, are one person: an owner who holds the strategy and the calendar and writes the monthly report, a producer for the content and a community manager for replies. Where an agency or freelancer comes in, the owner role and the inbox stay with the brand. The in-house or agency comparison gives the reasoning from the other side: continuous, knowledge-heavy work, such as talking to customers, tends to suit the business; the party whose work a measure judges should not keep the measure; and agencies win on specialist depth, extra capacity at busy times and creative range. As general practice, organic social has both kinds of work in it, so the useful question is not whether to hire but which jobs to hire out.

As general practice, the split below is a starting point built on the strategy hub's owner-and-inbox rule: the provider supplies the middle column, and everything in the right-hand column is decided, sent or held by the brand.

JobWhat the provider can doWhat stays with the brand
Strategy and platform choiceAudit the presence, propose a role and a goal for each platform, score the candidates on the criteria in the choosing platforms guideThe decision, the goal for each platform and the owner role
Voice and cadenceDraft voice principles for the brand to approve; write in the brand voice once the guide existsThe voice guide and its owner; the cadence, set from the hours for production, replies and reporting with the inbox subtracted first, the brand's own hours counted with the provider's
ProductionPlan, write, design, film and edit; fill the calendar's slots; write image descriptions and captionsSubject knowledge, access to people and places, the permission for anyone shown, and any decision to use content in ads
PublishingSchedule approved posts from the calendar by the agreed routeThe approval levels, and who approves anything that makes a claim, names a price or involves a partner
Replies and moderationDraft replies from the answers the brand has approved, suggest moderation actions under the published rules, log what it drafted and suggested, and flag cases for escalationThe inbox owner, who sends the replies and hides or removes comments, the response standard, the published rules, complaints, sales enquiries and anything that meets the crisis plan's triggers
Reporting and listeningTag posts and draft the insight note for the owner's monthly report from the export the brand holdsThe goals, the definitions, the history of results and the export
Crisis supportSupply hands: pause the queue, watch the conversation, draft statementsThe decision that it is a crisis, who speaks and who approves the statement

A RACI matrix written for these rows settles the argument before it starts. Each row gets exactly one accountable role, and for every row in the table's right-hand column that role is the brand's.

Two neighbouring engagements have guides of their own. Paid social is bought through the ad platforms and raises different questions, which the guide to hiring a Meta Ads agency covers. Creators and influencer programmes belong to the influencer marketing root. This guide is for organic posting, community and reporting on the brand's own accounts.

As general practice, the split that follows from the owner-and-inbox rule, and from keeping measurement with the side the measure does not judge, puts production and scheduling outside and the inbox and the measures inside. A brand that wants help with replies, for evenings or a busy launch, can ask the provider to draft from approved answers and to log what it drafted, while the brand's own inbox owner sends. Passing cases to an outside team is the arrangement the outsourced support team guide describes for service work: answers written down, authority defined, data scoped and the work judged on measures the business keeps. In that guide's table the business's own community owner keeps the public social inbox, and an outside team is handed only the cases passed over in private.

This guide gives no fees, day rates or retainer sizes, names no agency or tool, and is not legal or employment advice. Contract terms and data protection questions belong with the business's own advisers. For a business channel on YouTube, where the work is video planning, filming and packaging and care of a library, see the guide to hiring and evaluating a YouTube channel agency. For paid advertising on TikTok, the guide to hiring and evaluating a TikTok Ads agency covers which jobs to hand to a provider, what the business keeps, the questions on creative and Spark Ads codes and the reports to check against its own record.

What stays in the brand's name

Each item below is something the site's guides already ask a brand to hold, whoever does the work. List them before hiring, because the general agency guide asks for accounts, data and assets to stay in the business's name from the outset. The securing tutorial's handover step lists what an account runs on at the end of an engagement; this table lists the items at the start, with why each matters in a provider conversation.

WhatWhyWhere it is set up
The accounts and their administrationA provider's own login is one contract end from a lock-outSecuring social media accounts
The account registerIt shows who holds which access, with a review dateThe same tutorial
The voice guideA new provider reads it first and drafts are reviewed against itBrand voice and posting cadence
The calendar and everything scheduledA scheduled post is the brand's published wordBuilding a social content calendar
The approval levels and the record of approvalsThe brand decides which posts carry claims, prices or partnershipsSetting up a social media approval workflow
The moderation log and open conversationsThey show how the brand treated people in public and which cases were promised an answerCommunity management
Permissions for customers and colleagues shownThey were given to the brand for stated uses; usage rights for paid use are a separate, broader requestUser-generated content, Featuring employees
The export and the history of resultsResults held only in a vendor's dashboard leave the brand nothing to judge the provider againstSocial media reporting

Put these into the scope of work as obligations, not into a promise made in a pitch. The scope of work template has sections for accounts, data and ownership and for exit and handover, and the request for proposal template asks every supplier about data, access and ownership. Both leave the wording to the business and its advisers. The staff social media policy already covers agencies and freelancers given access to the official accounts, and is part of briefing them.

Where a platform allows people their own access, the provider gets its own, granted from the business's accounts, and nobody hands over a shared login. The securing tutorial notes, from the site's business portfolio guide and Meta's Business Help Centre, that on Meta an agency is added as a partner through its own business, so the pages and accounts stay in the brand's portfolio. Where a provider already holds a password, the tutorial's order is proper access first and the password change after, so the work is not interrupted.

Questions for every shortlisted provider

Put the questions in writing and compare the answers side by side. A provider that answers in generalities about engagement has told you less than one that says who will do each job and what it will need from you.

Accounts and access. Which of our accounts will you need, and through what access? Will you create any account, handle or page in your own name for us? Who at your end will hold access, and what happens to it when they move to another client?

Voice. How will you learn our voice, and what will you do when the voice guide does not cover a situation? Show a draft that breaks one of our principles and the comment you would expect from us. Who drafts replies, and what do they do when they are unsure?

Replies and drafting. Who drafts the replies, and how quickly will a draft reach our inbox owner? What happens outside the brand's own hours: does a draft wait, or does the case go on the escalation route? How would you draft a reply to a complaint, a sales enquiry, a creator asking for free product, and a message that mentions safety or personal data? Which approved answers will you draft from, who changes them, and which response standards will you accept being reported against? The inbox triage SOP is the routine the brand's own inbox owner follows.

Approvals. Which posts do you expect us to approve, how quickly can we do it, and how do reactive posts get approved on the day? What lead time does a filmed piece need? The approval workflow tutorial's fast lane for replies and reactive posts shows what a workable answer looks like.

Production. Who makes the content, who appears in it and how will you get material from our people? How are image descriptions and captions written, and by whom? What goes into your briefs for creators and freelancers? The guide to accessible social media posts lists what a brief should ask for.

Permissions and disclosure. How do you ask a customer for permission to repost, where is the answer recorded, and how is paid use kept separate? How do you label posts by hosts and creators who receive payment or product? The takeover guide and the guide to influencer contracts and disclosure set out how the site treats disclosure when a host or creator is paid or given product.

Measurement. What will the report lead with, which goal metric will each platform be read on, and against what comparison? Who keeps the exports? Can we see a past report, with its decisions, and what changed as a result?

Crisis. Are you named in our crisis plan? Who on your side can pause the queue on a Saturday evening, and do they have the access to do it? Who joins our escalation route?

People and continuity. Who will do the work, how many other accounts do they carry and who covers when they are away? For a freelancer, who is one person, that last question applies directly, and the key-person risk guide notes that a supplier can provide cover but is only useful in an emergency if it holds the procedure and the access.

Warning signs in a proposal

None of these is proof of a poor provider. Each is a place to press until the answer is specific.

  • A shared password, or an account to be opened under the provider's login. The securing tutorial rules out both.
  • A posting rhythm promised before anyone asked about your hours. The brand voice and cadence guide sets cadence from the hours available for production, replies and reporting, with the inbox subtracted first; a provider's hours are part of that sum and so are yours.
  • A presence on every platform. The choosing platforms guide argues for fewer platforms done well, with a veto for a platform where the audience is absent.
  • Targets taken from published benchmarks or from follower counts. The reporting guide explains why benchmarks do not say whether this month was good, and vanity metrics such as follower totals are listed as diagnostics, not results, in its table of metrics.
  • A report that lists every metric and ends without decisions. A report without a decision section is a measurement.
  • Results marked by the provider alone. A provider grading its own results has a stake in the verdict, which is why the export stays with the brand.
  • No named inbox owner on the brand's side, no stated hours for watching the inbox, or one script for every reply. The community management guide asks for response standards, an escalation route and replies that resolve something.
  • Criticism treated as something to delete. The same guide says criticism is answered and left up, with hiding kept for the categories in the published rules.
  • Customer photos used because they were public. The UGC guide asks for permission that is explicit, recorded and scoped.
  • Nothing said about leaving. If the proposal has no handover, the scope of work template's exit and handover section is where to ask for one.

Audit, strategy, production or reply drafting first

Do not buy everything in one block. The scope of work separates services and deliverables from what is out of scope, and, as general practice, the opening engagement splits into five pieces that can be priced and judged on their own.

  1. An audit of the presence. The social media presence audit scores each account on rows including fit, ownership, profile, content, replies, voice, accessibility and reporting. It is a bounded way to see a provider's judgement on your own accounts, and its rescore by the brand later gives the review something to read.
  2. Strategy and voice. Platform roles, goals and a voice guide are decisions the brand owns. A provider can draft them; the brand approves them and holds the documents.
  3. A trial of production. A fixed period of posts made to the voice guide, approved through the real approval levels. It tests whether drafts arrive on time and need little rewriting, which a pitch cannot show.
  4. Reply drafting. A separate scope, with the response standards, the approved answers and the escalation route attached. The inbox owner sends, so this piece tests whether drafts arrive quickly and need little editing, because a reply that goes out wrong is public at once.
  5. Reporting. Part of each engagement, with the brand holding the export each month.

Start with the smallest piece that tests the part you are least sure of. As general practice, ask a freelancer, who is one person, for a named deputy before the contract is signed; an agency spreads the work across people, and you should know which of them will touch your accounts. Whichever you choose, the brand owes the provider hours too: approving by the cut-off, giving the provider time with the people who know the subject, answering permission requests and reading the report. A provider cannot keep a promise that depends on hours the brand has not offered.

The weighted scoring matrix disciplines the choice: criteria and weights agreed before any proposal is read, account ownership applied as a gate and not as a weight, anchors written for the scores, and a second run of the totals under sceptical weights to see whether the leader changes.

Reports the brand can check

A provider's report or insight note is evidence, and the brand can test it against things it holds. The reporting guide's principles apply: a goal for each platform, the measure that follows from it, a comparison against the brand's own history and a section that ends in decisions. As general practice, test each claim in a report against something the brand holds itself:

What the report saysHow the brand checks it
What was publishedThe calendar's rows for the period, and the published posts on the accounts
A goal metric moved on a platformThe brand's own export for the same period, read per platform because definitions differ, and against the median of the brand's own earlier months for the same format
Replies were promptA sample of threads from the inbox, read against the response standard, and the moderation log
Visits and enquiries came from socialThe site's analytics and the enquiry record, with the links tagged to the brand's own naming convention, which the naming conventions and UTMs guide lays out
The month taught somethingA hypothesis written before the data, and last month's decisions followed up this month with what happened
Sentiment or share of voice improvedThe hand-tagged sample and the questions in the listening tutorial; a tool cannot see everything, and the report should say what it cannot see

If the provider's figures rise while the business's do not, start from the diagnosis for a provider whose reports look good while sales do not move: its causes include metrics that stay on the platform, a brief that names no business goal and conversions claimed too generously.

When the work can fairly be judged

Judge the work only against a record that predates it. The pillar's first ninety days sets up reporting before anything is published so that a baseline exists; with a provider, that means exporting the brand's own results from the platforms before the first post goes out, because the platforms keep history for a window they decide. The reporting guide's cadences then say what a week, a month and a quarter can each show, and the review of a provider's work follows them.

The first quarter follows the pillar's first ninety days, with the review in the third month, where the brand's rescore of the presence audit and the report's decisions are read together. As general practice, agree these dates in the scope, so that the review is a scheduled event and not a grievance.

Two habits protect the comparison. Alter one thing at a time, because when cadence, formats and pillars all shift in the same month nobody can say which change moved the result. And do not judge on one post: the content hub warns against dropping a format after one weak result, and against building a format around one viral result that the team cannot keep making. If the review is going badly, the page on turning round an underperforming agency starts from the evidence against the scope, and the client's share of the cause.

Changing provider without losing the accounts

A change of provider can lose what nobody wrote down. The order for confirming ownership, collecting what the account runs on and removing access is the one in the securing tutorial's steps on leavers and handover and in the agency offboarding checklist, so it is not repeated here. As general practice, take these points, the first three of which are particular to organic social:

  1. Decide what happens to the queue. As general practice, read what the old provider scheduled against what has happened before it goes out, as the crisis plan's restart rule does after a pause.
  2. Treat voice and conversations as the working knowledge. A new provider can see the profile and the published posts but not the voice guide's reasoning, the cases promised an answer or how the brand treated people in the comments; the securing tutorial's handover step covers collecting them before access ends.
  3. Brief the new provider from the same documents. As general practice, hand it what the old provider worked from, so the two can be compared. The old-post review tutorial names an agency handover as a reason to sort what is already published against today's facts.
  4. Rerun the access review. The securing tutorial's rule is to run the register's review whenever an agency starts or ends; record the date.

If results fall after the change, results dropped after changing agency dates the drop against the handover and works through lost history, rebuilt work and new definitions. The paid parallel is the Meta Ads guide's section on changing provider; for organic work the brand's own record of results is what makes the comparison possible.

Weighing three proposals for a preserves maker (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Weighing three proposals for a preserves maker

Vanbofet Preserves, an invented maker of marmalades and chutneys sold through farm shops and a small online shop, has an owner and one part-time assistant, a photo platform and a professional network, and an inbox the owner has been reading at night. She asks a design studio, a freelancer and an agency for proposals against the same request and agrees the weights before reading any of them. One must-have becomes a gate: every account stays in the business's name. The remaining 100 points go to the voice and reply approach 25, the production plan and its use of the owner's time 20, reports the brand can check 20, the crisis route and access 15, hours and continuity 10, and clarity of scope 10.

The studio wants to open the accounts under its own login to keep its tools in one place, so it fails the gate and is removed unless it changes the proposal. Each remaining score runs from 1 to 5 against anchors the owner wrote first, with the evidence beside it. The freelancer scores 5 for voice, 4 for production, 3 for reports, 3 for the crisis route, 1 for hours and continuity, because she works alone and weekdays only, and 4 for scope: 360 of 500. The agency scores 3 for voice, 5 for production, 4 for reports, 4 for the crisis route, 5 for hours and continuity and 3 for scope: 395. Re-run with voice at 35, production at 15, hours and continuity at 5 and the rest unchanged, the freelancer leads, 385 to 375, so the owner reads the result as turning on one judgement and not as a win for either, and that judgement is whose drafts sound like the shop.

She settles it on evidence, not on the total. Each candidate drafts replies to ten questions taken from the last month's inbox with customer details removed, and two posts from the voice guide. Three of the agency's ten drafts break the guide's plain-speaking principle, and the freelancer's need no changes. The owner chooses the freelancer for production and drafted replies, starts with a trial of production before reply drafting begins, asks her for a named deputy before the contract is signed, names her assistant as the second person on the inbox for evenings, gives the freelancer her own named access, granted from the business's accounts, and not a shared login, and books a review in the third month, in which the owner rescores the presence audit and reads the report's decisions.

Common mistakes

  • Hiring out the owner role and the inbox along with the production. The strategy hub keeps both with the brand, and a reply sent by an outsider lands on the brand's name regardless.
  • Letting the provider open the accounts. An account in the provider's own name leaves the brand one contract end from a lock-out.
  • Reading proposals before fixing the weights. Once there is a favourite, the weights drift towards what it offers.
  • Taking the provider's report as the measure. Keep the export and read the report against the brand's own history, per platform.
  • Setting the rhythm from the proposal. Cadence comes from the hours available for production, replies and reporting, with the inbox subtracted first, the brand's own hours counted with the provider's.
  • Forgetting the permissions. The register of permissions for customers and colleagues is the brand's, and a provider that cannot show one has not been asked for it.
  • Judging on a single post or a single month. Compare like with like against a record that predates the work.
  • Leaving the handover to the last week. The voice, the open conversations and the history of results are the account as much as the login; collect them while the outgoing provider still has access.

Frequently asked questions

What should a social media agency do, and what should stay with us?

As general practice, the provider can plan, make and schedule content, draft replies from answers the brand has approved, tag posts and draft an insight note from the brand's own exports for its monthly report. The brand keeps the accounts and their administration, the voice guide, the inbox and the sending of every public reply, the approval of anything that makes a claim or names a price, the permissions for any customer or colleague shown, the decision that a situation is a crisis, and its own export of the results. The site's strategy guidance keeps the owner role and the inbox with the brand, because an outsider finds a brand's voice and its customer conversations hard to take over, and easy to damage.

Can an agency write replies to our customers in our name?

It can draft replies that follow answers the brand has approved; the brand's own inbox owner sends them, because a reply sent by an outside person is still the brand speaking in public and the site's guidance leaves the public social inbox to the business's own community owner. It should not decide complaints, quote terms nobody has published or judge a crisis alone. Name the inbox owner on the brand's side, agree the response standard the drafts will be reported against, and, as general practice, check a sample of drafts and the moderation log alongside each monthly report.

How soon can a social media agency's work be judged fairly?

Once the brand holds a record of its own results from before the provider started, the provider has published at a steady rhythm for long enough to show a pattern, and the review compares like with like, such as the same format on the same platform. Read a week as a log of what went out, a month as the first fair comparison of formats and pillars against the brand's own medians, and a quarter as the point at which a platform's progress towards its goal can be judged. Alter one thing at a time where possible, and do not judge on a single post.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Sources

  1. Meta Business Help Centre — Meta

Related