Scope: what this audit covers and what it does not
The scorecard covers every organic social account the organisation runs or is visible on, including regional or product accounts and abandoned ones that still show up in search. For each, it rates whether the platform suits the audience and goals, how complete and current the profile is, what the content mix and cadence look like, how comments and messages are handled, whether the voice and visuals match the brand, and whether results are reported in a way that supports decisions. Score each account in its own column so they can be compared.
It does not teach strategy. Deciding which platforms to be on is covered in the choosing platforms guide; handling replies, moderation and escalation in the community management guide; and the tick-box pass for a profile in the social page optimisation checklist. Paid social is out of scope; the Meta Ads scorecard in the audit library covers that. Influencer programmes and social customer service operations deserve their own reviews.
Before you score: access and evidence
You need admin or analyst access to every account and to the native analytics on each platform, plus a list of who holds the logins. Fix an evidence window long enough to show a content pattern and keep it for the rescore. Write down the goal each account is supposed to serve, because an account cannot be judged on fit without one.
Export or screenshot each profile as a visitor sees it, logged out where the platform allows. Pull a sample of posts from the window with their format, topic and response. Note how many comments and messages arrived and how quickly and how well they were answered. Collect the last few social reports shared internally. If competitors' presence is relevant, note their visible activity so Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. can be discussed in general terms, without relying on figures you cannot verify.
Criteria and scoring
Rate each account missing, partial or solid on every row. Platform fit and account ownership are gates.
| Criterion | What good looks like | Score guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Platform fit (gate) | The audience the goal needs is active here, and the format suits what you can make | Missing: no audience or goal / Partial: audience present, goal unclear / Solid: clear fit |
| Account ownership and access (gate) | Accounts held in business tools, with named admins and recovery set up | Missing: personal or unknown ownership / Partial: some gaps / Solid: owned and documented |
| Profile completeness | Name, handle, bio, links, contact details and imagery complete and current | Missing: incomplete or outdated / Partial: mostly complete / Solid: complete and current |
| Profile consistency | Handles, names and descriptions consistent across platforms | Missing: confusing variations / Partial: minor differences / Solid: consistent |
| Content mix | Formats and topics suit the platform and serve the goal, not only promotion | Missing: repurposed promotions / Partial: some native content / Solid: platform-native mix |
| Content pillars | A small set of defined themes guides what is posted | Missing: random posting / Partial: loose themes / Solid: defined pillars |
| Cadence | Regular rhythm the team can sustain, matched to the platform | Missing: bursts and silences / Partial: irregular / Solid: steady and sustainable |
| Response handling | Comments and messages answered promptly and helpfully | Missing: ignored / Partial: slow or inconsistent / Solid: prompt and helpful |
| Moderation and escalation | Rules for spam, abuse and complaints, with an escalation route | Missing: none / Partial: informal / Solid: written and followed |
| Brand voice | Tone fits the brand and the platform | Missing: off-brand or inconsistent / Partial: variable / Solid: recognisable |
| Visual identity | Visual style recognisably the brand, adapted to each format | Missing: no consistency / Partial: some / Solid: consistent and adapted |
| Accessibility | Alt text, captions on video and readable text in images | Missing: none / Partial: some / Solid: standard practice |
| Reporting | Reports tie activity to the account's goal and lead to decisions | Missing: no reports / Partial: vanity metrics only / Solid: goal-led with actions |
Profile and access rows are scored against what each platform documents, such as the Meta Business Help Centre for Facebook and Instagram pages and LinkedIn Marketing Solutions Help for company pages. Do not score features a platform does not offer to the account type.
How to score and prioritise
Score the gates first. An account that fails platform fit should not receive more effort until its purpose is rethought or it is paused; improving a profile nobody in the target audience will see is wasted work. An account that fails ownership is a risk whatever its results, because a departing employee or a lost password can take it away. Fix ownership before anything else on that account.
Then rank the remaining weaknesses by the account's importance to the goals and the visibility of the problem. Unanswered complaints in public rank high on any active account, because they are seen by everyone who visits. Cadence and content mix problems rank high on the accounts that carry the goals. Profile tidiness ranks high on accounts that people find through search, and low on accounts being considered for closure.
Reading the result: what to do with each band
Red means a gate scored missing for that account. If fit is missing, decide whether to repurpose the account or pause it with a pointer to active channels. If ownership is missing, recover and document access before any other work.
Amber means the gates hold but several rows are weak. Agree content pillarsOne of a small set of recurring themes that a brand's content is planned around. and a realistic cadence first, then fix response handling, then profile and visual consistency. Set a KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. per account that matches its goal, so the rescore has something to read.
Green means the account is healthy. Protect the cadence, review pillars each quarter, and look at whether ReachUnique people who saw an ad. and engagement are growing among the audience that matters rather than in general.
From audit to action plan
Lay the accounts side by side with their bands, then decide the portfolio first: which accounts grow, which are repaired and which pause. Only then turn weak rows into tasks with an owner and a rescore date. Reporting fixes belong with whoever writes the monthly report; the social media reporting guide covers what a goal-led report contains. A report that leads with vanity metricsMetrics that look impressive but do not inform a decision or track a business outcome., such as follower totals, scores partial on the reporting row. The tutorial on building a social media performance baseline builds the record of the account's own results that a goal-led report can place each result against.
A college with too many accounts
A further-education college finds 17 social accounts across five platforms, created over the years by departments. Seven fail ownership: they were set up with staff members' personal emails, two of whom have left. Four fail platform fit, including a video account last updated two years ago. The central team recovers access to five accounts, closes the two it cannot recover through the platforms' processes, and pauses four with a pinned post directing followers to the main accounts. The remaining six score amber. With effort concentrated, the team moves those six to a shared calendar of three content pillars and a weekly cadence it can sustain.
Common mistakes
- Scoring accounts without a goal. Fit and reporting cannot be judged against nothing. Write the goal for each account before scoring.
- Treating closure as failure. Pausing an account that serves no audience is a good outcome. Keeping it alive out of habit is the failure.
- Counting followers as reporting. Follower totals rarely change a decision. Score reports on whether they tie activity to goals.
- Ignoring abandoned accounts. An old, forgotten profile still represents the brand in search. Include it in the audit.
- Copying one cadence to every platform. What suits one platform overwhelms another. Score cadence against each platform's norms and the team's capacity.
- Letting each department score its own account. Owners are generous to their own work. Have one person score every account on the same day.
