Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Audit Guides

Product Feed and Performance Max Audit Scorecard

A scored Shopping and Performance Max audit: feed health, lifecycle labels, campaign structure, asset groups, values and margin, and reconciliation with orders.
Auditadvanced11 min readUpdated

Scope: what this audit covers and what it does not

The question this audit answers is whether the product feed, and the Shopping or Performance Max set-up built on it, is good enough to trust what the campaigns report and to add budget, and what should be fixed first. It covers a running catalogue programme in Google Ads and Merchant Center: how disapprovals and warnings are handled, how complete titles and attributes are, whether price, stock and variants match the site, how products are labelled for their stage in life and their margin, which campaign types run and how they are divided, how asset groups, signals and controls are set, what the primary conversions count, how return targets are set and whether results are checked against real orders.

It does not re-teach the work. Feed attributes, titles, custom labels and the diagnostics routine belong to the product feeds guide, and the week-to-week running of the campaigns to the Shopping and Performance Max playbook. A new feed is checked with the Merchant Center feed setup checklist and a new campaign with the Performance Max launch checklist. The Shopping and Performance Max hub is the map of the guides behind every row.

Search campaigns are scored by the Google Ads account audit, which has no feed rows; a business running both can score each on the same scale. The store itself, from product pages and delivery promises to checkout and repeat purchase, is scored by the online store audit, a single campaign page by the landing page audit, and every scorecard sits in the audit library.

Before you score: access and evidence

Ask for access to Merchant Center and read access to the Google Ads account, including its conversion settings. Without the Merchant Center diagnostics you cannot score the feed rows, so they stay provisional until you have it. Fix an evidence window long enough to cover the catalogue's normal rhythm of launches and price changes, avoid a window that sits entirely inside a sale, and keep the same window for every rescore.

Collect:

  • Merchant Center access with the diagnostics view, the feed sources, supplemental feeds and rules;
  • the product data export with titles, identifiers, product types, custom labels, price and availability;
  • Google Ads exports of Shopping and Performance Max campaigns, listing groups and asset groups with their settings for the window;
  • the conversion action list with each action's primary or secondary status, counting and value settings;
  • margin by product or category from the business, and the return targets in use;
  • the business's own order records for the same window, with returns and cancellations.

Write down the margin the business works to before you look at results. The break-even calculator and the ROAS calculator help check whether each return target in use sits above the break-even return for the products it covers.

Criteria and scoring

Rate each row missing (absent or broken), partial (present but incomplete, inconsistent or out of date) or solid (matches the "what good looks like" column). The scale is your judgement against that column, not a number. Rows marked gate decide the band on their own when they score missing.

Feed and Merchant Center

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Feed diagnostics routine (gate)Disapprovals and warnings are reviewed on a routine with an owner, and causes are fixed at the source rather than patchedMissing: nobody reads diagnostics, best-sellers disapproved / Partial: reviewed occasionally, the same reasons recur / Solid: an owner, a routine, fixes at the source
Titles and attributesTitles lead with the words shoppers search, identifiers are correct and required and recommended attributes are completeMissing: titles copied from internal names, identifiers absent / Partial: complete for best-sellers only / Solid: consistent across the catalogue
Price and availability agreeFeed price and stock match the product page and its structured dataMissing: mismatches flagged and left / Partial: sync works, some templates disagree / Solid: one source for feed, page and markup
Variants submitted correctlyEach variant is its own item, grouped so the right size or colour is shown and linkedMissing: one item standing for the whole range / Partial: grouped, links open the default variant / Solid: own id, shared group, correct link

The product feeds guide sets out the diagnostics routine and treats the diagnostics page as a backlog ordered by revenue at risk. Required attributes are left to Google's product data specification, which this scorecard does not repeat. Price agreement is scored against the product structured data tutorial, and variants against the product variants tutorial.

Catalogue segmentation

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Lifecycle and margin labelsCustom labels carry lifecycle stage, margin band or season so campaigns can treat products differentlyMissing: no custom labels / Partial: labels set once and never updated / Solid: labels maintained as products move
New, seasonal and clearance rulesNew products, seasonal ranges, clearance lines and out-of-stock items each have their own handlingMissing: every product treated alike / Partial: clearance handled, new products starved / Solid: a rule for each stage

The guide to new, seasonal and clearance products explains why one target cannot serve every product and how each Custom Label moves a product between groups.

Campaign structure

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Campaign type choiceThe choice of Standard Shopping, Performance Max or both side by side follows the catalogue and the control the business needsMissing: a type chosen by default / Partial: deliberate, never revisited / Solid: chosen on purpose and recorded
Shopping priorities and negativesStandard Shopping product groups, priorities and negative keywords route queries on purposeMissing: one product group, no negatives / Partial: groups split, priorities unused / Solid: routing deliberate and reviewed
Performance Max campaigns and listing groupsThe number of campaigns and listing groups follows real differences in targets or budgets, not the catalogue's menuMissing: a campaign per category with the same target / Partial: some splits without a reason / Solid: each split has a reason

The type choice is scored against the comparison of Performance Max and Standard Shopping, routing against the Standard Shopping structure guide and Performance Max campaigns against the Performance Max structure guide. Where Standard Shopping does not run, leave that row unscored and say so in the findings.

Asset groups and controls

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Asset group themesEach asset group has one theme, a matching final URL and assets in every shape the format usesMissing: one group for everything / Partial: themed, gaps in asset shapes / Solid: one theme, matching page, complete assets
Signals and search themesAudience signals come from the business's own data, and search themes fill gaps the page undersellsMissing: no signals / Partial: generic interests only / Solid: own data and deliberate themes
Brand and URL controlsBrand exclusions, placement exclusions and URL expansion are set deliberately and recordedMissing: defaults nobody chose / Partial: brand excluded, URL expansion unchecked / Solid: each control set and recorded

The asset group tutorial covers what an Asset Group carries and how an Audience Signal guides it; asset counts are left to Google Ads Help. The controls row follows the Performance Max structure guide.

Values and targets

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Order values on primary actions (gate)Only real purchases are primary conversions, each carrying the order value with duplicates removedMissing: other actions primary beside purchases, or values absent / Partial: purchases only, duplicates or fixed values / Solid: one primary purchase action with real values
Margin-aware targetsReturn targets are set from margin and break-even, by label or product group rather than one figure for the catalogueMissing: one target from revenue alone / Partial: margin considered, one figure for all / Solid: targets by label or group from margin

The conversion action clean-up tutorial explains why bidding optimises towards every primary action and how to repair them; the shopping and catalogue ads guide sets targets from margin rather than from Conversion Value alone.

Reconciliation and evidence

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Orders reconciliationPlatform conversions are reconciled with orders each month, and targets are set on reconciled numbersMissing: platform figures only / Partial: occasional checks / Solid: monthly, with a tracked ratio behind the targets
What Performance Max addsA holdout or uplift test, planned before the results, shows what Performance Max adds over the campaigns it overlapsMissing: no evidence beyond attribution / Partial: before-and-after comparisons / Solid: a planned test behind the main spend

The tutorial on reconciling conversions with sales shows how to explain the gap line by line, and the incrementality testing guide sets out the test designs.

How to score and prioritise

Score the two gates first. If the feed carries unresolved disapprovals, the campaigns are choosing from a partial catalogue and every structure row describes what was left. If primary conversions miscount values, automated bidding has been chasing the wrong figure and the target and structure rows are provisional: what looks like a weak campaign may be one bidding towards a lead form or a doubled order. Mark them so.

Then rank the remaining weaknesses in this order:

  • The data that steers bidding: margin-aware targets and lifecycle labels, because a single target treats best-sellers, new lines and clearance as the same bet.
  • Structure and controls: campaign type, listing groups, asset group themes and brand exclusions.
  • Reconciliation and incrementality evidence, which must be in place before any budget increase.
  • Title polish and asset refreshes last, unless the diagnostics point to them.

Within each group, rank by the revenue the weakness touches. A disapproved best-seller outranks many disapproved long-tail items, and a fix on the campaign carrying most of the spend outranks the same fix on a small one. The academy checkpoint on running, auditing and testing a Shopping programme tests the audit's two gates, its bands and the fix list beside who decides about a product and the uplift test's guardrails.

Reading the result: what to do with each band

Red means a gate scored missing. Hold budget increases and new campaigns, give the feed an owner and clear the top disapproval reasons at the source, and make real purchases the only primary action with correct values. Rescore after a full month on the corrected set-up, because automated bidding needs time to adjust.

Amber means the gates hold at least partially but several other rows are partial or missing. This is the usual result. Work a short ordered list one area at a time, starting with labels and targets.

Green means the gates are solid and most rows are too. Move effort into planned incrementality tests, feed title tests and asset refreshes, and rescore each quarter and before each peak season.

From findings to a prioritised fix list

Write each partial or missing row as a finding in plain words: what you saw, the evidence and the revenue it touches. Turn the findings into one fix list with a line per fix: the finding, the fix, the owner, the guide that explains it and the rescore date. Order the list by the priorities above, not by how easy each fix is.

Group the lines by who does the work. Feed fixes sit with whoever owns the store platform and the feed, values and conversion actions with whoever runs tracking, labels and targets with the buyer and the person who knows margins, and structure, asset groups and controls with the account manager. Present the band, the gate findings and the first few fixes to the budget holder, and keep the full scorecard as the working copy for the rescore. The academy exercise on auditing Shopping and testing Performance Max for an aquarium store practises scoring a running programme with this scorecard, banding it and turning the findings into one ordered fix list with owners and a rescore date.

Illustrative example

Illustrative example — not a real result

A garden tools retailer audits its catalogue before spring

Brazquel Garden Tools, an invented online garden tools retailer with 1,200 products and about £14,000 a month on Performance Max, audits its catalogue campaigns in February over the previous ten weeks. Feed diagnostics score missing: about 400 products carry price mismatches because sale prices change on the site but not in the feed, and nobody owns the diagnostics page. Order values on primary actions also score missing: a catalogue request form was set as a primary conversion beside purchases, worth a fixed £20 each. Margin-aware targets score missing, because a single target of 400% covers clearance shears and new cordless tools alike, and lifecycle labels are absent. Asset groups score partial. The band is red. The fix list puts a feed owner and a daily price sync first, the request form moved to secondary second, and lifecycle labels with separate targets for new, core and clearance lines third. After a full month on the corrected set-up, mismatches have fallen to a handful, the gates score solid and the band moves to amber.

Common mistakes

  • Judging campaigns before the feed. A campaign that cannot show half its best-sellers is not under-bidding. Score the feed gate first.
  • Leaving extra actions primary. A lead form or a page view counted beside purchases teaches bidding to chase it. Score the values gate on what is primary, not on what the purchase tag sends.
  • Setting one target for the catalogue. A new line without history and a clearance item are different bets. Score targets on whether they follow margin and lifecycle.
  • Splitting campaigns by the catalogue's menu. More campaigns only help where targets or budgets genuinely differ. Score each split on its reason.
  • Reading Performance Max's own column as proof. It overlaps with search and brand demand. Score the evidence row on reconciled orders and a planned test.
  • Changing everything before peak season. Large simultaneous changes leave bidding relearning at the worst time. Work the list in order and rescore on the same evidence window.

Frequently asked questions

How is this audit different from the Google Ads account audit?

The Google Ads account audit scores search accounts: keywords, ads, bidding and conversion tracking. It has no rows for the product feed, lifecycle labels, listing groups or asset groups, which decide what a catalogue programme can win. This scorecard rates those, from Merchant Center to reconciled orders. A business running both search and catalogue campaigns can score each on the same scale.

Why are the feed and the conversion values the gates?

Product campaigns have no keywords, so the feed decides which products can show, what they are matched against and which price appears. Automated bidding then optimises towards whatever the primary conversions report. If disapprovals go unresolved or values are counted wrongly, every result and every bid rests on bad data, so both are scored and fixed first.

Do I need Standard Shopping alongside Performance Max to score well?

No. The criterion is whether the choice of Standard Shopping, Performance Max or both follows the catalogue and the control the business needs, and whether it was made on purpose. A programme that runs Performance Max alone can score solid if the choice was deliberate, its listing groups follow real differences in targets and its brand and URL controls are recorded.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Where this page is used

Part of these learning paths

Also related

Sources

  1. Google Ads Help — Google Ads Help
  2. Product data specification — Google Merchant Center Help
  3. Google Merchant Center Help — Google

Related