What this checkpoint covers
Skaenalm Art Supplies, an invented online retailer of paints, brushes and canvases, has every role the playbook names. The questions apply the Shopping and Performance Max playbook, the product feed and Performance Max audit and the Performance Max uplift test.
Skaenalm Art Supplies: the programme
- Skaenalm runs its whole range of roughly 2,400 lines through a single Performance Max campaign with a 450% target ROAS.
- Contribution margin: own-brand watercolours 48%, branded oils 30%, canvases 24%, discontinued paint sets on clearance 8%; blended across the range, 35%.
- Labels set once at launch: "new" still covers a range launched 14 months ago, and student starter kits keep "seasonal" outside term time.
- An agency audit scored titles, assets and structure in detail without Merchant Center access; a newsletter sign-up is a primary conversion worth £5.
- Regional test, 8 weeks after learning, no brand exclusion: Performance Max spent £6,000 in treated regions and reported £33,000 of conversion value. Brand queries carried 38% of it; new customers were 29% of orders in treated regions against 36% in control; blended cost per conversion across the account rose from £9.80 to £11.40 in treated regions and held level in control.
Task
- Answer each question with what you would do and why, before opening the explanations.
- Mark an answer wrong if the action is right but the reason is not, and reread the guide section linked from it.
Questions
- The campaign manager excluded the branded oils for returns below break-even; the merchandiser heard a month later and now wants the own-brand watercolours pushed harder. Who decides each, and who acts?
- Stretched canvases are disapproved for price mismatch every week; each Monday the feed owner adds a rule copying the site price, and by Thursday they are flagged again. What should change?
- The campaign manager says the single target is fine because the account return looks healthy. What is wrong, and how do the labels stop drifting?
- The agency's audit grades the account amber and recommends new asset groups. What band should it be, and what does that hold back?
- The analyst writes the findings as separate lists, one per team, each ordered by how quick the fixes are, and plans the rescore over the term-start sale. What should the list look like?
- The campaign manager reports Performance Max's own return in treated regions, far above break-even, and wants it doubled. Read the test.
- Midway through the test the merchandiser wanted the brush titles rewritten and a canvas sale run. What should have happened, and what do the guardrails now say?
Answers explained
- Split by the playbook's table. An exclusion for poor returns against margin is the campaign manager's call, and the merchandiser is told, since there may be a commercial reason to keep the line. The push is the merchandiser's call, with the campaign manager on cost; the feed owner sets the label, the campaign manager adjusts the group. See who decides about a product.
- Fix the price at the source. A disapproval that returns after a fix was fixed downstream, and a rule has to be maintained forever. The store platform should feed the same price to the page and the product feedA structured file of a store's products, prices and availability used to build shopping and catalogue ads.; rules are for what the source cannot change quickly. See keeping the feed clean.
- One target treats every product as the same bet. Watercolours, canvases and clearance sets need targets from their own margins and stages, or the healthy average hides losses. Labels are filled from data and refreshed on a set schedule, and the merchandiser supplies the stage decisions that the feed owner writes into the feed; the stale "new" and "seasonal" labels show that refresh never ran. See moving products through their lifecycle.
- Red. A newsletter sign-up beside purchases fails the values gate, so bidding has chased sign-ups, and without Merchant Center access every feed row is provisional. Red holds budget increases and new campaigns: purchases become the only primary action, Merchant Center access is granted so the feed rows can be scored, and new asset groupsThe Performance Max unit holding the text, images, videos and signals for one theme, product set or audience. wait. See reading the bands.
- One list, in the audit's order. Gates, bidding data, structure and controls, evidence for budget moves, titles last, ranked by revenue touched within each group, each line with finding, fix, owner, guide and rescore date. Group the work by team afterwards; rescore on the same evidence window, never one inside a sale. See from findings to a fix list.
- It paid for itself only on its own report. Performance MaxA Google Ads campaign type that runs one goal across all Google inventory from shared assets. competes with every other campaign, so only the account total against the control prediction shows IncrementalityConversions caused by marketing.. The incremental return falls below break-even, so the campaign is held at a lower budget or the spend returns to the campaigns it overlapped; doubling is not on the table. See reading the results.
- Both should have waited. Feed changes and promotions move every shopping campaign at once, so the plan freezes them for the window. The guardrails show value carried by brand queries and returning customers, and blended cost per conversion rose in treated regions, so each conversion now costs more across the account. The brand exclusion is applied, audience signals tightened and the test rerun before any scaling. See the guardrails and design.
Answers three and six: the arithmetic
A 450% target (4.5) sits far below the clearance sets' break-even of 12.5 and well above the watercolours' 2.1: it loses money on one and starves the other.
Campaign's own figure: £33,000 ÷ £6,000 = 5.5. Account total in treated regions: £11,400 above the control prediction, interval roughly £2,400 to £20,400. Incremental return: £11,400 ÷ £6,000 = 1.9, against a break-even of 1 ÷ 0.35 ≈ 2.9 at the blended 35% margin.
Where to go next
Tripped up by any of the first five? Redo the aquarium store audit and test exercise; for target-setting by margin, revisit the advanced e-commerce level. The last module turns to retention, starting with the baking supplies shop retention audit.
