Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Audit Guides

Content Marketing Programme Audit Scorecard

A scored content marketing programme audit: goals and audience, pillars and calendar, briefs and standards, distribution, measurement and keeping it current.
Auditintermediate11 min readUpdated

Scope: what this audit covers and what it does not

The question this audit answers is whether a content programme is working towards business goals, with standards, distribution and upkeep that make each piece earn its cost, and what should change first. It scores the programme that produces content rather than the pages it has produced: goals and measures, audience research, pillars and the calendar, briefs, standards, expert input and AI review, people-first quality, distribution and repurposing, topic organisation for search, measurement, ownership and upkeep.

The page-by-page decisions to keep, refresh, consolidate or retire belong to the content inventory and audit that the content governance guide runs, recorded in the content inventory template; this scorecard asks only whether that inventory exists and is kept. Single pages are scored for search by the on-page SEO audit, and the brand's social channels by the social media presence audit. Search content production week to week is run by the SEO content operations playbook.

It does not re-teach the work. The content strategy framework and the content marketing guides linked in each area own their methods. Every scorecard sits in the audit library.

Before you score: access and evidence

Ask for the strategy or plan, the calendar, the style guide, access to the analytics reports used for content and the content inventory if one exists. Without the analytics reports you cannot see whether any strand does its job, so the measurement rows stay provisional until you have them. Fix an evidence window long enough for pieces to have been found, read and acted on, which for search content means looking well past publication, and keep the same window for every rescore.

Collect:

  • the written content strategy or plan, with goals and the measures attached to each strand;
  • the calendar for the evidence window and the briefs behind a sample of pieces;
  • the style guide, the review steps and the record of who approves what;
  • distribution records for a sample of pieces: where each went beyond publishing;
  • performance reports for content grouped by strand and job;
  • the content inventory with owners and review dates, if one exists.

Choose the sample across strands and authors rather than the pieces the team is proudest of. A programme is judged on what it usually produces.

Criteria and scoring

Rate each row missing (absent or broken), partial (present but incomplete, inconsistent or out of date) or solid (matches the "what good looks like" column). The scale is your judgement against that column, not a number. Rows marked gate decide the band on their own when they score missing. A row that does not apply, such as AI review for a team that does not use AI in drafting, is marked not applicable rather than missing.

Strategy

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Goals and measures per strand (gate)Each content strand has a job tied to a business goal and a measure that shows whether it is doing that jobMissing: content published to keep a schedule, with no job or measure / Partial: goals stated for the programme, not per strand, or measured by views alone / Solid: a job and a measure for every strand
Audience researchTopics come from customer questions, sales and support conversations and research, not from guessesMissing: topics from the team's own ideas / Partial: search data only, or research done once / Solid: questions from several sources, kept current
Pillars and calendarA few pillars organise the calendar, which plans by job and capacity rather than by date aloneMissing: a list of dates and titles / Partial: pillars named, calendar still sized to a fixed output / Solid: pillars drive the calendar, sized to real capacity

Goals are scored against the content goals and KPIs guide, which sets a goal per funnel stage and replaces activity measures with ones that change decisions. Research is scored against the audience research guide, and the plan against the content pillars and calendar guide, which explains how each Content Pillar becomes topics and how the Editorial Calendar is sized to capacity with an evergreen base.

Production standards

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Briefs for every pieceEvery piece starts from a brief with audience, angle, evidence and the action it should promptMissing: a title and a word count / Partial: briefs for some pieces, or without the action / Solid: a brief for every piece, used at review
Editorial style guideA style guide covers voice, terms and formatting, and writers use itMissing: none / Partial: written but out of date or ignored / Solid: kept current from editors' corrections and used
Expert inputPieces that need expertise draw on interviews with people who have itMissing: expert topics written from other articles / Partial: experts asked for drafts they never send / Solid: prepared interviews, quotes checked with the expert
AI drafts reviewedAI-assisted drafts go through human review for accuracy, originality and voice before publishingMissing: AI drafts published unchecked / Partial: edited for voice, claims not checked / Solid: every claim sourced, voice restored, a review gate nothing passes without

Briefs are scored against the content briefs tutorial, the Editorial Style Guide against the style guide tutorial, expert input against the guide to interviewing subject-matter experts and AI review against the guide to AI-assisted content with review, which reads Google's guidance on helpful content as it is published rather than through summaries.

Quality

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
People-first contentContent shows real experience and expertise and is written for readers rather than for rankingsMissing: pieces written around keywords, no named author or evidence / Partial: experience shown on some pieces / Solid: authorship, evidence and first-hand experience throughout
Written for the webPages lead with the answer, are easy to scan and work on a phoneMissing: the point arrives late, walls of text / Partial: headings and lists, answer still buried / Solid: point first, scannable, readable on a phone

People-first quality is scored against the E-E-A-T guide, which explains, from Google Search Central's helpful content documentation as it states it, why E-E-A-T matters and how it is shown on a page and across a site. Writing is scored against the writing for the web guide.

Distribution

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Planned distributionEach piece has planned channels beyond publishing, chosen for where its audience isMissing: published and left / Partial: shared on the brand's own social accounts by habit / Solid: channels chosen per piece and planned in the brief
RepurposingStrong pieces are reworked into other formats on purpose rather than copied acrossMissing: never reused, or excerpts pasted everywhere / Partial: reused without adapting to the format / Solid: chosen source pieces, adapted and tracked

Distribution is scored against the distribution channels guide, which treats search and email as the base, and repurposing against the repurposing guide.

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Performance read by job (gate)Content is judged against its job, grouped by strand, with assisted value considered alongside direct resultsMissing: page views for the whole blog, or no reports / Partial: reports by page, not grouped by strand or job / Solid: grouped by strand, read against each job, assisted value considered
Topic organisationTopics are organised into clusters with one page owning each query and links between themMissing: pages competing for the same queries / Partial: clusters planned, links or ownership incomplete / Solid: a hub and supporting pages, one owner per query, linked

Performance is scored against the guide to measuring content performance, which separates being found, engagement and contribution to an outcome and ends in a monthly review. Topic organisation is scored against the topic clusters guide and the topic clusters framework.

Upkeep

CriterionWhat good looks likeScore guidance
Owners and inventoryEvery page has an owner and sits in an inventory with a review dateMissing: no inventory / Partial: an inventory without owners or review dates / Solid: owner and review date for every page, reviewed on schedule
Updates and correctionsOut-of-date pieces are updated, consolidated or retired, and corrections are made openlyMissing: old pages left as they were / Partial: updates made, dates and corrections unexplained / Solid: updates noted, corrections open, retired pages handled

Ownership is scored against the content governance guide, which also runs the page-by-page inventory, and updates against the guide to updating and correcting content. Evergreen Content still needs an owner: it is the part of a library most likely to keep ranking after its facts have moved.

How to score and prioritise

Score the gates first. Content with no job, or no way to read whether it does that job, cannot be judged, and every other score loses its point. If goals score missing, the research, standards and distribution rows describe how well the team makes something whose purpose nobody has set, so mark them provisional. If performance reading scores missing, nobody can say which strand to grow and which to stop.

Then rank the remaining weaknesses in this order:

  • Quality and accuracy risks: unreviewed AI drafts, missing expertise and out-of-date pages that still rank. These put the brand's name on claims it cannot stand behind.
  • Distribution, because a good piece nobody sees has the same result as a weak one.
  • Production efficiency, style and calendar refinements next.
  • Repurposing last, unless the calendar runs short of ideas.

Within each group, rank by the reach the weakness touches. An out-of-date guide that brings in most of the programme's search visits outranks the same fault on a page nobody finds.

Reading the result: what to do with each band

Red means a gate scored missing. Hold new topics and new formats, write a job and a measure for each strand, set up reporting grouped by strand, and decide nothing about growth until the new measures have been read. Rescore once they have run for a full reporting cycle.

Amber means the gates hold at least partially but several other rows are partial or missing. This is the usual outcome. Work a short ordered list, starting with accuracy and upkeep, and bring each change to the monthly content review so its effect is seen.

Green means the gates are solid and most rows are too. Move effort into the strands that do their job best, into distribution tests and into the inventory's refresh cycle, and rescore each year or after a change of team or strategy.

From findings to a prioritised fix list

Write each partial or missing row as a finding in plain words: what you saw, the evidence and why it matters. A dated page with a claim that is no longer true, or a strand with no measure at all, is worth more than a general remark about quality. Then turn the findings into one fix list with a line per fix: the finding, the fix, the owner, the guide that explains it and the rescore date. Order the list by the priorities above, not by how easy each fix is.

Group the lines by who does the work, because goals and measures sit with the content lead and whoever owns the business goals, reporting with the analyst, standards and reviews with the editor, distribution with the channel owners and upkeep with each page's owner. Hand the page-level decisions the audit uncovers to the content inventory, so this list stays about the programme. Present the band, the gate findings and the first few fixes to whoever funds the programme, and keep the full scorecard as the working copy for the rescore.

Illustrative example

Illustrative example — not a real result

A home energy advice company audits a busy content programme

Eskavor Energy Advice, an invented home energy advice company, publishes about 12 articles a month across 4 strands and cannot say what any of them achieves. It runs the audit over the last 6 months. Goals and measures score missing: the plan sets a publishing target and no strand has a measure. Performance reading scores missing, because the only report is total page views for the blog. Updates score missing: 7 guides on home energy grants, among the most visited pages, describe terms that changed about a year ago. Owners and inventory score missing, and planned distribution scores missing, because nothing is shared beyond the blog. Briefs score partial and writing for the web solid. The band is red on the goals gate. The fix list puts a job and a measure for each of the 4 strands and a report grouped by strand first, updating or withdrawing the 7 grant guides with open update notes second, an inventory with an owner and review date for every page third and a distribution line in every brief fourth, and holds new topics. After 3 months, both gates score solid, upkeep scores partial and the band moves to amber.

Common mistakes

  • Scoring pages instead of the programme. A strong article does not make a strong programme. Score how content is made, and leave page decisions to the inventory.
  • Accepting views as a measure for every strand. A strand meant to win enquiries is not doing its job because it is read. Score goals on whether each strand has its own measure.
  • Judging the sample the team chooses. The proudest pieces are not typical. Sample across strands and authors.
  • Treating publishing frequency as a strength. A full calendar with no job per piece scores missing on the gate, however busy it looks.
  • Ignoring pages that still rank. Old pages with moved facts carry the most risk because people still find them. Score upkeep before style.
  • Fixing everything at once. New strands, new formats and new reports together make the next review impossible to read. Work the list in order and rescore on the same evidence window.

Frequently asked questions

How is this audit different from a content inventory and audit?

A content inventory and audit works page by page and decides whether each piece is kept, refreshed, consolidated or retired. This scorecard rates the programme that produced those pages: whether its strands have goals and measures, how topics are chosen, what standards each piece passes, how content is distributed and how the library is kept current. A programme that scores badly here will keep producing pages the inventory later has to retire, so the two are best run together, with this audit deciding what changes in the way content is made.

Why are goals and performance reading the gates?

Content with no job cannot be judged, and content with a job but no way to read whether it does that job cannot be judged either. Without both, a team cannot tell a strong strand from a weak one, so the scores on research, standards and distribution lose their point: there is no outcome to say they matter. Both are scored first, and a programme without them is banded red whatever its quality.

Can a small team with one writer use this scorecard?

Yes. The criteria ask whether each part of the programme exists and is deliberate, not whether it is large. A single writer with a goal and a measure for each strand, briefs, a short style guide, a plan for where each piece goes after publishing and a list of pages with review dates can score solid on most rows.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Also related

Sources

  1. Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content — Google Search Central

Related