Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

B2B Marketing › B2B Demand

Hiring and Evaluating a B2B Demand Agency

How to hire and judge a B2B demand or account-based agency: what stays with you, questions, warning signs, a bounded first project, reports and handover.
Guideintermediate19 min readUpdated

What a business-to-business demand agency is hired to do

A demand agency, studio or freelancer is hired to run part of a programme the demand section describes: aiming at a profile and a list of named organisations, content written for each role on a buying committee, advertising to a company list, events, sequences that support sales development and the report that says what came of it. The decision is less whether to hire than which of those jobs to hire out, and what must stay inside the business so that the provider can do the work and the business can judge it.

Two rules from the site's agency guides apply here. The in-house or agency comparison keeps strategy, data and measurement in the business, buys specialist depth and surge capacity, and gives measurement to whichever party the number does not grade, because an agency that reports its own return on its own terms has a conflict of interest. Business-to-business adds a third. The stages between a lead and a customer are an agreement between marketing and sales, as the alignment guide sets out, so an agency can work to them but cannot write them, and cannot make sellers act on what it delivers. As general practice, that is why this kind of work is harder to hand over than a single channel: much of what decides the result, such as who is on the list, what counts as qualified and how quickly sellers respond, is not the agency's to decide.

As general practice, treat the table below as a first draft to adapt. The middle column is what a provider can supply; the last column is decided, signed off or held by the business.

JobThe provider's partThe business's part
Profile and account listAnalyse CRM exports, propose fit fields and disqualifiers, build a draft list with tiers for reviewThe ideal customer profile signed off with sales, the list in the CRM with an owner for each account, and the decision on tiers
Content for each roleWrite, design and produce assets for the roles on the buying committeeThe claims and their evidence, time with the experts, permission for every customer named, and the decision to gate an asset
Advertising to named accountsBuild and run campaigns aimed at companies from an uploaded list, narrowed by job role, and read the company engagement reportThe ad account, the uploaded lists, billing and access, and the exclusion of customers and comparison accounts
Events and roundtablesPlan, invite, run the logistics and prepare the follow-upThe guest list built with sales, who follows up and on what basis attendees may be contacted afterwards
Sequences for sellersDraft sequences and short assets from messages the business has approved, and prepare account researchWho sends and from which domain, the consent basis and suppression list, every claim made in the business's name
Hand-off and routingConfigure the CRM and routing to the rules the two teams have agreedThe stage definitions, the service levels and return reasons, and what sellers do next
ReportingPrepare the report and an insight note from the business's own exportThe measures and their definitions, the earlier results on record and the verdict

A RACI matrix drawn up for these jobs makes ownership explicit before work begins, with one accountable role on each row. As general practice, where the row is the business's, that role is a named person on the business side, and where a row depends on what sellers do it is a named person in sales, not the agency's account lead.

Two adjacent engagements are covered by separate guides. A programme that is only content is the territory of the content marketing agency guide, and tracking and reporting work that is only measurement is covered by the analytics agency guide. The outbound guide describes sales development as a programme usually managed by sales, so this guide covers only marketing's support for it, as that guide defines it. The agency guide gives selection, fees and contracts for every provider; this one gives what is particular to business-to-business demand work. It gives no fees, retainer sizes or results to expect, names no agency, platform or tool beyond LinkedIn, and is not legal advice.

The records the business keeps from the first day

Every row of the table below is a record that one of the site's guides already asks a business to keep, whoever does the work. Write the list down before any provider is approached: the general agency guide expects the business to hold its accounts, data and assets from the first day. Then enter each row in the scope of work as a written duty, so that none of them rests on a promise made in conversation. The scope of work template gives a section on accounts, data and ownership and another on ending the engagement, while the request for proposal template has a section on data, access and ownership terms that each supplier prices in; neither supplies the legal wording, which is for the business and its advisers.

What the business holdsWhy it matters in a provider conversationWhere it is set up
The profile and its disqualifiersA profile the provider wrote alone has not been signed off with salesBuilding an ideal customer profile
The account list, with fit fields, tier and owner, in the CRMA list that lives in an agency's spreadsheet driftsAccount-based marketing
Stage definitions, service levels and return reasonsThey are the contract between the two teams, and the agency's output is judged against themMQL, SQL and lead stages
The CRM and its source fields, with the sourcing ruleTwo reports can credit the same opportunity differently unless the rule is written downSales and marketing alignment
Committee maps and account plans, with the plays in themThey hold what sales know about each account and what marketing plans for itABM account plan template
The customers willing to act as references, with the uses each one agreedAgreement belongs to a person and covers specific uses, so a provider cannot assume moreCustomer references and advocacy
The consent basis and suppression list for every contactThe business has to be able to show the basis for contacting each personMarketing support for outbound prospecting
The ad account, the uploaded company lists and the tagHistory, audiences and lead forms are what make an account worth keepingSetting up LinkedIn Campaign Manager
The history of results by cohort, and the self-reported answersJudging a provider needs a record that predates it and survives itBusiness-to-business measurement

On a platform that issues access person by person, each member of the provider's team is given access from the business's own accounts. The Campaign Manager tutorial limits an agency to access given to its named individuals, scoped to the job and reviewed on a date, and rules out working through an employee's credentials or a password that several people know. Agencies should not open the ad account for the business. Where an account already sits under an agency's or a former employee's login, the tutorial's advice is to ask that the business be given full control of it, and failing that to open a new account in the business's name, knowing that its audiences, conversions and history begin again. The business's own access review checks agency access against live engagements and removes it when an engagement ends.

Two of these records deserve particular attention in a provider conversation: the list and the sourcing rule. The list, because the account is the programme's unit and the outbound guide wants it held in the CRM, not in loose spreadsheets that fall out of date. The sourcing rule, because without it the agency and the business can count the same opportunity differently, which the measurement guide resolves by reporting marketing-sourced pipeline and influenced pipeline side by side. The rule should say who sets the source and when, and whether outbound and partner deals have their own.

Questions for every shortlisted agency

Put one list of written questions to all candidates and enter the replies in a single table. Prefer the reply that commits a named person to each job and states what it needs from the business and from sellers.

The profile and the list. Will you work from our profile, or bring your own? Where will the account list live, who signs it off and how will you treat an organisation outside it that asks for a demo? The account qualification tutorial keeps a fast lane for declared intent, and a provider should know why.

Sales. Which sellers will you need, for what, and how often? What do you expect them to do when an account engages, and how will you find out whether they did? When sales say the leads are poor, how will you settle it? The alignment guide settles that conflict with acceptance, qualification and opportunity rates by source against the agreed criteria, not with opinion.

Stages and measures. Which stage definitions will you work to, and who owns them? What will your report lead with? Which measure will you accept being judged on? A provider that answers with a count of leads has shown what it expects to be judged on.

Sources and credit. How will you record the source of an opportunity you started and one you only touched? Will you accept outbound as its own source, as the outbound guide recommends, beside marketing's influence on those deals?

Contacts and rules. Where will contacts come from? Will any be bought or scraped? How is the basis for contacting each person recorded, how do opt-outs reach every system, and which domain will prospecting mail leave from? The outbound guide asks the business to know the source and basis of every contact and to maintain a single suppression list that marketing and sales both use.

Content and proof. Who writes for each role, and how will you get time with our experts? How are claims sourced? How do you request a reference from a customer, where do you record what they agreed to and how do you disclose a paid or discounted recommendation? The references guide treats each of those as part of the pool.

Advertising. Which of our accounts and lists will you need, and who will own them? How will you handle a short list that may not clear the audience minimum after matching? How will you keep any comparison accounts out of an audience widened to meet it? The LinkedIn account-based guide explains that matching takes time and that a list has to clear a documented minimum.

Named people and cover. Which named individuals will touch our records, how many other clients does each carry, and who steps in during an absence? As general practice, a freelancer is a single point of failure, so the last question carries weight there; a deputy is cover only after having done the task once in earnest, the standard the key-person risk guide applies.

What a weak demand proposal gives away

No single item here proves an agency is weak. Treat each as a prompt to keep asking until the reply names something concrete.

  • A target set in leads or marketing-qualified leads. The measurement guide makes pipeline and revenue the outcome and treats lead volume as a diagnostic, and Goodhart's law describes what happens to a measure once it becomes the target.
  • A report that ends at the form. The diagnosis of flat sales behind good agency reports lists leads never closed out as a cause: if nobody marks what became of a lead, the agency optimises for forms.
  • Scoring built on downloads. The lead stages guide separates signs of reading from signs of buying, and says criteria drawn from the first kind hand sales leads that they then reject.
  • A list whose origin cannot be shown. The outbound guide warns that bought and scraped lists carry legal risk and, through complaints and bounces, deliverability risk too.
  • Personalisation by merge field. The account-based guide calls it worse than none, because the committee notices.
  • Starting with the largest accounts. The same guide suggests proving the approach on the second tier before bespoke plays for the first.
  • A promise of results inside a quarter. Demand creation is read on leading indicators first and on revenue over the cycle, which the demand generation diagnosis sets out.
  • Gating most of the content. The lead generation versus demand generation comparison advises gating the few assets that merit it and publishing the rest.
  • Pipeline claimed by one rule only. Sourced alone undercredits marketing and influenced alone overcredits it, so a provider should expect to report both.
  • No named sales counterpart. The account-based guide says such programmes most often fail in the hand-off.
  • A login that belongs to the agency. The Campaign Manager tutorial limits agencies to access granted to their own named people, so an agency-owned account or a shared password is a reason to ask again.
  • No exit terms. Ask for them, and read them against the exit section of the scope of work template.

Audit, list, pilot, then programme

Resist buying the whole programme at once. As general practice, split the first engagement into parts that are priced and judged one by one, which also fits the way the general agency guide keeps services and deliverables apart from exclusions.

  1. A review of the hand-off. The lead management audit rates the hand-off on definitions, routing, speed of follow-up and whether outcomes flow back to marketing. Work delivered into a leaking hand-off is wasted, and the review also shows what the provider spots unprompted.
  2. The profile and the list. The provider can analyse and draft; the business signs off with sales. The profile tutorial makes that sign-off a step of its own.
  3. A bounded pilot with comparison accounts. The pilot tutorial agrees a short list with sales, holds a matched group back, sizes the plays to capacity and writes the stop, extend or scale rule before the pilot starts. As general practice, applied to an agency it tests the provider's contribution, since the comparison group shows what the programme would have produced anyway.
  4. Content and outbound support, as separate scopes after the pilot, each with its own measure.
  5. Reporting. Written into each piece and built from an export the business holds.

As general practice, a freelancer should be asked to name a deputy before signing, and an agency should be asked which of its people will have access to the CRM and the ad account. As general practice too, the business has duties of its own: sellers' time for the list and the review meetings set in the scope, time with its experts for content, approvals by the agreed cut-off, access to the CRM and someone who reads the report. A commitment that needs the business's time is only as firm as the time it gives.

Use the weighted scoring matrix to compare proposals. Write the weights before the first proposal is opened, keep must-haves out of the weights as pass-or-fail gates, say in advance what each score means, and test the front-runner by recomputing the totals under sceptical weights. As general practice, for this kind of work two gates fit: the records in the table above remain in the business's name, and every contact's origin can be shown.

Testing a report against the business's own records

A provider's report is a set of claims, and the business can test each against records it already has. The measurement guide's design carries over: the outcome is pipeline and revenue, the leading indicators are those this business has found to come before it, and stage rates are read for each cohort, not month against month. As general practice, every line of a report should be matched to a record on the business side.

The report claimsA check against the business's own records
Accounts were reached or engagedThe account and contact records in the CRM, with roles counted as roles and engagement read against the definition agreed with sales
Leads or accounts were deliveredStage rates by source and cohort from the CRM, with acceptance and return reasons read beside them
Meetings were bookedThe calendar and the CRM's meeting records, with outbound recorded as its own source
Pipeline was createdThe opportunity records, under the written sourcing rule, with the sourced and influenced figures shown together and the share with no recorded source
Sequences went out and replies cameSending and bounce records, complaints and the suppression list, since mailbox providers weigh complaints heaviest
Advertising engaged the target accountsThe company engagement report inside the business's own ad account, and the list's match rate
Demand is being createdSelf-reported answers on forms, coded monthly, with branded search and target-account engagement read as trends
Content is used in dealsUsage records from the sales content library, read as the diagnosis of sales not using marketing content advises

Where the agency's figures climb and the business's own stay flat, the diagnosis of agency reports and flat sales, mentioned among the warning signs, is the place to begin; two of its causes are a brief that names no business objective and leads that are never closed out.

How long before the work can be read

Two clocks run. As general practice, early work can be read at the first review dates written into the scope, on what the agency does and asks of the business: whether the list was signed off, whether each play has an entry and an exit written down, whether advertising reached only the agreed accounts, whether sellers were briefed and whether the first report opened with pipeline. Results are read over a full sales cycle, taken from the business's own closed deals and not from a rule of thumb, by cohort of first touch and beside the comparison group where there is one. The measurement guide asks leadership to agree beforehand how the work will be judged: cohorts and leading indicators for the near term, revenue across the full cycle, and no change of standard because one quarter looks weak.

The general agency guide sets the review rhythm and the scorecard both sides complete. As general practice, write the review dates into the scope together with what each review may decide, so that a poor set of figures does not by itself bring a review forward. As general practice too, alter one variable at a time when you can, and avoid treating a single quarter of lead counts as a verdict either way. If a review goes badly, start with the underperforming agency tutorial.

Changing agency without losing the list, the records or the audiences

The agency offboarding checklist holds the general sequence for any exit. As general practice, the points below add only what is specific to business-to-business demand work:

  1. Confirm the list and its tiers are in the CRM. An account list in the outgoing agency's file leaves the successor guessing which organisations were chosen, why and by whom.
  2. Confirm the uploaded lists, audiences and forms sit in the business's own ad account. If any sits in the agency's, ask that the business be given full control first, as the Campaign Manager tutorial advises.
  3. Keep campaign names and source fields stable. The measurement guide asks for consistency over years, not quarters, so that a cohort can still be matched to its spend after the handover; the campaign records guide shows the records that carry them.
  4. Collect the plays, sequences and assets, with the claims and their evidence, and the suppression list and consent records, before access ends. The plays, written with entry and exit conditions, are what make a programme repeatable.
  5. Do not reuse the outgoing agency's best accounts as the new comparison group. The comparison needs accounts that received only the usual programme.
  6. Give the successor the profile, the list and the earlier results the outgoing agency started from, so that each engagement is read from the same starting point.

When results drop after the switch, read the diagnosis of results dropped after changing agency against the handover date.

Weighing three proposals for a weighbridge maker (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Weighing three proposals for a weighbridge maker

Vubomeg Weighing is an invented maker of weighbridges and load-monitoring software for quarries, waste sites and haulage yards. It has a marketing lead, two sellers and a CRM, and wants help with an account-based programme on a list of 260 sites. One written request goes to a specialist agency, a generalist agency and a freelancer, and the weights are written down before any reply is opened. Two must-haves are gates and carry no weight: the account list, the CRM records and the ad account stay in Vubomeg's name, and the origin of every contact can be shown. The other 100 points are split across six criteria.

The specialist agency proposes a list from a data supplier it will not name, which fails the second gate, so it is set aside unless the proposal changes. Each of the other two is scored from 1 to 5 on each criterion, against anchors written before the proposals arrived, and the evidence for each score is kept with it. The last column holds the sceptical weights, and the final row re-runs the totals with them.

CriterionWeightGeneralist agencyFreelancerSceptical weight
Profile and list approach204415
Working method with sellers202530
Reports the business can check204325
Content and proof155315
Contact rules153410
Continuity10525
Total of 500 on the base weights100370365
Total of 500 on the sceptical weights350380100

On the base weights the generalist agency leads, 370 to 365; under the sceptical weights the freelancer leads, 380 to 350, so the lead turns on the weights, chiefly how much the working method with sellers counts.

The totals do not decide it. The marketing lead puts the same task to both: each is given an export of closed deals with names removed and asked which accounts it would add to the list, what its first report would lead with and which sellers it would need. The generalist agency's answer names no seller and leads with leads; the freelancer's asks for four hours a month from each of the two sellers and leads with pipeline by cohort. Vubomeg chooses the freelancer, on the condition that she names a deputy before signing. The engagement starts with a review of the hand-off, then a pilot on tier two with 20 comparison accounts; the list and the uploaded audiences stay in Vubomeg's own accounts, the freelancer works through named access of her own, and a review after one full sales cycle applies the pilot's stop, extend or scale rule.

Common mistakes

  • Hiring out the profile, the definitions and the measure along with the programme. The stages are an agreement between marketing and sales, and measurement belongs to whoever the number does not grade.
  • Letting the agency open the accounts or keep the list. An account the agency opened, or a list kept in its own file, has to be rebuilt the day the contract ends.
  • Setting the target in leads. An agency can meet a lead target while sales reject what it delivers, the pattern described for criteria built on reading signals.
  • Scoring before the weights are written. Weights chosen after a proposal has been read end up describing that proposal.
  • Judging a pilot with no comparison group. Without accounts that received only the usual programme, the agency may be credited with deals that were coming anyway.
  • Accepting contacts whose origin cannot be shown. Legal risk and deliverability risk arrive together.
  • Letting the agency mark its own pipeline. Keep the rule written, the field required and the report built from the business's export.
  • Skipping sales. A programme without a named seller for each account is warming accounts nobody is working.
  • Planning the exit only at the end. The list, plays, audiences and records are as much the programme as the people who run it.

Frequently asked questions

Which parts of a business-to-business demand programme should an agency run, and which should stay with us?

As general practice, an agency can analyse your records, propose the profile and the account list for you to sign off, write and produce content for each role on the committee, run advertising to your uploaded list, draft sequences from messages you have approved, support events and prepare the report. The business keeps the profile and its disqualifiers, the list itself, the stage definitions and service levels agreed with sales, the CRM and its source fields, the claims and the customer permissions behind them, the consent basis and suppression list for every contact, the ad account and the measure the agency is judged on. The site's agency guidance keeps strategy, data and measurement in-house and buys specialist depth and surge capacity, and the alignment guidance makes the stages an agreement between marketing and sales, which an agency cannot sign on the business's behalf.

Can an agency supply the account list and the contacts on it?

It can build a list from your profile for you to review and keep in your CRM. The contacts need more care. An address at work that points to one named person counts as personal data, so a lawful basis is needed before it is used. In its direct marketing guidance the Information Commissioner's Office separates individual recipients, sole traders among them, from corporate subscribers, so the position changes with who is being contacted, and the site's guides add that bought or scraped lists carry legal and deliverability risk. Ask where every contact came from, how the basis for contacting each person is recorded, how opt-outs reach every system and who keeps the suppression list, and take advice from whoever owns compliance. A provider that will not say where its contacts came from has answered the question.

How soon can a business-to-business agency's work be judged?

On two clocks. As general practice, the early work can be read at the first review dates written into the scope, on things the agency does and asks of the business: whether the list was signed off, whether plays were written down, whether advertising went to the agreed accounts only, whether sellers were briefed and whether the first report opened with pipeline rather than leads. The result takes at least one full sales cycle, read from your own closed deals, by cohort of first touch and beside a comparison group where there is one. Agree the review dates and the decision rule in the scope before work starts, and avoid judging on one quarter of lead counts.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Sources

  1. LinkedIn Marketing Solutions Help — LinkedIn
  2. Direct marketing guidance — Information Commissioner's Office (UK)
  3. CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business — Federal Trade Commission
  4. Digital Marketing and Measurement Model — Avinash Kaushik

Related