First, find the untouched leads and who held them
Take every inbound lead created in the last full month and add four columns from the CRM: the owner at creation, the owner now, the time of the first logged outreach and the outcome recorded, if any. Sort the leads with no outreach into groups. Some will have no owner at all. Some will belong to people who were away or have left. Some will exist in the marketing platform but not in the CRM, or will sit in an object or view sales never opens. The rest will be assigned, visible and simply not worked, which is where response targets, context, trust and capacity come in.
Before acting, check that the activity data is real. If reps log calls by hand, compare a sample of "untouched" leads with the calling and email tools; a team that calls but does not log has a reporting fault, not a follow-up one. Then separate leads that were never worked from leads that were worked and returned. The second group belongs to the companion diagnosis on MQLs not converting to SQLs, which deals with qualification rather than contact.
Diagnosis table
Diagnosis
| Symptom | Check | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leads are assigned and visible but first contact takes days, or never comes | Whether a written response target exists, and whether anyone reports against it | No service-level agreement for response time | Agree targets by lead type with a named owner for breaches |
| Many untouched leads have no owner, or an owner who is absent or has left | Unowned and orphaned records by routing rule and territory | Routing leaving leads unassigned | Fix the rules, add a fallback queue, check queues daily |
| Leads appear in the marketing platform but not in the CRM view sales uses | Form-to-CRM counts for the same day; sync errors; hidden-field mapping | Leads not reaching the CRM view | Repair the sync and mapping; reconcile counts daily |
| Reps say they do not know why the person got in touch | Which source, campaign and actions are visible on the record sales works from | Lead arrives without context | Carry source, campaign and qualifying action into required CRM fields |
| One source's leads are skipped while others are worked | Contact rate by source against that source's past qualification rate | Trust eroded by earlier poor leads | Fix the source's quality, then rebuild trust with evidence |
| Untouched leads cluster after webinars, events or campaign launches | Leads per rep per day against what reps work on normal days | Lead peaks exceeding capacity | Stagger launches, prioritise by lead type, nurture the overflow |
Fix, verify and prevent each cause
No response target that anyone measures
Without an agreed response time, follow-up competes with every other task a rep has, and inbound leads lose to renewals, proposals and existing deals. The gap is not visible because nobody reports it.
Fix: agree response targets by lead type, fastest for demo and pricing requests, as part of the operating agreement described in the sales and marketing alignment guide, and name who acts when a target is missed. Kaushik's measurement model pairs each KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. with a target for a reason: a response time with no target and no owner is only a statistic.
Verify: the share of leads contacted within target rises week on week, and the untouched count for the month falls.
Prevent: show response time beside lead volume on the shared weekly dashboard, so a busy month with slow follow-up cannot be reported as a good month.
Routing that hands leads to nobody
Routing rules decay quietly. A territory is redrawn, a rep leaves, a new form creates leads without the field the rule reads, and leads start landing with no owner or with someone who will never see them.
Fix: document the rules and their fallbacks as the CRM lead stages and pipeline guide describes, so that every record crossing the hand-off line gets an owner, a task with a due time and a notification, and an escalation rule reassigns anything untouched past its window.
Verify: the daily count of unowned records and of leads owned by inactive users stays at or near zero.
Prevent: add a routing check to every leaver process and every new form launch, and keep the queue review in someone's job description. The tutorial on reassigning CRM records when someone leaves sets out that leaver step in full, from open deals and round-robin slots to emails still sent in the person's name.
Leads that never reach the screen sales uses
Sometimes the lead exists, just not where sales looks. Forms that strip hidden fields, a connector that fails overnight, a mapping that sends a new form's submissions to the wrong object or list: each leaves the lead in the marketing platform while the CRM view shows nothing.
Fix: test each form end to end by submitting a lead and reading the record that arrives, following the capture and reconciliation habits in the CRM integration guide, and repair the mapping or sync that drops records. Where the leads come from LinkedIn forms, the LinkedIn leads not syncing diagnosis covers that integration.
Verify: daily counts of submissions in the form tool and new leads in the CRM agree.
Prevent: reconcile the two counts every day for new forms and every week for established ones.
Records too thin to start a conversation
A rep who opens a lead and sees a name, an email and nothing else has to research before calling, and under pressure that lead waits. Sales needs to know why the person got in touch, which campaign brought them and what they did on the site.
Fix: capture the campaign parameters described in Google's URL builder documentation, the form name and the qualifying action into hidden fields, and write them to required properties on the record, as the CRM fundamentals guide recommends. Show the same fields in the view reps work from.
Verify: a sample of new leads all carry source, campaign and the action that qualified them, and reps' first messages refer to what the lead asked for.
Prevent: make those fields required at creation and report monthly on records missing them, grouped by the form that created them.
A source sales has learned to skip
Reps remember. After a few batches of contacts who never meant to buy, a source's leads get left until last and then not at all, even when the source has since improved or the occasional good lead is in the pile.
Fix: first fix the quality problem at its root, which the lead stages guide links to the qualification criteria and the return path, then show sales the evidence: acceptance and opportunity rates for that source since the change, by cohort.
Verify: contact rates for the skipped source return to the level of other sources, and its leads progress at a comparable rate.
Prevent: require a return reason on every lead sales declines, so quality complaints reach marketing as data while they are still small.
More leads than the team can reach
A webinar, an event list or a successful campaign can deliver a week's leads in a day. Reps work the newest or the most promising, and the rest age past the point where a call helps.
Fix: use the capacity planning in the inbound lead handling playbook: tell sales before large launches, rank lead types so demo and pricing requests are worked first, and route lower-intent contacts into nurtureKeeping in useful contact with leads who are not yet ready to buy until they are. with a rule that brings them back when they show buying intent.
Verify: after the next peak, high-intent leads are still contacted within target and the overflow sits in a named nurture track rather than in reps' queues.
Prevent: share the campaign calendar with sales and agree in advance how many qualified leadsA lead that marketing judges ready for sales follow-up against agreed criteria. a week the team can absorb.
A prevention routine for the hand-over
Unworked leads are cheapest to catch the day they appear. Each working day, someone in marketing operations reviews three lists: leads with no owner, leads owned by people who are out, and high-intent leads past their response target. Each week, the sales manager and marketing read the same dashboard: leads created, leads contacted within target, leads with no activity and leads returned with a reason, split by source and lead type. Each month, reconcile form submissions against CRM records, confirm that every live form still writes source and campaign fields, and read contact rates by source to see whether any is being quietly skipped. Before every launch that could produce a spike, agree with sales how the extra volume will be handled. After every leaver or territory change, test the routing. The lead routing QA checklist sets out that test, from a test lead on each form to the owner's alert. Keep the response targets and their owners written in one place, and change them only at the quarterly review where both teams are present.
An HR platform finds where its leads went
An HR platform's marketing team reported 720 inbound leads in March; sales said it had seen about 450. The CRM export showed 214 leads with no logged activity. Of those, 96 had no owner because a new event form did not populate the region field the routing rule read, 41 were assigned to two reps who had left, and 38 had never reached the CRM because a connector failed for four days. The remaining 39 were demo requests that arrived during a product launch week, when reps received about 60 leads each against a normal 15. The team added a fallback queue, fixed the form mapping, set a same-day target for demo requests with daily breach reports, and staggered the next launch. In May, 31 of 690 leads had no activity after five working days.
Once follow-up is reliable, the lead response time test shows whether still faster follow-up adds enough meetings to fund an immediate-response rota.
Common mistakes
Treating unworked leads as a motivation problem before checking routing and sync. Measuring response time from what reps log by hand. Leaving the fallback queue unowned. Launching a large campaign without telling sales. Letting a distrusted source's leads age in the queue instead of fixing the source. Sending leads to sales with no source, campaign or reason attached. Arguing about lead quality before confirming the leads were contacted at all.
