Why accept guest contributions at all
The good reason is the reader. A practitioner who has done the thing your readers want to do, a specialist your team cannot employ, or a customer with a story only they can tell can add experience and expertise your own writers do not have. Google's guidance on helpful content suggests thinking about who created a piece of content, and the AI-assisted content guide explains how a byline answers that question. A contributor with real experience of the subject is a good answer to it.
The bad reasons are the ones that fill most inboxes: free content to hit a publishing target, or a payment to carry someone's links. Both turn the site into a place where other people decide what is published, and both point towards the patterns Google's spam policies describe. The guide to Google's spam policies records two that apply directly. Link spam includes guest postsAn article written for another publication's readers under the author's name and published because the editor wants it. and articles with optimised Anchor TextThe visible, clickable words of a link.. And site reputation abuse is publishing third-party pages on a site to take advantage of the host's ranking signals, with a test of purpose: is this content here because it serves the site's readers, or because it can rank on the site's standing?
So the decision to accept contributions is a governance decision, and the content governance guide is where it belongs: who may contribute, who edits and approves contributions, and how they are recorded in the inventory like any other page. If the answer is that contributions will be published with less scrutiny than staff work, the better answer is not to accept them.
Contributor guidelines worth publishing
A public guidelines page, sometimes called a "write for us" page, does two jobs. It tells the right contributors what you want, so their pitches arrive closer to usable. And it tells the wrong ones what you refuse, which saves the editor from answering the same offer every week. It is worth publishing even if you mostly commission contributors directly, because it is the page you point to when someone asks.
Good guidelines are short and specific:
- Who the site is for. The readers, what they already know and what they come for.
- What you publish from contributors. The subjects, the kinds of experience you want, and the formats.
- What a pitch should contain. The question the piece answers, why the contributor is the person to answer it, an outline, and links to their previous work.
- How pieces are edited. That every contribution is edited to the house style guide, fact-checked and may be changed or declined at any stage, and that the contributor approves substantive changes to their argument.
- Bylines and author pages. That every contributor gets a byline and an author page, with a real name and real qualifications.
- Links. That links are included only where they help the reader, at the editor's discretion, and that the site does not accept links in exchange for payment, products or services.
- Disclosure. That contributors declare any commercial connection to products, services or organisations the piece mentions, and that the site tells readers about it.
- What you do not accept. Payment for publication outside your labelled sponsored offer, keyword-anchored links, articles published elsewhere, and pieces written for search rather than readers.
The editorial style guide tutorial builds the house rules contributors are edited to; link the style guide from the guidelines page so contributors can read it before they write.
Vetting a pitch and the person behind it
Vet two things: the idea and the person.
The idea is vetted like any brief. Does it answer a question your readers ask, from an angle your existing pages do not cover? Does it fit the subjects the site is about? A pitch on a subject far from the site's own is the shape the site reputation abuse policy describes, whatever the quality of the writing.
The person is vetted for what the byline will claim. Look for their real work: things they have made, run, taught or published under their own name, and a professional presence that matches what they say about themselves. The first question in the E-E-A-T guide's site review is who made a page and whether a stranger can verify it, so a contributor whose credentials cannot be found anywhere outside their pitch is a risk to the site's credibility as well as to the piece.
| Signal in a pitch | What it usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| A specific question, an outline and links to the writer's own work | A real contributor | Assess on fit and quality |
| A list of possible titles on loosely related subjects | Content produced to place links | Decline or ask for one specific idea with evidence of experience |
| "Any topic you like" plus a link the article must carry | A link placement offer | Decline |
| An offer to pay a fee for publication | A sponsored placement, not a contribution | Point to the labelled sponsored offer, if you have one |
| A writer representing an agency on behalf of clients | Commissioned link building | Ask who the client is; usually decline |
| A pitch from someone with a commercial interest in the subject | Possibly useful expertise with a material connection | Assess, and plan the disclosure from the start |
Editing a contribution to house standards
A guest contribution is edited exactly as a staff piece would be. That means the house style guide for spelling, names, numbers, headings and links; the accuracy standard for every claim, with a source where a reader might doubt it; the accessibility rules; and the subject review the governance roles require for anything technical, legal or financial. A contribution that cannot reach the standard is declined, however much work it took to get there.
Two edits are specific to contributions. First, read for promotion: sentences that exist to mention the contributor's products, employer or clients, and comparisons that conveniently favour them. Cut what does not serve the reader, and note what remains for the disclosure. Second, read the links. Every link is checked as a citation would be: does it go to the source of the claim, and would the house link it if a staff writer had written the piece? The section on links below covers what happens to the ones that fail.
Agree before publication what the contributor may change afterwards. A contributor who later asks to add links to an old article is asking for something the outbound links guide treats as a paid link with extra steps if anything is offered in return; the simplest policy is that published pieces change only through the house's update and correction routine.
Bylines, author pages and accountability
Every contribution carries the contributor's real name, and every contributor has an author page. The E-E-A-T guide lists author pages for every contributor with real qualifications among the site-wide practices that show E-E-A-TExperience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trust., and an author page is where the qualifications, the contributor's other work and any standing commercial connection are stated once and linked from every piece.
Whether author archives should be indexed is a separate, per-template decision. The index rules for archive pages set the test: an author archive earns its place when the author is someone readers look for and the page is a real profile with a biography, credentials and best work; a thin list of one article is better left out of the index. Apply the rule to contributors' pages the same way it applies to staff.
The byline names the author, and the site remains accountable for what it publishes. A named editor approves every contribution, and the contributor's piece is subject to the same corrections policy as everything else.
Links, payments and disclosure
Treat each link in a contribution on its merits, using the values the outbound links guide sets out from Google's documentation on qualifying outbound links: sponsored for adverts and paid placements, ugc for content users post, and nofollowA link attribute asking search engines not to treat the link as an editorial endorsement. for links the site does not want to vouch for. The nofollow entry explains why Google treats all three as hints.
| Link in a contribution | Example | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Citation the editor checked | A study or official document supporting a claim | Editorial: keep, no attribute |
| Useful resource the editor would link anyway | A tool or guide that helps the reader do the task | Editorial: keep, no attribute |
| Contributor's own site in the bio | The contributor's business or portfolio | A credit; follow the house default for bio links |
| Self-promotional link in the body | The contributor's product page, added to the argument | Remove, or keep with nofollow if it genuinely helps the reader |
| Keyword-rich anchor to a commercial page | A product keyword linking to a client's shop | Remove; this is the guest post pattern the link spam policy names |
| Any link that was paid for | Money, products or services exchanged | Sponsored, and the piece is labelled as advertising |
The outbound links guide's rule for user content offers a workable model for contributors: a default qualification on links, which trusted, established contributors can be exempted from deliberately rather than by accident, mirroring Google's note that a site may remove ugc from members who have contributed well over time. Whatever the house decides, apply it in the template so that every contributor's bio links are handled the same way.
Payment changes what the article is. If the site pays the contributor, the piece is commissioned work and is edited like any other. If the contributor or anyone behind them pays the site, the piece is a sponsored placement and is handled as advertising: the media and publishing guide records that advertorials and branded content are advertising, and that the UK advertising codes administered by the ASA require marketing to be obviously identifiable as such. The sponsored articles guide covers that arrangement from the buyer's side; on your own site, it means a visible sponsored label and every commercial link qualified as sponsored.
Disclose commercial connections even when no money changes hands with the site. A contributor who is paid by, works for or represents a business whose products the piece mentions has a material connection. The FTC's endorsement guidance, as the media industry guide and the influencer contracts guide describe it, expects material connections to be disclosed clearly. A plain line at the top of the piece and on the author page, saying who the contributor works for and what their connection is, lets readers weigh the recommendation. This is general practice, not legal advice.
Offers to refuse
Some offers arrive so often that the answer should be written down in advance, in the guidelines and in a reply the editor can send.
- Paid guest posts with fixed keyword links. Payment for an unlabelled article with followed, keyword-anchored links is the link spam pattern; decline, or offer a labelled sponsored placement with qualified links if you sell one.
- Link insertions in existing articles. A fee for adding a link to a published piece is selling links; the outbound links guide lists it among the things a link policy never accepts.
- Sections run by someone else. A third party offering to write and manage a section of your site, usually on a subject far from your own, is the site reputation abuse pattern.
- Bulk articles from content suppliers. Volume offers of articles on loosely related subjects add nothing your readers need and invite the scaled content the spam policies describe.
- Link exchanges. "We will publish yours if you publish ours" with agreed links; the spam policies guide lists excessive link exchanges among its link spam examples.
- Articles published elsewhere. A piece already published on another site adds a copy, not a contribution, unless it is handled as syndication with the original credited.
Saying no is easier when the policy exists. The BacklinkA link from another site to yours. such an offer is really about belongs to the contributor's plan, not yours; your plan is the reader, and a link sold from your site is your risk.
A sewing magazine's contributor policy (illustrative)
Thimblecrest Sewing Magazine accepts one pitch and declines another
Thimblecrest Sewing Magazine, an invented online magazine for home dressmakers, publishes contributor guidelines in March. In April it receives 46 pitches. One comes from a pattern designer who proposes a tutorial on fitting a bodice for a sway back, with an outline and links to the 12 patterns she sells under her own name. The editor checks the patterns and the reviews of them on independent sites, accepts the pitch, and asks for photographs of each step. The draft is edited to the house style guide; two sentences promoting her latest pattern are cut, and one link to it stays in her bio, which carries nofollow by the magazine's template default for new contributors. Because the tutorial uses one of her own patterns, a line at the top says she designed and sells it. She gets an author page with her background and her other work. The same week an agency offers a fee per article for 10 "guest posts" on home décor and finance, each with 2 fixed keyword links to clients' shops. The editor declines, and replies with the magazine's sponsored placement terms: a labelled article on sewing subjects only, edited by the magazine, with every commercial link marked sponsored. The agency does not reply.
Common mistakes
- Accepting contributions to hit a volume target. Free articles cost editing time and invite the patterns the spam policies describe; accept them for what they give readers.
- Publishing with less scrutiny than staff work. A contribution is edited, fact-checked and approved like every other page, or it is declined.
- Letting contributors choose their anchors. Keyword-rich links to commercial pages are the guest post pattern the link spam policy names.
- Charging without labelling. A paid article is advertising; it carries a sponsored label and qualified links.
- Hiding commercial connections. Readers should know when a contributor works for or sells what the piece mentions.
- Off-topic contributions. Pieces far from the site's subject serve someone else's ranking plan, not your readers.
- No author pages. A byline with no page behind it cannot show who the contributor is or why they know the subject.
- Allowing later edits outside the routine. Links added to old contributions on request are how sold links creep in; published pieces change only through updates and corrections.
