Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Content Marketing › Troubleshooting

Guest Posts Not Driving Traffic

Why guest articles bring few visitors and how to fix it: the wrong publication, a generic piece, a bio with no reason to click, untagged links, nothing shared.
Troubleshootingintermediate8 min readUpdated

First, decide what the article was for and measure it

Write down what the article was expected to bring. If the answer is readers, the measure is referral visits from the publication and what those visitors did on your site. If the answer is rankings, the measure is whether the link exists, how it is marked and whether the placement is one search engines count at all. If the answer is reputation, the measure is slower: citations, invitations, enquiries that mention the piece. The guide to writing guest articles treats readers and reputation as the main jobs and the Backlink as the least of them, so an article judged only on rankings may be failing a test it was never built to pass.

Then gather the evidence per article. Open the referral report filtered to the publication's domain for the weeks after it went live, and the campaign report for any tagged link in the bio. Check the article as published: is the bio there, does the link work, which attribute does it carry? Compare the visits with the article's likely readership, which the publication's editor can sometimes share. A piece read widely that sent nobody points at the bio or the piece; a piece read by almost nobody points at the publication or the promotion.

Diagnosis table

Diagnosis

SymptomCheckLikely causeFix
The host has large traffic, yet the article sent almost no oneWho reads the publication against who buys from youA publication chosen for its links or authority rather than for readers who match yoursChoose outlets your own readers already trust
Readers came to the article but did not click throughWhether the piece says anything only your team could have writtenA generic piece that could have run anywhere, with nothing only you could writePitch an idea grounded in first-hand work
The piece was read and quoted; the bio link was barely usedThe bio's wording, its link and where it sends peopleA byline and bio that give the reader no reason to visitWrite a specific bio pointing to a page that continues the article
Referral reports show little, but the team heard from readersWhether the bio link was tagged, and where untagged visits landedLinks untagged, so the visits arrive unattributed or not at allTag the bio link where the editor allows, and read referrals by domain
Rankings did not move after a run of guest articlesThe links' attributes and the kind of sites that ran the piecesSearch traffic expected from links that are qualified or from placements the spam policies discountJudge guest work on readers and reputation, not on links
A burst on launch day, then nothingWhether the article was shared through the newsletter, social and teamThe article published and never shared through the brand's own channelsPlan owned sharing for the first weeks after publication

Fix, verify and prevent each cause

A publication your readers never visit

A publication with impressive authority figures can still have no readers in common with you. The guest articles tutorial starts from the other end: ask customers what they read, note what the team quotes, check the trade and professional titles in the field, and leave out sites that publish on every subject or advertise guest posts in return for links.

Fix: rebuild the target list from your readers' habits, with a line for each publication on who reads it and what it is trusted for.

Verify: the next article on that list sends more referral visits per reader than the earlier placements, and those visitors browse beyond the landing page.

Prevent: require every pitch to name the reader the publication shares with you before it is sent.

A piece anyone could have written

Readers click through to the author whose article taught them something they could not find elsewhere. A summary of common advice, written to fit any outlet, gives them no reason to want more. The tutorial asks for an idea new to the publication's readers and grounded in something the author knows first-hand: a method, a pattern across cases, data the business holds.

Fix: pitch the next article around one finding from your own work, written in the publication's style with the substance first and promotion left out.

Verify: the article draws comments, shares or quotes, and the bio link's click-through rises against earlier pieces.

Prevent: before pitching, ask whether a competitor could have written the same piece; if so, find a different idea.

A bio that leads nowhere

The bio is where an interested reader decides whether to find out more. A line of service keywords reads as an advert, and a link to the homepage drops the reader somewhere unrelated to what they just read. The tutorial asks for a sentence or two naming the author's role and the experience that qualifies them, consistent with their own site.

Fix: write the bio around why this author could write this piece, and point its link at a page that continues the article's subject, such as a related guide or the author's page.

Verify: visitors from the bio link spend time on that page and move further into the site.

Prevent: write the bio and choose its destination at the same time as the pitch, not as an afterthought on submission.

Visits that arrive unlabelled

Visitors who come from the article through an untagged link appear as referrals from the host, and sometimes, when a link passes through a redirect or a reader copies the address, as direct traffic. The naming conventions and UTMs guide sets out consistent UTM values from one builder, and the guest articles tutorial adds the courtesy that matters here: ask the editor before tagging a bio link.

Fix: tag the bio link where the publication allows it, and where it does not, read referrals filtered to the host's domain and landing page.

Verify: each article's visits can be named in the reports and match what readers report.

Prevent: keep a log of every placement with its link, its tag and its referral figures, as the tutorial's final step describes.

Expecting search value that is not on offer

Some guest programmes are judged on rankings and fail that test because the links were never going to count. Google's guidance on qualifying outbound links describes the attributes sites use to tell Google about the relationship behind a link, and many publications mark contributors' links with them as a house rule. The spam policies list guest posting with keyword-rich Anchor Text among examples of link spam, and the link building methods guide draws the line at scaled guest posting whose purpose is the link.

Fix: stop judging guest articles on rankings, drop placements chosen for links, and keep the anchors in your brand name or a natural phrase.

Verify: each article is reported on readers, reputation and enquiries.

Prevent: write in the brief what the article is expected to bring, and leave rankings out unless the link is a natural, editorial one.

Published and left alone

A publication shares a contributor's article once, alongside everything else it publishes that day. Without the author's own channels, the article gets that single moment. The content distribution channels guide treats distribution as a plan written before publication: who needs to see the piece, where they already are, the form it must take there and when each release goes out.

Fix: plan the owned sharing for each article in advance: a newsletter mention, native social posts that make one point from it, colleagues sharing their own view, all linking to the publication's page.

Verify: referral visits continue beyond launch day and the shares come from the people you meant to reach.

Prevent: make the sharing plan part of the pitch-to-publication checklist so no article goes live without one.

A prevention routine for guest articles

Treat each guest article as a small distribution project with a written purpose. Before pitching, record the publication, the readers you share with it, the idea only your team could write, and what the article is expected to bring: readers, reputation or both. Draft the bio and choose its destination page with the pitch. Agree with the editor whether the bio link may carry campaign tags, and note the answer.

When the article goes live, read it as published, check every link, and start the sharing plan the same day: the newsletter, social posts adapted to each platform, the team's own accounts. Over the following weeks, log the referral visits from the host's domain, visits through any tagged link, what those visitors did, and any citations, enquiries or invitations that mention the piece. That log is the evidence for which publications deserve another pitch and which did not reach your readers at all.

Each quarter, read the log across every placement. Publications that sent readers who stayed go to the top of the list; publications that sent nobody leave it, whatever their authority. If the team keeps measuring guest work on rankings, revisit what the programme is for; the content troubleshooting section lists the neighbouring symptoms, such as pieces on your own site that get no engagement, that often share the same distribution cause.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Torvlehatch Payroll Advisers moves from big blogs to a trade title

Torvlehatch Payroll Advisers, an invented payroll consultancy for small employers, places four guest articles on large marketing blogs over six months, chosen for their authority scores. Together they send 37 referral visits and no enquiries; each bio reads "payroll, HR and compliance services" with a homepage link, and nobody at the firm shares the pieces. The firm's clients mostly read a trade magazine for small-business accountants. Its next article, pitched there, explains three payroll errors the team corrects most often in new clients' records, with a bio naming the author's years running payroll for small firms and linking to the firm's guide on fixing those errors. The bio link is tagged with the editor's agreement, and the newsletter and two partners share the piece in its first week. Over the following eight weeks the article sends 388 visits, 81 of them through the tagged link, and five enquiries mention it. The firm drops the remaining blog placements from its plan.

Common mistakes

Choosing publications by authority score. Pitching a topic instead of an argument. Linking the bio to the homepage. Asking for a followed link as a condition of the article. Measuring guest work on rankings alone. Leaving the publication to do all the sharing.

Frequently asked questions

Are guest posts still worth writing?

Yes, when the article is wanted for its own sake by a publication your readers trust. The writing guest articles tutorial treats the link as the least of a guest article's three jobs, behind reaching readers and building a reputation in the field. Articles written mainly to place a link are the ones Google's spam policies describe as link spam, and they rarely send visitors either, because the sites that accept them are not where anyone goes for advice.

Why did the article bring visitors in its first week and almost none since?

That is the usual shape. Most referral visits arrive while the publication is promoting the piece and while your own channels are sharing it, and they fall away once both stop. A long tail exists only where the article keeps being found, through the publication's own search traffic or links from elsewhere. Plan for the first weeks: share the piece through your newsletter, social accounts and team, and judge it on what those weeks brought.

Can we ask the publication to remove the nofollow from our link?

It is better not to. Some publications mark contributors' links as a house rule, and Google's guidance on qualifying outbound links describes those attributes as the way a site tells Google about the relationship behind a link. The guest articles tutorial notes that asking for a followed link as a condition of the article is among the link spam examples the spam policies give. Judge the piece on readers and reputation instead.

Terms used on this page

Also related

Sources

  1. Qualify your outbound links to Google — Google Search Central
  2. Spam policies for Google web search — Google Search Central

Related