Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Digital Marketing › Troubleshooting

Enquiries From the Wrong Kind of Customer

Why marketing brings enquiries from people the business cannot serve: a vague promise, broad reach, hidden terms, cheap offers, volume targets and no feedback.
Troubleshootingintermediate12 min readUpdated

First, confirm what the enquiries really are

"Most of our leads are rubbish" is a feeling until it is counted. Take a recent run of enquiries from every route, not only the website form: calls, emails, messages, directory contacts and platform lead forms. For each one, record where it came from and what happened to it, using a short list of outcomes that whoever answers enquiries agrees with. Kaushik's measurement model judges marketing by the business outcomes it produces rather than by activity, and this sample is the cheapest way to apply that: the outcome is a customer won, and the enquiry is only a step towards it.

Outcome tagWhat it meansWhere it points
Booked or wonBecame a customer or a confirmed jobThe sources and messages to protect
Outside the area or marketThe business does not serve where they areReach and targeting
Below the minimum or wrong jobToo small, or a service the business does not offerThe promise and the visible terms
Left at the priceEngaged until the price, then stoppedThe offer, or terms shown too late
Never reachableWrong details, no reply, or not a real personThe platform pages and the form itself
Still openNot yet decided either wayRead again once the outcome is known

Read the tags by source. If one platform produces most of the unreachable and fake contacts, the problem is that platform's form or delivery, and the Google Ads, Meta lead ads and LinkedIn lead form diagnoses cover those settings. If the same poor-fit reasons recur across search, social, directories and referrals alike, the cause is upstream of any single channel, and this page applies. If the complaint is instead that there are too few enquiries of any kind, the diagnosis of marketing that generates no leads is the right starting point, and for business-to-business teams whose problem lies in scoring thresholds and hand-over, the diagnosis of marketing qualified leads that do not become sales qualified owns it. Keep the sample counts honest: with a small business's volumes, a handful of enquiries can swing the picture, so read reasons across several weeks rather than one.

Diagnosis table

Diagnosis

SymptomCheckLikely causeFix
Enquiries for every kind of job, from every kind of buyerDoes the headline, ad or profile say who the service is for?The message names what the business does but no customerRewrite the promise around the customers the business serves best
Many enquiries from outside the area, or from businesses too small or too largeLocation, size and budget of poor-fit enquiries against the audiences each channel targetsReach and targeting wider than the segments servedNarrow targeting to the served segments and exclude the rest
People drop out the moment price, minimum or lead time comes upWhether the page and form show price guidance, minimum job, area and lead timeTerms hidden until the conversationShow the conditions on the page; ask one qualifying question on the form
Spikes in enquiries after a discount, with few bookings at full priceOutcomes of enquiries during offers against those outside themAn offer that draws deal seekersRestrict eligibility or swap the discount for an offer that suits real buyers
Channels celebrated for enquiry count while sales complainWhich number the plan, report and any bonus rewardEnquiry count set as the targetMake customers won, or qualified enquiries, the target
Ad platforms keep finding more of the same poor-fit peopleWhether any outcome beyond the form fill reaches the platforms or the reportNo record of which enquiries became customersRecord outcomes by source and feed them back to the platforms

Fix, verify and prevent each cause

A promise that names no customer

"Cleaning, repairs and installation" tells people what is on offer; it does not tell anyone whether they are the customer the business wants. With no signal about who it is for, the message is answered by everyone who needs anything like it, including people the business would rather turn away. The positioning guide owns this cause: a position is defined against the alternatives for a particular segment, and a position is a trade-off: a business that stands clearly for one thing gives up standing for others.

Fix: write down who the business serves best and why, then rewrite the headline, the ad copy, the profile descriptions and the first lines of the service pages so a reader can tell within seconds whether the offer is meant for them. Show the kinds of jobs and customers in photographs and case notes as well as words.

Verify: the share of enquiries tagged as the wrong job or the wrong kind of buyer falls across several channels, not only the one where the copy changed first.

Prevent: keep the written statement of who the business is for beside every brief, and check new campaigns and pages against it before they go live.

Reach that goes beyond the customers served

A local firm advertising across a whole region, a specialist supplier using broad interest audiences, or a directory listing set to every category all reach people who cannot be served however good the message is. The segmentation guide owns this cause, including the point that a platform audience only approximates a segment and that the match has to be checked rather than assumed.

Fix: list the segments the business actually serves, by place, size, need and budget, and compare them with the targeting of every channel: location settings, audience definitions, directory categories and the areas named on the site. Narrow each to the segments served and exclude the rest. For business buyers, an ideal customer profile built from your own records adds written disqualifiers that targeting and routing can use, and the Ideal Customer Profile it produces gives every channel the same definition.

Verify: enquiries tagged as outside the area or the wrong size fall, while booked work from the served segments holds or rises.

Prevent: review targeting against the written Segmentation whenever a campaign, a listing or an agency changes, because broad defaults creep back in.

Terms that stay hidden until the call

When the price range, the minimum job, the area covered or the waiting time appears only in conversation, every person outside those conditions still enquires, and someone spends time discovering they cannot be helped. The forms guide owns this cause in its section on fields and qualification: a field earns its place when the next step or the routing depends on it, and asking for the location early lets a local service check it covers the address before anything else is asked.

Fix: state the conditions plainly where people decide to enquire: on the service page, beside the form and in the ad or listing where space allows. Add a single qualifying question only where the answer changes what happens next, such as the postcode for a local service or the type of job.

Verify: enquiries tagged as left at the price or below the minimum fall, and completion among people who do qualify does not drop.

Prevent: include the visible conditions in every landing page brief, and update them on every surface the day a price, minimum or service area changes.

An offer that pulls in bargain hunters

A large discount on a first job, a free inspection or a cheap entry service attracts people for the deal. In general practice some of them become good customers, while others take the offer and do not return, or enquire only to compare prices. The guide to planning promotions owns this cause, and its section on who should be eligible treats eligibility as the main lever for limiting who a discount reaches, including people who would have paid full price anyway.

Fix: decide what the offer is for, restrict who can claim it, or replace the discount with something only a real buyer values, such as a maintenance plan, a priority booking slot or a guarantee.

Verify: enquiries during the offer convert to booked work at full terms more often than before, and the share tagged as left at the price falls.

Prevent: give every promotion a stated job and an eligibility rule before it runs, and review its outcomes by source afterwards rather than its enquiry count.

A target that rewards the count

If the plan, the agency report or a bonus is built on enquiry numbers, every channel is tuned to produce more of them: broader audiences, softer qualifying, cheaper placements and easier forms. The guide to objectives and KPIs owns this cause and warns that making lead volume the measure produces cheap, unqualified leads; the framework page on Goodhart's law explains why a number stops describing the business once people are rewarded for moving it.

Fix: make customers won, or enquiries that meet the written definition of qualified, the KPI, with the enquiry count shown beneath it as a diagnostic. Track the Cost per Qualified Lead by channel; the CPA calculator turns spend and qualified enquiries into that figure.

Verify: channel owners start reporting qualified enquiries and customers per source, and budget moves towards the sources that win work.

Prevent: have whoever answers enquiries own the definition of qualified, so the people judged by the number cannot quietly change it.

No record of which enquiries became customers

When nobody records the outcome of each enquiry against its source, the report can only count enquiries, and ad platforms set to find more conversions find more people like those who fill in forms, whatever they are worth. The guide to connecting the CRM to ads and analytics owns this cause: it covers capturing the click identifier with the enquiry and sending outcomes back, including the Offline Conversion Import pattern.

Fix: record each enquiry's source and outcome in one place, even if that place is a spreadsheet at first; then send booked or won outcomes back to the platforms that can use them, and report the Lead-to-Customer Rate by source each month. The inbound lead handling playbook sets out the closing-the-loop step and who owns it.

Verify: each month's report shows customers won by source, and campaigns optimised on outcomes begin bringing enquiries that book more often.

Prevent: make the outcome field compulsory before an enquiry can be closed, and check monthly that every source still passes its identifier through.

Prevention: a written customer, visible terms and outcomes recorded by source

The fixes above share three habits. Built into the routine, they keep poor-fit enquiries from creeping back as campaigns, agencies and people change.

A written customer. Keep a short description of who the business serves best and who it does not, agreed by the people who sell and deliver. Brief every campaign, page and listing against it, and give each new agency or freelancer a copy before they set up an account. When the business changes what it offers or where it works, change the description first and the targeting second.

Visible terms. Wherever a person decides whether to get in touch, they should be able to see the conditions that would rule them out: the area, the minimum job, price guidance where it can be given, and the current lead time. Keep these in one place that every surface draws from, so a change reaches the site, the listings and the ads together rather than one at a time.

Outcomes recorded by source. Every enquiry carries its source and, once known, its outcome tag. Each month, read the tags by source beside spend: which sources produce customers, which produce mostly poor-fit enquiries, and which reasons are growing. Move budget towards sources that win work, and treat a source whose poor-fit share is rising as a question for the targeting or the offer behind it, not for the person answering the phone. The tutorial on keeping an enquiry record builds the sheet that holds these outcomes, with its columns, the source question and a monthly check against the business's other counts.

A regular read of the reasons. At each planning review, take a fresh sample of enquiries and repeat the check from the start of this page. Reasons shift: a new competitor, a changed price, a new platform audience or a seasonal offer can each bring a fresh group of people who cannot be served. A sample read regularly catches the shift while it is still small.

A shared report with sales or delivery. The people answering enquiries see poor fit first. Give them a standing place in the monthly review to bring examples, and agree that any change to the definition of qualified is made together and dated. The diagnosis of traffic that grows while sales stay flat applies the same discipline one step earlier, to visits rather than enquiries, and the marketing strategy troubleshooting hub lists the other programme-wide symptoms and where each is diagnosed.

A gutter cleaning firm stops paying for jobs it cannot take (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Draxumel Gutters sorts its enquiries

Draxumel Gutters, an invented gutter cleaning and repair firm, was receiving about 160 enquiries a month from ads, directory listings and a half-price first clean, yet its crews were booking only 28 jobs. The owner tagged one month's 158 enquiries by outcome: 49 were outside the area the crews cover, 37 were single small jobs below the £85 minimum call-out, 31 left once they heard the full price, 13 were never reachable and 28 booked.

The firm rewrote its promise around regular maintenance for terraced streets in its own area, tightened the location targeting on its ads and directory categories, and added the minimum call-out and a postcode check to the quote form. It replaced the half-price offer with a maintenance plan priced at £140 a year for two visits, changed its monthly target from enquiries to booked jobs, and fed booked jobs back to its ad accounts. Three months later it was receiving about 90 enquiries a month and booking 41 jobs, and its cost per booked job had fallen from £64 to £39.

Common mistakes

  • Blaming the platform first. Tuning one ad account when the same poor-fit reasons arrive from every channel.
  • Counting enquiries as success. Reporting enquiry volume as the result, which invites every channel to buy more of the wrong ones.
  • Hiding the price to keep enquiries up. Saving the conditions for the call, so staff spend their days telling people the job cannot be done.
  • Adding fields instead of signals. Making the form longer to filter people out, when showing the area and the minimum on the page would sort them before they start.
  • Discounting to fill the diary. Running deep first-job offers that bring in people who never pay full price.
  • Leaving outcomes in someone's head. Knowing which enquiries became customers without recording it by source, so neither the report nor the ad platforms can learn from it.

Frequently asked questions

Should we add more questions to the form to filter out poor enquiries?

Only questions that change what happens next. Asking for the location when the service is local, or the type of job when some jobs are not taken, sorts people before anyone spends time on them. Questions asked merely to make the form harder put off good customers as well as poor ones. Showing the area, the minimum job or the starting price on the page often does more than any extra field, because people who cannot be served simply do not enquire.

Our enquiries fell after we fixed the targeting. Did we make things worse?

Not if booked work held steady or rose. Fewer enquiries from people you could never serve is the intended result, and it frees the time that was spent answering them. Judge the change on customers won and on the cost of each qualified enquiry, read from your own records over a period long enough to mean something, not on the raw enquiry count.

Who decides what counts as the wrong kind of customer?

The people who serve and sell to customers, written down with the owner or leadership and shared with marketing. A wrong customer is one the business cannot serve well or profitably, such as someone outside the area, below the minimum job or needing something the business does not offer. Writing the reasons as a short list of outcomes lets every enquiry be tagged the same way, so the pattern is visible rather than a matter of opinion.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Frameworks

Sources

  1. Digital Marketing and Measurement Model — Avinash Kaushik

Related