Definition
A discussion guide is the written plan for a qualitative research session. The customer interviews tutorial describes it as a plan for the conversation, not a script: it opens with an easy warm-up, moves to the specific episode the team wants to reconstruct and spends most of the session there, with open questions about past behaviour and a list of probes. Hypothetical questions and the business's own product come last, if at all.
The name covers several formats. An interview guide, a guide for a group and a guide for a call with an industry expert share the same skeleton but differ in what they ask for, and each belongs to one study's learning goal rather than being reused unchanged.
What a discussion guide contains
An introduction and warm-up. Purpose, consent and the reassurance that there are no right answers, then a few easy questions about the person's role or week.
The episode. The core of a customer guide is one real occasion: what was happening when the need arose, what the person tried first, what they compared, what nearly stopped them and what tipped the decision. The customer interviews tutorial uses the jobs-to-be-done structure for this section.
Open questions and probes. Questions start from "tell me about the last time" rather than "would you", and probes such as "what happened next?" and "why was that important?" are written down so they get asked.
A close. A question about what the researcher should have asked and did not, and the next steps.
In practice: interviews, groups, expert calls and commissioned research
The research session readiness checklist asks for a guide built for the format of the session, and lists the draft guide among the materials to have ready before the first booking. A guide for a group plans for who speaks and when people write things down alone; an interview guide does not need to.
For expert and trade conversations, the guide to interviewing industry experts keeps the same skeleton but asks for the expert's general picture rather than their personal story, and asks for the basis of every claim. It also suggests writing the study's competition-law rules into the guide, so everyone running interviews knows which topics are out of bounds.
Upstream, the research brief template records the topics the guide must cover and any it must avoid, so the guide is written against a decision rather than a list of curiosities. Downstream, when an agency runs the fieldwork, the guide to commissioning a research agency has the business sign off the guide, with the screener and the consent wording, before fieldwork starts, because that is the last cheap moment to remove a question that leads.
A nursery group rebuilds its interview guide around the week parents chose
Jailteth Childcare ran 6 interviews with parents who had enrolled a child in the previous 4 months. Its first guide asked what parents thought of the fees, the opening hours and the website. The answers were polite and interchangeable, and 5 of the 6 sessions ended up as a discussion of price. The researcher rewrote the guide around one episode: the week each parent decided. Starting from "tell me about the day you first started looking", the next 8 interviews heard who they asked, which settings they shortlisted and what nearly put them off. In 7 of those 8, the visit to the setting was the moment the decision tipped, often because of how staff greeted the child. The group moved effort from its fee page to booking and running visits.
Related terms
A ScreenerThe short questionnaire that confirms each research candidate fits a study, asking about recent behaviour without revealing which answers qualify. decides who gets into the room; the discussion guide decides what happens once they are there. In a Focus GroupA moderated discussion among a small set of people who share an experience, used to hear how people talk about a category together and react to material., the guide carries extra work, because it has to manage group dynamics as well as topics. A Leading QuestionA survey or interview question whose wording contains or suggests its expected answer, producing measurement bias rather than evidence. is the most common fault a guide review looks for, since a guide that leads produces confident findings in the wrong direction. A Diary StudyA qualitative method in which a small set of people record, at the time it happens, what they do during an episode that unfolds over days or weeks. replaces the live guide with prompts sent over days or weeks, which ask what happened rather than for opinions.
Common confusions
- A discussion guide is a script. Reading questions in order turns a conversation into a spoken survey. The guide is there to make sure the important ground is covered, not to fix the order.
- A discussion guide is the same as a questionnaire. A questionnaire fixes the wording and the answer options so that answers can be counted; a guide plans open conversation whose answers are interpreted.
- One guide fits every study. The structure carries over, but the episode, the probes and the topics to avoid come from the learning goal of each study and the format of each session.
- More questions make a better guide. A guide crowded with questions leaves no time for the reconstructed episode, which should take the largest share of the session.
