Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Glossary term

Fake Review

A review not based on a genuine experience, such as one written by the business, paid for without the experience or bought from a service.
StrategyconceptUpdated

Definition

A fake review is a review that is not based on a genuine experience of the product, service or business it describes. The guide to reviews and social proof for stores, setting out principles from the FTC's business guidance on advertising and endorsements, gives the core cases: reviews the business writes for its own products, reviews paid for from people who did not genuinely experience the product, and reviews bought from a service. Fake negative reviews of a competitor fall under the same heading.

Two further cases follow from the definition. Reviews written by staff or written on a customer's behalf are fake reviews, as the review request launch checklist records. And a review generated by an AI tool is a fake review whatever prompt produced it, a point the guide to writing product reviews and roundups repeats for editorial reviews: the experience has to be the tester's.

What the guides record: prohibited practices and selective asking

The reviews guides draw on the FTC's business guidance and endorsement guides and on the Competition and Markets Authority, and between them state one direction. Fake reviews are prohibited. Asking only customers likely to be positive, or suppressing negative feedback, misrepresents the overall picture in the same way that invented reviews would. Incentives cannot depend on what the customer writes, and incentivised reviews have to be identified as such. Connections between a reviewer and the business must be disclosed.

That makes the boundary wider than the word "fake" suggests. A business can publish only genuine reviews and still mislead, by choosing which ones appear, delaying the critical ones or sending the request only to people who said they were happy. Rules also differ by platform: the checklist notes that the local reviews guide reads Google's help centre as prohibiting any incentive on a business profile, and that both app stores prohibit incentivising ratings.

In practice: asking everyone on the same terms and replying to fakes

The safe way to collect reviews is the opposite of faking them: ask every customer, in the same way, at the same point, with nothing that depends on sentiment. For a chain, the guide to managing reviews across many locations adds that the risk often comes from how head office measures branches; a staff target or prize draw tied to review counts is an incentive in its own right.

Businesses also receive fake reviews. The local reviews and reputation management guide covers the reply, and the tutorial on app ratings and review replies points to it for unfair or fake reviews, where a calm factual correction, or the platform's own reporting route, does more than a public argument. In a chain, the multi-location guide routes a review that looks fake to the centre, which reports it, while the branch checks its records.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A cottage company turns down a review package

Gloungenny Holiday Cottages opened a new 3-bedroom property with no reviews, beside its 11 established cottages averaging 4.7 stars. A marketing service offered a package of 25 five-star reviews within a fortnight. The owner declined. Instead, every guest at every cottage received the same request 2 days after checkout, with no offer attached and no question about how the stay went first. The new cottage had 9 reviews after 10 weeks, one of them a 2-star review from someone whose booking records showed they had never stayed. The owner reported it through the platform and posted a short reply stating that no booking matched the review and inviting the writer to get in touch. The platform removed it 3 weeks later.

A Review Request is the legitimate way to build reviews, and its rules mirror the ones a fake review breaks: everyone is asked, and nothing depends on the rating. A Material Connection, such as employment, family ties or payment, must be disclosed wherever a connected review is allowed at all, and the local reviews guidance goes further by never asking staff, family or partners. A Testimonial is an endorsement the business selects and presents itself, so it too must come from a genuine customer's own account. Social Proof is what all of these exist to supply, and what fake reviews counterfeit.

Common confusions

  • Only invented reviews count as fake. The guides treat suppressing negative reviews and asking only happy customers as misrepresenting the picture in the same way.
  • Any incentivised review is fake. Where a platform allows an incentive at all, a review from someone who genuinely used the product, rewarded whatever they wrote and labelled as incentivised, is not fake. A review paid for without the experience is.
  • An AI-written review based on real feedback is fine. A generated review is a fake review whatever prompt produced it.
  • Replying angrily is the way to deal with a fake review. A calm, factual reply and the platform's reporting route do more, and the reply is read by future customers.

More terms to look up

Where this term is used

Sources

  1. FTC Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking — Federal Trade Commission
  2. Competition and Markets Authority — GOV.UK

Related