Definition
An in-app message is content an app displays within its own interface during a session, triggered by what the person does or the screen they reach. It differs from a push notification in where it appears and who it can reach. A push notification is delivered through the operating system to someone outside the app, and only to people who allowed notifications. An in-app message appears inside a session the person started, so it reaches everyone using the app and depends on no opt-in.
The guide to push notifications and in-app messaging sums up the split: push earns a return visit, while an in-app message helps the person get more from the visit they are already making.
In practice: banners, tooltips, modals and pre-prompts
The formats differ in how much of the screen they take and so in how much attention they demand.
- Tooltips point at one element on the screen in use, the lightest form of guidance.
- Banners sit at the edge of the screen and leave the task in view.
- Cards appear in a feed or on return, and can hold an unfinished step or a record of messages that can wait, such as an in-app inbox.
- Modals take over the screen and stop the task until they are closed, which suits only messages that matter more than whatever the person was doing.
One in-app message has a special role: the soft prompt, or pre-prompt, shown before the operating system's notification request. It explains what notifications will do for this person at a moment when the value is obvious, and only if they agree does the app show the system prompt, which on iOS can be shown only once. A declined soft prompt costs nothing; a declined system prompt is hard to recover.
The guide to designing in-app messages sets out the placements that work, at a natural pause, at the point of need and on return, and the one to avoid: straight after launch, before the person has done anything the message could be relevant to. Every message also needs an exit condition, so that a tip stops once the feature has been used.
In-app messages versus push notifications
| Row label | In-app message | Push notification |
|---|---|---|
| Where it appears | Inside the app, during a session | Lock screen, notification centre, banners over other apps |
| Who it reaches | Anyone currently using the app | Only people who allowed notifications |
| Main job | Guide, explain, offer at the moment of use | Bring people back for something timely or personal |
| Main risk | Blocking tasks, teaching people to dismiss without reading | Disabled notifications or an uninstall |
The two are planned together, because people experience them as one app talking to them. One frequency cap should cover both, and the tutorial on notification preferences by topic includes persistent in-app messages, such as inbox cards, in the inventory of everything an app sends. When the same users also receive email and texts, the coordination widens: the tutorial on software onboarding emails lets in-app guidance handle a step while the user is in the product and sends the email only if they leave, and the guide to SMS and messaging for retention places in-app messages as the route that spends no notification goodwill at all.
A recipe app moves its welcome message
Whiskladle Recipe Box showed every new user a full-screen modal on first launch, listing five features before they had seen a single recipe. In a two-week test, half of new users kept the modal and half saw nothing on launch and a small banner after saving their first recipe, suggesting they add it to a weekly plan. Of 4,800 new users in each group, 37% of the modal group ended their first session without saving a recipe, against 28% of the banner group. Weekly plans created in the first seven days rose from 11% to 16%. The team retired the launch modal and wrote exit conditions for every remaining message.
Related terms
A Push NotificationA message an app sends through the operating system's notification service, shown on the device outside the app to people who allowed notifications. is the out-of-app counterpart, delivered through the operating system to people who allowed it. The Push Opt-In RateShare of app users shown the notification permission prompt who allowed notifications. is the share of people who grant notification permission, and the in-app soft prompt is one of the main things that moves it. A Deep LinkA link that opens a specific screen inside a mobile app rather than its home screen. sends a tap on a message to the exact screen it mentions. Activation RateThe share of new users or sign-ups who complete the activation event, the action marking first real value, within a set window. is the measure in-app onboarding messages usually serve, since their job is to bring new users to the first moment of value.
Common confusions
- In-app messages are free to send. They cost no permission, but each one spends attention, and too many teach people to dismiss everything.
- They are push notifications shown inside the app. They do a different job, with different triggers and limits.
- Opening the app is a good trigger. It gives the message no behaviour to be relevant to.
- Only marketing teams send them. Product, support and engineering often send them too, which is why one cap and one inventory are needed.
- The most visible format works best. A modal gets seen and also gets in the way; a lighter format at the right moment usually does more.
