Definition
The GDPR's article on the lawfulness of processing lists six grounds on which processing personal data is lawful. Processing needs at least one of them:
- Consent: the person has given consent for one or more specific purposes.
- Contract: the processing is necessary to perform a contract with the person, or to take steps they asked for before entering into one.
- Legal obligation: it is necessary to comply with a legal obligation the organisation is subject to.
- Vital interests: it is necessary to protect someone's life.
- Public task: it is necessary for a task carried out in the public interest or in the exercise of official authority.
- Legitimate interests: it is necessary for the legitimate interests of the organisation or a third party, except where those interests are overridden by the interests or fundamental rights and freedoms of the person, in particular where the person is a child.
The word "necessary" in five of the six matters. Those bases cover processing that is needed for the stated purpose, not everything that would be convenient once the data is held. Consent has its own conditions: the regulation describes it as freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous, and withdrawing it must be as easy as giving it.
In practice: choosing and recording a basis per purpose
The working unit is the purpose. A retailer's loyalty scheme, as the retail industry guide explains, involves several uses of the same data, and each needs a lawful basis. The real estate industry guide makes the same point about applicant registrations and valuation requests, and the guide to product-qualified leads treats routing a named user's product usage to a seller as processing that needs a basis decided with whoever owns compliance first.
Three habits follow from the regulation's accountability principle, which expects the business to be able to show that it complies. The basis is identified before the processing starts, not reconstructed when someone asks. It is recorded beside the purpose it covers. And it is revisited when the purpose changes, because data collected for one purpose cannot simply be reused for an incompatible one. The guide to AI disclosure and data privacy asks the same question of AI tools: is there a lawful basis for this processing, and was the data collected for this purpose or a compatible one.
Lawful basis versus consent for marketing messages
Two different sets of rules meet in marketing. The GDPR governs processing the personal data. Separate rules on electronic marketing govern sending the message: the ICO's direct marketing guidance explains when emails and texts need consent, the narrow case in which existing customers may be marketed similar products if they were given a simple way to opt out, and the requirement to offer an opt-out in every message. A business can therefore have a sound lawful basis for holding a contact's details and still be unable to email them marketing. The comparison of first-party and third-party data adds the supplier question: with bought data, consent and lawful basis depend on someone else's collection practices, which the buyer has to verify.
A garden room builder separates quote follow-up from its newsletter
Shedlumen Garden Rooms receives about 90 quote requests a month through its website. Its records list two purposes for the details people enter. Following up the quote they asked for, by phone within a few days, is recorded with legitimate interests as the basis, with a note of why a person requesting a price would expect a call about it. Adding them to the monthly newsletter is a different purpose: the form carries an unticked box for it, and only the 31 people a month who tick it on average join the list, with the wording they saw and the date stored beside each address. Anyone who later declines a call is added to a do-not-contact list that every follow-up checks.
Related terms
The GDPRThe EU regulation setting the rules for processing personal data, including its principles, lawful bases, individuals' rights and breach duties. is the regulation that sets out the six bases and the principles they sit within. A lawful basis is needed only for Personal DataAny information relating to an identified or identifiable living person, such as a name, email address, location data or an online identifier., but that category is broad enough to cover most marketing records. Double Opt-InA sign-up process in which the subscriber confirms through a link sent to the address given. is a sign-up practice that leaves a clear record of a person's request to join a list, useful evidence where consent is relied on. A Suppression ListA list of addresses or contacts excluded from every send, such as unsubscribes, hard bounces and spam complaints. keeps people who have opted out or objected away from future sends, which is how a business honours those choices across every tool.
Common confusions
- Consent is always required. It is one of six bases; for some purposes another basis fits better, and the electronic marketing rules decide separately when a message needs consent.
- Legitimate interests means any business interest. The basis requires the processing to be necessary and the interest not to be overridden by the person's interests or rights.
- One basis covers everything a business does with a record. Each purpose needs its own, and a new purpose needs checking against the one the data was collected for.
- The basis can be chosen after a complaint. It is identified and recorded before processing starts.
- A lawful basis makes a bought list usable. The basis depends on how the data was collected and what people were told, which a buyer has to verify rather than assume.
