Why this matters
Every competitive deal lost after a demo wastes the acquisition cost (CACCost to acquire one new customer.) already spent getting there, and late losses often turn on answers given in the moment. The competitive battlecards guide sets out a card sales will use: short, sourced, honest about losses and current. The pricing and packaging guide explains why the pricing metric, not the list price, often decides how a buyer compares two offers. This vendor's losses turn out to be as much about how it charges as about what it sells.
The vendor and its losing deals
Ashlock Sourcing is an invented vendor of sourcing software for mid-sized companies. Its main rival is Tendrell Procure, an invented larger suite vendor. Ashlock's salespeople improvise on price and integrations, and some discount heavily to match.
Ashlock Sourcing: win-loss and public information
Head-to-head deals last year: 40, of which Ashlock won 14. Product marketing interviewed 12 buyers, 6 who chose Ashlock and 6 who chose Tendrell.
| Theme | Raised by buyers who chose Tendrell | Raised by buyers who chose Ashlock |
|---|---|---|
| Tendrell's ready-made ERP connectors | 5 of 6 | 1 of 6 |
| Ashlock looked dearer for many users | 4 of 6 | 0 of 6 |
| Slow answers to the security questionnaire | 3 of 6 | 0 of 6 |
| Faster implementation | 0 of 6 | 5 of 6 |
| Supplier portal easier for suppliers | 1 of 6 | 4 of 6 |
| Responsive support | 0 of 6 | 3 of 6 |
- Users per deal: median 20 in deals Ashlock won, 55 in deals it lost.
- Ashlock: £60 per user per month, £6,000 implementation, annual contracts. Buyers in won deals reported go-live in about six weeks.
- Tendrell's public pricing page: platform fee £15,000 a year plus a sourcing module at £6,000 a year, three-year minimum term, partner implementation "from £25,000". Review sites describe implementations of four to six months. Its release notes announce a new supplier portal next quarter.
- Ashlock salespeople currently discount by up to 30% when price comes up.
From win-loss notes to a fair battlecard
Start with the themes, not the feature list. Losses that cluster around one capability become a "why we lose" line with a response, not something to hide. Wins buyers mention unprompted become the proof. Public information, gathered as the competitive intelligence guide describes, sets the rival's claims and prices, and every line on the card needs a source and a date. The test for each claim is whether Ashlock could defend it if the buyer forwarded the card to Tendrell.
Task
- Read the win-loss table and user counts, and state where Ashlock wins and loses.
- Compare three-year cost for a buyer at the won-deal and lost-deal sizes, and find where the two cross.
- Write the card's front section: who Tendrell is, when Ashlock meets it, why Ashlock wins and loses.
- Write responses to the top objections, three landmine questions and the pricing story.
- Recommend any packaging change to the pricing owner.
- Plan training, placement, measures and upkeep.
Worked answer
Ashlock Sourcing: three-year cost comparison
Ashlock over three years: 36 months × £60 × users + £6,000 = £2,160 × users + £6,000. Tendrell over three years: 3 × (£15,000 + £6,000) + £25,000 = £88,000, before any partner overrun.
At 20 users: Ashlock £49,200 against £88,000. At 55 users: Ashlock £124,800 against £88,000. The two cross at about (£88,000 − £6,000) ÷ £2,160 ≈ 38 users.
A 30% discount on licences at 55 users still leaves Ashlock at about £89,000, so matching price by discount gives away margin without winning on cost.
Where Ashlock wins and loses. It wins smaller deals on speed, supplier experience and support, and loses larger ones on integrations and a per-user price that grows with every occasional requester. The security losses are fixable.
Front section.
- Who they are: a larger suite built around ERP connectors, sold to finance-led procurement teams, three-year terms, partner-led implementation.
- When we meet them: mid-sized companies buying their first sourcing platform; the larger the user count, the likelier the loss.
- Why we win: buyers report going live in weeks, suppliers onboard without help, support answers quickly.
- Why we lose: ready-made connectors for more ERP systems; cost at high user counts; slow security answers.
Objections and responses. "Tendrell connects to our ERP out of the box." Confirm which system, show the supported connector or documented interface, and offer a technical call; if Ashlock lacks it, say so and qualify honestly. "You're more expensive." Move to three-year total cost with implementation and time to value, using the buyer's real user count. "Is it secure?" Send the pre-completed security pack the same day; product marketing builds it this quarter.
Landmine questions. How soon must the first category run through the system? Who will support suppliers through onboarding? What will implementation cost in total? Each surfaces a real need where Tendrell is weaker.
Pricing story. Below the crossover, Ashlock costs less over three years and goes live sooner. Above it, do not discount licences to match; sell time to value or qualify out. The card quotes Tendrell's prices only from its public page, dated.
Packaging recommendation. The pricing metric penalises wide adoption, as the pricing guide warns. Propose charging only buyer seats, with occasional requesters free, and test it on the lost-deal profile before it reaches the card.
Training, use and upkeep. Run role-play with one representative voicing Tendrell's claims, and add the card to onboarding, as the sales content and training guide describes. Attach it to the opportunity record whenever Tendrell is tagged. Track card opens in competitive deals, win rate against Tendrell by user band and average discount as the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. set, with stage losses read down the FunnelModel of the customer journey stages.. Review the card monthly while Tendrell is the main rival, with a triggered update when its supplier portal launches, and show the owner and review date on the front.
Common mistakes
- Hiding the losses. Representatives know the integration gap and stop trusting the card.
- Matching price with discount. It gives away margin without changing the comparison.
- Unsourced claims about the rival. One wrong claim in front of a buyer ends the card's credibility.
- Publishing without rehearsal. An unpractised card is rarely used live.
Bring this into the business-to-business revenue strategy capstone or revisit the intermediate business-to-business level.
