Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

B2B Marketing › Intermediate

Designing a Lead Scoring Model for a Freight Software Platform

Practise replacing a send-everything hand-off with a scoring model sales will trust. You read an invented freight software company's leads and outcomes, choose fit and engagement criteria, set gates, weights, decay and the hand-off threshold, test the model on sample leads and design the nurture for everyone who falls short.
ExerciseIntermediate levelModule 2: Scoring, nurture and alignment5 minUpdated

Why this matters

When every download reaches sales, salespeople sort the queue by instinct and stop trusting marketing's leads. The lead scoring guide sets the test: people above the line close at a visibly higher rate than those below it. The nurture sequences guide covers everyone the score keeps on marketing's side, and the sales and marketing alignment guide the agreement both rely on.

The platform and its leads

Cratehollow Logistics Software is an invented company whose software plans loads, routes and driver shifts for hauliers and for shippers with their own vehicles. Two salespeople receive every demo request, download and webinar registration, and say most are a waste of a call. Cratehollow has no customer data platform (CDP): the CRM and the marketing automation tool hold every field the model can use.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Cratehollow: last quarter's leads and what became of them

Lead groupLeadsBecame opportunitiesWon
Demo request, fleet of 20 or more vehicles, transport or operations role60248
Demo request, fleet under 204561
Rate-card template download, fleet of 20 or more, transport role140103
Rate-card template download, fleet under 20 or unknown38040
Known contacts viewing pricing twice or more in a week, fleet of 20 or more70124
Webinar attended live, fleet of 20 or more5062
Webinar registered, not attended9020
Students, job seekers and competitor domains5500
Existing customers using the download form40Not applicableNot applicable
Outside the UK and Ireland, which Cratehollow cannot serve3500
Total9656418

Won deals came mostly from hauliers and own-fleet shippers planning in spreadsheets, led by a transport manager, operations director or managing director.

Choosing the scoring criteria

Keep fit and engagement as separate scores, so a well-placed director who has done nothing is never confused with a student who has read every page. Put disqualifiers in gates, not large negative points. Give engagement a rolling window and caps, give demo requests their own route, set the threshold from where past wins sat and expect to calibrate it.

Task

  1. List the gates that remove a lead from prospect scoring altogether.
  2. Choose the fit criteria and their weights from the won-deal pattern.
  3. Choose the engagement criteria, weights, caps, negative signals and decay rule.
  4. Set the hand-off threshold and the rule for demo requests.
  5. Score the sample leads in the worked answer and check the routes.
  6. Design the nurture for leads below the threshold: branches, goal events, exits and a holdout.
  7. Write the sales service level and the measure that shows whether the model works.

Worked answer

Gates. Outside the UK and Ireland; competitor domains; students and job seekers; existing customers, who move to a separate expansion model.

Fit and engagement. Fleet size and role separate the won deals most clearly, so they carry the most weight. Engagement favours what preceded opportunities: pricing views, demo requests and live attendance. A download is interest, not intent, and opens score nothing.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Cratehollow: the first scoring model

Fit criterionPoints
Fleet of 50 or more vehicles / 20 to 49 / 5 to 19 / under 5 or unknown40 / 35 / 15 / 0
Transport manager, operations director or managing director / planner or fleet administrator / other30 / 15 / 0
Haulier or shipper with own fleet / forwarder without vehicles20 / 5
Plans in spreadsheets or on paper / uses a rival system10 / 0
Engagement criterion, rolling 30 daysPointsCap
Pricing page viewed15 each30
Case study or comparison page viewed10 each20
Webinar attended live / registered only20 / 520
Template downloaded55
Email link clicked5 each10
Careers page viewedminus 20Not applicable

Hand-off: fit of 60 or more and engagement of 40 or more. A demo request goes to sales at once whatever the scores; if fit is blank, the record is enriched and reviewed rather than queued behind nurture.

Sample leadFitEngagementRoute
Transport manager, haulier, 35 vehicles, spreadsheets; pricing twice and a case study35 + 30 + 20 + 10 = 9530 + 10 = 40Sales
Fleet administrator, haulier, 12 vehicles, spreadsheets; download and live webinar15 + 15 + 20 + 10 = 605 + 20 = 25Nurture
Operations director, own-fleet shipper, 60 vehicles, rival system; download only40 + 30 + 20 + 0 = 905Nurture, switching branch
Student email domain; downloadGateNot scoredRemoved
Demo request, fleet field blankUnknownDemo requestSales, after enrichment

On last quarter's data the queue shrinks from 965 leads to roughly 200 while the groups behind most of the 64 opportunities still reach it. The 140 qualified downloaders, with 10 opportunities, now start in nurture, which must bring them back quickly.

Nurture. Three branches. High fit with low engagement enters a sequence on moving from spreadsheets to planned loads: a comparison of the two ways of working, a case study from a haulier of similar size, a pricing and implementation explainer, then a plain-text note from a named salesperson. Rival-system users get a switching branch. Low fit receives the newsletter only and is re-scored when enrichment changes. A pricing view or demo request is the goal event and exits the lead to sales; unsubscribes, replies and a salesperson taking the record also exit it. A small random holdout stays out of each branch.

Service level and measure. Sales contacts demo requests the same business day and scored leads within one business day, accepting or returning each with a reason code. The model's KPI is the conversion rate (CVR) to opportunity above the line against below it, reviewed quarterly with sales.

Common mistakes

  • One blended score. Fit and engagement in a single number that nobody can act on.
  • Demo requests waiting on a score. The clearest buyer waits because a field was blank.
  • Nurture with no exit. A lead who requests a demo keeps receiving the sequence.
  • A threshold nobody revisits. Without calibration the line drifts from what closes.

Next, take the scoring and alignment checkpoint or return to the intermediate business-to-business level.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related