What this checkpoint covers
The questions draw on the branding hub, the brand strategy guide and the positioning statement framework. None asks for a definition; each asks for a judgement you would have to make for a real business.
Task
- Write an answer and one line of reasoning for every question before reading any explanation.
- Mark yourself right only when your reasoning matches, not just your conclusion.
- Reread the linked section for any question you missed, then revisit the gin distillery brand strategy exercise with a business you know.
Questions
- A bakery owner says the brand is finished because a designer has delivered a new logo and colour palette. What would you tell her?
- A bicycle repair shop writes its audience line as "Sam, a commuter who rides every day". What is the risk, and how would you rewrite it?
- A pottery studio's proof points read "quality, passion, creativity". What is wrong, and what would you ask the owner for?
- A tea company runs a new campaign line every quarter and calls each one its brand strategy. What has it confused?
- A plumbing firm's positioning statement still reads as true when a rival's name is swapped in. What does that tell you, and what do you change first?
- A florist wants to target only customers who are ready to order today. What does the brand lose by ignoring the rest of the FunnelModel of the customer journey stages.?
- A cider maker lists ten distinctive assets in its strategy. What would you advise?
- A start-up sets "brand awareness" as its measure but records no starting figure. Why does that matter?
Answers explained
-
A logo is part of the identity, not the brand. The brand is what people remember and feel about the bakery when they choose, built from every contact. The identity should express a strategy that sets who the bakery is for and what it promises. The table of what a brand is and is not makes this distinction directly.
-
A persona has replaced the market. One imagined rider can guide creative, but the audience line should describe the category buyers the shop wants to be remembered by, such as people in the area who own a bike and need it fixed occasionally. Drawing the line narrowly limits ReachUnique people who saw an ad. to the customers the team finds easiest to picture. See audience and category.
-
Those are claims, not proof. Proof is specific and checkable: a firing process a customer can watch, a repair guarantee, a named material. Ask the owner what a sceptical buyer could verify, and retire anything that cannot be. The positioning, promise and proof section sets the test.
-
It has confused campaigns with strategy. A brand strategy changes rarely and fixes the audience, position, promise and assets; campaigns express it and can change every quarter. A new line each quarter with no stable position underneath teaches customers nothing that lasts. The brand strategy FAQs separate the two.
-
The position is not distinctive. The substitution test has failed, so the statement has not chosen anything a competitor could not also claim. Start with the key benefit and the reason to believe, which are usually where the generic wording sits. See testing a statement.
-
Future buyers. Most people who will need flowers next month are not shopping today. A brand that only speaks to ready buyers will not be remembered when the others enter the market, and the ready buyers themselves become harder and dearer to win. The brand and performance section explains how the two depend on each other.
-
Choose two or three and use them relentlessly. A system nobody can remember is not a system, and recognition comes from years of consistent use. See distinctive assets.
-
Without a baseline the result cannot be judged. Any later figure could be growth, decline or noise. Record the starting point before any new activity, alongside measures such as Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility.. The first branding programme lists setting the baseline as its own step.
Where to go next
If you answered most questions with matching reasoning, move on to the identity and voice module in the beginner level. If questions on proof or positioning tripped you up, rewrite the proof points and positioning statement from the gin distillery exercise for a local business you know, then run the substitution test on it.
