Brief
Greystone Credit Union is an invented, member-owned savings and loans provider serving people who live or work in a group of towns in the English Midlands. It offers savings accounts, small personal loans and a children's savings club, and it is run by a volunteer board with a small paid staff. Last year it merged with Tollbridge Community Savings, a smaller credit union in a neighbouring town, which still trades under its own name, branch sign and website. The children's club has its own name, Acorn Savers, and its own leaflets.
The board wants membership to grow among working adults under forty, who mostly bank with large high-street and app-based banks and do not know credit unions offer anything for them. It is willing to fund brand building for a year but wants to know, at the end, whether people in the area know Greystone better than before and think of it for the right reasons. The chief executive's words: "Most people here walk past our door and have no idea what we are."
Inputs and constraints
Greystone: members, awareness and competition
| Item | Greystone | Tollbridge | Acorn Savers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Members | 11,400 | 2,100 | 1,300 children (accounts opened by parents, most of them members) |
| Members under 40 | 22% | 15% | Not applicable |
| Prompted awareness among adults in its own area (local panel, 600 respondents, last year) | 26% | 31% in its own town | 4% |
| Unprompted awareness when asked to name places to save or borrow locally | 3% | 5% in its own town | Not asked |
| Category estimate for the area | Figure |
|---|---|
| Adults living or working in the common bond area | about 310,000 |
| Brand advertising by banks, building societies and lenders reaching the area each year (agency estimate) | £1.6 million to £2.4 million |
| Greystone's share of local savings and loan accounts (estimate from member numbers) | about 2% |
| Greystone and Tollbridge brand spend last year combined | £18,000 |
Budget for next year: £140,000 excluding staff, of which the board asks that no more than £10,000 is spent on research. Planning costs per thousand impressions: local radio £9, online video £13, social £5, out-of-home near stations and bus stops £7.
Constraints you must work within:
- Financial promotions must be fair, clear and not misleading, and every advert, page and press release needs sign-off by the compliance officer, who reviews a batch once a fortnight.
- Greystone may not quote members' experiences without their written permission; a handful have given it.
- Tollbridge members are attached to their name, and its branch is the only one in its town.
- The marketing team is one manager and a part-time content assistant; an agency can be hired for media buying.
Task
- Decide the architecture. Using the brand architecture guide, decide what happens to the Greystone, Tollbridge and Acorn Savers names: master brand, descriptor, endorsement or migration, with the evidence from the awareness data and the dates of any migration. Apply the method from the hotel group brand architecture exercise.
- Write the messaging. A core message, pillars and proof for the master brand, aimed at working adults under forty, with the variant any remaining name needs. Follow the messaging hierarchy and proof points guide and record the evidence for every objective claim so the compliance officer can check it.
- Set the brand objectives. Name the population, the measures and the targets: unprompted awareness, consideration and the associations the plan sets out to build, each as a key performance indicator (KPIA metric tied directly to an objective.) with a baseline and a date.
- Set the budget from share of voice. Follow the share of voice guide: estimate the category's spend as a range, choose a target share above market share, convert it to a budget and compare that with what the board will fund. Use the marketing budget calculator for the arithmetic and say what you will narrow if the target cannot be afforded: geography, period or audience.
- Plan the awareness campaign. A digital PR idea built on data or expertise Greystone genuinely has, following the guide to campaign ideation and data stories, and a media objective with reach (ReachUnique people who saw an ad.), frequency range and flights, as in the plant-based dairy awareness exercise. Lay out the lines in the media plan template, check delivery with the CPM calculator and the reach and frequency calculator, and brief the creative with the creative brief template, leaving time for compliance.
- Design the tracker. Population, screener, question order, sample per wave, cadence and the baseline date, following the brand awareness and lift guide and the survey and questionnaire design guide. Reuse the approach from the electric bike brand tracker exercise and fit it inside the research budget.
- Plan share of voice and supporting measures. Paid share of voice (Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility.) from the agency estimate, share of search against the main local alternatives, earned coverage from the PR work and branded search against a baseline, with the annotations each needs.
- Write the one-page plan. Every decision above on the one-page marketing plan template, with the detail in appendices, the dates on which each part will be judged and what the board will see at each review. Check each flight against the campaign launch QA checklist before it goes live.
Evaluation criteria
| Criterion | What a strong answer shows | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Architecture | Greystone as master brand, Tollbridge migrated or endorsed through a dated period that respects its members, Acorn Savers as a descriptor, each argued from the awareness data | Keeping all three names out of caution, or renaming Tollbridge overnight |
| Messaging | A core message the target adults would recognise, few pillars, each with proof the compliance officer can check | Pillars that are product features, or claims with nothing recorded beneath them |
| Objectives | Population defined as adults in the area, unprompted awareness and consideration as headline measures, baselines and dates | Prompted awareness as the headline, or members counted as the brand measure |
| Budget | A share of voice target and range compared honestly with the board's budget, with a stated narrowing of geography, period or audience | The full budget spread thinly across the whole area and year |
| Campaign | A PR idea from data Greystone holds, media objectives in reach and frequency, flights, caps and creative time for sign-off | An advert-led plan judged on account openings in the same month |
| Tracker | Unprompted before prompted, competitors included, a baseline before the first flight and a sample that fits the research budget | A survey launched after the campaign, or wording that leads |
| Share of voice and reporting | Paid share, share of search, coverage and branded search read on one page beside the tracker, with annotations | Share of voice reported alone, or against a flattering set of rivals |
A strong submission also says what the plan will not do this year, what would make the board change course at the half-year review, and which result would show that awareness rose for the wrong reasons.
Submission checklist
When you have finished, review your plan against the evaluation table, then return to the intermediate brand marketing level to mark the level complete.
