What this checkpoint covers
Mapleridge Dental Group is an invented group of dental practices with a shared website, a service page for each treatment, a page for each practice and a blog written by whoever had time. The questions draw on the keyword cannibalisation guide, the internal linking guide and the SEO content operations playbook, and they build on the stove maker consolidation exercise.
Task
Answer every question in a sentence or two with your reason before reading the explanations; count an answer as right only if the reasoning matches. Reread the linked page for each miss, then write the single operating rule that would have prevented most of these problems on your own site.
Questions
- The implants service page and a blog post explaining what implants are both receive impressions for the treatment's name. A colleague wants to merge them. What do you check, and what do you decide?
- The practice pages differ only in the town name and compete with each other for emergency appointment queries. Every practice is real and offers emergency slots. Merge, differentiate or remove?
- Two whitening posts were merged last month. The retired URL still serves its page with a canonical tag pointing to the survivor, and most internal links still point to the retired URL. What is wrong?
- An old post announcing a practice refit has no search traffic, no external links and describes a building the group has since sold. What do you do with it?
- A thorough guide to a child's first dental visit has a single inlink from deep in a paginated blog archive and barely ranks. How do you fix it?
- Across the library, the anchor "teeth whitening" points to the service page, a blog post and a price list. Why does that matter, and what is the rule?
- Each month the marketing coordinator publishes a post that overlaps an existing one. What operating rule stops it?
Answers explained
- Check intent before merging. Filter the query in GSCGoogle's search performance and indexing tool.: if the ranking URL alternates between the two pages for the same query, they compete. Then read the SERPThe page of results a search engine shows.: if it shows provider pages for the treatment name and explainers for the question form, the pages serve different intents. Usually the answer is to differentiate: the service page owns the commercial query, the guide owns the questions, and each links to the other with anchors that state the difference (what the term means).
- Differentiate. Each practice is a real place, so the fix is genuinely local content per page: the team, the real opening hours, emergency arrangements, directions and photographs of the practice. Pages that only swap a town name read as one page with many URLs; if a practice could not support its own content, fewer pages would be the honest alternative (stores and multi-location sites).
- The weaker signal was used and the links were left behind. A permanent redirect is the strongest consolidation signal; a Canonical TagTells search engines the preferred URL. is the fallback only when a page must stay reachable. Redirect the retired URL, update every internal link at the source, including navigation and related blocks, and update the sitemap (executing a consolidation).
- Retire it. It answers nothing anyone asks and describes something that no longer exists. With no links or traffic, let it return not found; had it carried links, a redirect to the nearest relevant page would keep them. Record the decision so the next audit does not rediscover it (deciding what to do).
- Link it from where its topic comes up. Add it to the children's dentistry hub, link it from sibling pages and from paragraphs that mention a first visit, with anchors that describe it. A page reachable only through a deep archive is found late and recrawled rarely (finding under-linked pages).
- One concept, one target. The same anchor pointing at different pages tells the engine three pages are about whitening, which reinforces cannibalisation. Point it at the page that owns the query, vary the wording naturally, and make the anchor describe the target (rules and anchor text).
- No brief without a map check. Every query group has one owner URL in the keyword map; new ideas are checked against it at monthly planning; refreshes update the existing page; and a quarterly maintenance pass reads query and page data for new splits. New pages and refreshes share one backlog so refreshes are not starved (the content backlog and refresh queue).
Where to go next
If you missed the decision questions, redo the merge and differentiate steps of the stove maker exercise. If you missed the linking or operating questions, map the anchors for one topic on a site you know. Then continue to the final module with the cyber security training contribution exercise, or revisit the intermediate content marketing level.
