Brief
Tallyhouse Invoicing Software is an invented invoicing and expenses app for freelancers and small firms, sold on monthly plans after a free trial. Its blog has been written for years by rotating freelancers without a shared map or named authors. Organic traffic has been flat for a long time, articles regularly compete with each other, and nobody agrees what content contributes to sign-ups. The marketing lead wants a larger programme; the leadership team will fund it only with a case it can test.
You are writing that case. It must be honest about what the evidence shows, propose what to do before any increase and say how leadership will know, at set points, whether to continue. It assumes the strategy, pillar and governance work of the intermediate content marketing level.
Inputs and constraints
Tallyhouse: content inventory and search data
| Inventory group | Posts | Organic clicks, last 12 months | Sign-ups with a post in the session path | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Invoicing how-tos | 140 | 520,000 | 2,100 | 31 query groups split across 2 or more posts |
| Freelancer tax and expenses | 95 | 380,000 | 1,600 | No named authors; 22 posts cite rules that have changed |
| Invoice and quote templates | 25 | 210,000 | 2,900 | Strongest converters; 4 templates duplicated |
| Productivity and lifestyle | 120 | 160,000 | 150 | Off the product's subject |
| Product news | 40 | 10,000 | 60 |
Organic sessions to the blog have sat near 95,000 a month for 6 quarters. Search Console shows the ranking URL alternating for most of the 31 split query groups.
Tallyhouse: sign-ups, economics, competitors and resources
- Sign-ups in the last 12 months: 24,000. Last-click source organic blog: 6%. Coded free-text answers to "how did you hear about us?": search 38%, an accountant or friend 22%, a blog article or template 15%, app store 12%, social 8%, other 5%.
- Trial to paid: 18% overall; 21% for sign-ups whose path included a template or guide.
- Contribution per paid customer over an average lifetime: about £240.
- Earned share of voice in freelancer and small-business titles on invoicing, tax and getting paid, last 12 months: Competitor X 41%, Competitor Y 27%, Tallyhouse 9%, others 23%.
- Experts: an in-house chartered accountant who can give 8 hours a month, a customer success lead and a data analyst. Anonymised invoice data shows how long customers wait to be paid, by sector and region.
- Current content budget: £180,000 a year (freelance writing £110,000, editor £50,000, promotion £20,000). The marketing lead is asking for £300,000.
Constraints: tax content must be reviewed by the accountant before publication; freelancers remain the writing capacity; customer data may be published only in aggregate, after legal review; the leadership team wants a first review point within two quarters of approval.
Task
- Diagnose the library. From the inventory, say which groups earn their place, which compete with themselves, which are out of date and which are off the subject, using the method from the stove maker consolidation exercise.
- Plan consolidation before scaling. Decide merges, redirects, refreshes and retirements by group, the internal link rebuild around the survivors, and the quarterly maintenance pass from the SEO content operations playbook. Sequence it so the library stops competing with itself before output grows.
- Write the authority plan. Choose the topics Tallyhouse will own and show how E-E-A-TExperience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trust. becomes visible on those pages, following the E-E-A-T guide: named authors, the accountant as dated reviewer, first-hand detail and sources. Plan a data-led campaign from the invoice data, as in the payroll software campaign exercise, and set an earned Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. target with its denominator.
- Build the contribution model. Show content's part in sign-ups and paid customers from several views, last click, path-based, self-reported and conversion quality, with what each can and cannot show, as the business-to-business measurement guide recommends and the cyber security training exercise practised. Add a cohort view from sign-up to paid.
- Forecast with ranges. For holding the budget, a modest increase and the requested increase, forecast sign-ups and contribution as ranges, with the assumptions named. Apply the marginal returns and forecasting guide: say where the next pound buys most, and why that is not where the average says.
- Design the operating model. Roles, briefs from the content brief template, the inventory, owners, review dates, rules for AI-assisted drafting and approval for tax content, drawing on the content governance guide. Set the weekly, monthly and quarterly rhythm.
- Set budget and review points. Phase the budget, attach go, adjust and stop criteria to each review point, and name the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. each review reads.
- Write the case. One page structured by the content strategy framework, with appendices for the library plan, the authority plan, the model, the forecast and the operating model.
Tallyhouse: the first contribution figures a strong answer reaches
- Self-reported view: 15% × 24,000 = 3,600 sign-ups; at 18% to 21% trial-to-paid, about 650 to 760 paid customers; at £240 each, about £155,000 to £180,000 of lifetime contribution.
- Last-click view: 6% × 24,000 = 1,440 sign-ups; about 260 paid customers; about £62,000.
- Templates: 2,900 path sign-ups from 25 posts, against 150 from 120 lifestyle posts.
- Against a £180,000 budget, the honest reading is that the programme roughly pays back on the more generous views and not on the narrowest one, and that its value is concentrated in a small share of the library.
Evaluation criteria
| Criterion | What a strong answer shows | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Authority plan | Uses internal experts and a data-led campaign to build trust in chosen topics | Promises more articles on the same topics |
| Consolidation | Fixes overlap and internal links before scaling output | Scales a library that competes with itself |
| Contribution model | Shows content's part in sign-ups from several views with stated limits | Uses last-click or traffic as the case |
| Forecast and budget | Forecasts with ranges, marginal thinking and named assumptions | A single optimistic number |
| Operating model | Defines roles, governance, cadence and review points from the playbook | Leaves production to freelancers without governance |
A strong case also argues from where the value already sits. Templates and invoicing guides do most of the work; lifestyle posts do almost none. The cheapest next gains are therefore in consolidating, refreshing and linking what exists and in making expertise visible on the tax pages, not in adding volume. That argument should shape the phasing: a first phase that funds the clean-up and the authority work, with the larger increase released only if the review points show the views of contribution moving together. Every AttributionAssigning conversion credit to touchpoints. figure in the case is labelled as modelled or self-reported, and none is presented as cash.
