Why this matters
Channel choice is where small businesses waste the most effort, usually by choosing on novelty, imitation or habit. The guide to choosing channels replaces those forces with checks on demand, attention, job and economics, and ends in a scoring table. The See-Think-Do-Care framework adds the intent view: who is in each cluster and what they want from you. Here you apply both to one business with a specific goal.
The bakery and its customers
Fernvale Bakery is an invented independent bakery on a high street next to a small business park. Weekends sell out; weekdays do not. The owner wants more weekday orders, both walk-in and pre-ordered.
Fernvale Bakery: the situation
| Input | Detail |
|---|---|
| Goal | More weekday orders over the next quarter |
| Monthly marketing budget | £300 in cash, plus about 4 hours a week of the owner's time |
| Who buys on weekdays | Office workers from the business park at lunch; office managers ordering platters for meetings; local residents on the school run |
| Existing assets | A simple website with an order form; a Google Business Profile with 4.8 stars from 140 reviews; 620 email addresses from past online orders, never emailed |
| What people search for | "bakery near me", the bakery's name, and "office catering" plus the town name |
| Owner's skills | Comfortable writing emails and posting photos; no video editing; has never run ads |
| Margin on a platter order | About £18 |
Before scoring anything, sort the weekday customers by intent. Office workers walking past at lunch are mostly in See: they know the street, not the bakery's range. Office managers searching for catering are in Think or Do: they have a meeting to feed and are comparing options. Past online customers are in Care, or close to it, and nobody is talking to them.
Scoring the channels
Use the criteria from the choosing-channels guide, scored from low to high, and weight them by what this business needs most. Fernvale's goal is near-term orders on a tiny budget run by one busy person, so demand, job fit, economics and capability matter more than durability or speed.
The weights for Fernvale
| Criterion | Weight | Why this weight |
|---|---|---|
| Demand or attention | 3 | Weekday buyers must demonstrably be there |
| Job fit | 3 | The channel must reach a weekday buyer in the right state |
| Economics | 2 | £300 a month; cost per order must sit under the platter margin |
| Speed | 1 | Results within the quarter, but not this week |
| Capability | 2 | The owner runs it; a badly run channel is worse than none |
| Durability | 1 | Nice to have: does it build an asset? |
Scores run from 1 to 5, so the maximum weighted total is 60.
The candidate channels are: Google Business Profile and local search, email to past order customers, paid search on catering terms, organic Instagram, paid local social ads, a promoted listing on a food delivery app, and a short-video platform.
Task
- Assign each candidate channel one job (create demand, capture demand, convert or retain) and the See-Think-Do-Care cluster it would serve.
- Score each channel against the six criteria using the weights above, and calculate the weighted totals.
- Shortlist the top three. Check that together they cover more than one job.
- For every channel you leave out, write one sentence on why it waits and what would change your mind.
Worked answer
Fernvale Bakery: scored channels
| Channel | Job and cluster | Demand | Job fit | Economics | Speed | Capability | Durability | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google Business Profile and local search | Capture; Do | 5 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 57 |
| Email to past order customers | Retain; Care | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 56 |
| Paid search on catering terms | Capture; Think and Do | 4 | 5 | 3 | 5 | 3 | 1 | 45 |
| Organic Instagram | Create; See | 3 | 2 | 4 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 36 |
| Paid local social ads | Create; See | 3 | 3 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 1 | 33 |
| Delivery app promoted listing | Convert; Do | 3 | 3 | 1 | 4 | 4 | 1 | 33 |
| Short-video platform | Create; See | 2 | 1 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 3 | 21 |
Example of the arithmetic for email: (4 × 3) + (5 × 3) + (5 × 2) + (5 × 1) + (5 × 2) + (4 × 1) = 56.
The shortlist. Local search through the Google Business Profile comes first: people already search for a bakery nearby, the reviews are strong, and adding weekday photos, platter options and an order link costs only time. Email to past customers is a close second; the list exists, has never been used and reaches the Care cluster that already trusts the bakery. Paid search on catering terms completes the set. It reaches office managers while they are comparing, and search engine marketing (SEMPaid search advertising (sometimes used to include SEO).) can be capped to a small daily budget. Together they cover capture, retention and the move from Think to Do.
Why the rest wait.
- Organic Instagram: it creates ReachUnique people who saw an ad. among people who are not deciding where to buy lunch today, so it waits until the capture channels are working and there is weekday content worth showing.
- Paid local social ads: the budget is better spent where intent already exists; revisit once email shows which weekday offers people respond to.
- Delivery app promoted listing: the commission and fee would consume most of the margin on each order, so it fails the economics check for now.
- Short-video platform: the owner cannot produce video and its audience skews away from weekday buyers, so it scores lowest on both capability and job fit.
Read across the FunnelModel of the customer journey stages. and the shortlist has a gap at the top: nothing creates new demand. That is an acceptable trade for one quarter with this budget, but it should be written down so the owner revisits it.
Common mistakes
- Scoring by audience size. The short-video platform has the largest audience and the weakest fit; size is not the criterion.
- Equal weights for everything. Weights are where the business's situation enters the grid. Without them, the score describes channels in general, not this bakery.
- Forgetting existing assets. An unused email list is the cheapest channel most small businesses have. The journey stages guide reminds you the journey does not end at purchase.
- Shortlisting more than three. The limit is the owner's time, not the budget. The beginner level overview returns to this in the capstone brief.
