Why this matters
Most small makers frame the question as "marketplace or website?" and pick one on instinct. The comparison of marketplaces and own stores argues that the better question is what each route is for. The e-commerce marketing hub explains why: revenue is traffic, conversion, order value and repeat purchase multiplied together, and the two routes are strong on different terms. This exercise puts numbers to that trade-off, so the recommendation rests on what an order is worth.
The candle maker and its options
Emberlane Candles is an invented business: one maker who hand-pours soy candles and sells them at weekend craft fairs. Buyers often ask to reorder online, and the maker collects email addresses at each fair. There is no website yet.
Emberlane Candles: the business today
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Range | Twelve scents in one jar size at £22; three gift sets of three candles at £54 |
| Product cost | £6.50 per candle including jar, wax, wick and label; gift box adds £2.50 |
| Packing and postage | About £4.20 per parcel, absorbed in the price |
| Fair sales | Around 110 candles a month; about a third of fair buyers say they have bought before |
| Email sign-ups | 380 addresses collected at fairs, with a tick box agreeing to hear about new scents |
| Time | The maker can spare about six hours a week for online selling |
The maker has costed two routes. All fees below are assumptions for this exercise, not any real provider's prices.
The two routes, as the maker has costed them
| Row label | Handmade-goods marketplace | Own store on a hosted platform |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed cost | None | £29 a month for software |
| Per-order fees | 13% of the order value plus £0.30 | 2% of the order value plus £0.25 for card payments |
| Expected order mix | Mostly single candles; average order about £26 | More gift sets and multi-candle orders; average order about £38 |
| Expected new-customer cost | Folded into the fee | About £11 per new customer from social ads and fair flyers, estimated |
| Customer contact | Order details only; marketing to buyers outside the marketplace not allowed | Full: email, order history, consent recorded at checkout |
Comparing the channels
Compare margin per order after every cost, not revenue. Separate a first store order, which carries the cost of winning the customer (CACCost to acquire one new customer.), from a repeat order, which does not. Candles burn down, so where the second order goes depends on who holds the relationship. And ask which part of the FunnelModel of the customer journey stages. each route serves: the marketplace reaches strangers who are browsing, the store serves people who already know the maker.
Task
Write your answer before reading the worked one.
- Work out the margin on a typical order on each route, after product cost, packing, postage and fees.
- Split the store into a first order, including the cost of winning the customer, and a repeat order.
- Compare the routes on customer data, control and repeat purchase, and say which matters most here.
- Decide where Emberlane should start selling, on one route or both.
- Give each route a job: which products go where, at what price, and how one feeds the other.
- Name the figures to check after three months.
Worked answer
Margin per order. The store keeps more per order, because the fee is lower and because it sells the gift sets that raise average order value (AOVAverage revenue per order.).
Emberlane's margin per order on each route
| Row label | Marketplace order | Store first order | Store repeat order |
|---|---|---|---|
| Order value | £26.00 | £38.00 | £38.00 |
| Product cost | £7.70 | £11.40 | £11.40 |
| Packing and postage | £4.20 | £4.20 | £4.20 |
| Fees | £3.68 (13% plus £0.30) | £1.01 (2% plus £0.25) | £1.01 |
| Software, spread over 20 orders | — | £1.45 | £1.45 |
| Cost of winning the customer | Included in the fee | £11.00 | £0.00 |
| Margin | £10.42 | £8.94 | £19.94 |
The first store order earns a little less than a marketplace order once acquisition is paid for. Every repeat store order earns nearly twice as much as a marketplace order. A marketplace repeat order earns no more than the first one did, and only if the buyer finds Emberlane rather than a competitor listed beside it.
Data, control and repeat purchase. The marketplace keeps the buyer's contact details, puts other candle sellers on the same page and sets the template. The store keeps the email address and order history, which make a reorder reminder possible. For a product that is used up, repeat purchase decides the outcome.
Where to start. Both, from the first month, with different jobs. The fair list is warm demand that belongs on the store; sending it to a marketplace would hand those buyers over. The marketplace is worth having for discovery, because its shoppers are already searching for candles and early sales show which scents sell to strangers. The maker's limited hours rule out anything beyond one store and a short listing.
A job for each route.
- Own store: the home. The full range, the gift sets, new scents first and a refill reminder. Email the fair list on launch.
- Marketplace: the shop window. A subset of best-selling single scents at the same price as the store, so the maker's own promotion never sends people to the fee-bearing route.
- The bridge. A card in every marketplace parcel inviting the buyer to register for care tips and new scents on the store, within the marketplace's rules on contacting buyers.
What to check after three months. The store's share of orders, new store customers and how many came from parcel cards, repeat orders as a share of store orders, and margin per order on each route. If repeat orders grow and the cards bring people across, the marketplace is feeding the store. If marketplace sales grow while store sales fall, it is replacing it, and the range there should shrink.
Common mistakes
- Comparing revenue instead of margin. Busy is not the same as profitable.
- Sending the fair list to the marketplace. It gives away the only customers the maker already owns.
- Pricing the marketplace lower. It teaches buyers to skip the store and pay the maker less.
- Listing the full range everywhere. Without exclusives, nobody has a reason to visit the store.
Then check yourself in the e-commerce marketing basics checkpoint, or return to the beginner e-commerce level.
