Why this matters
A fortnight after launch there is just enough data to be dangerous. One ad looks brilliant on a handful of bookings, another looks dreadful on a handful of clicks, and the owner wants to know whether the money is working. Acting on noise resets learning, kills ads that would have come good and scales ones that got lucky.
This exercise applies two readings. The pausing underperforming ads SOP sets the order: confirm the threshold, check data volume and tracking, check learning status, compare against target, then pause, keep or escalate and log it. The performance reporting guide says a report should lead with plan against actual in the business's own data and end with a decision. The targets and budget come from the groomer's brief, written with the campaign brief template.
The groomer and its first results
Sudsy Paws Mobile Grooming is a fictional one-van grooming service covering a group of nearby villages. The owner books first appointments online. Search and social campaigns launched a fortnight ago with tracking tested on day one.
Sudsy Paws: threshold document and brief targets
- Target cost per first booking: £35, judged in the owner's booking diary.
- Minimum data before any ad is judged: £150 of spend in a 14-day window.
- Pause if cost per booking is more than 30% above target (above £45.50) with enough data.
- Do not judge an ad set in its learning phase unless it is plainly broken.
- Plan for the fortnight: £700 spend, 20 new customers.
Sudsy Paws: results by ad, days 1 to 14
| Ad | Campaign | Spend | Clicks | CTR | Bookings reported | Cost per booking | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A "Groomed on your driveway" | Search prospecting | £240 | 160 | 6.1% | 8 | £30 | Tracking healthy |
| B "From £35 a groom" | Search prospecting | £160 | 70 | 4.2% | 2 | £80 | Tracking healthy |
| C Van tour video | Social prospecting | £140 | 95 | 0.9% | 2 | £70 | Ad set re-entered learning on day 9 after a budget edit |
| D Before-and-after image | Social prospecting | £110 | 120 | 1.4% | 4 | £27.50 | Same ad set as ad C |
| E Carousel of breeds | Social remarketing | £50 | 40 | 1.1% | 5 | £10 | Frequency 6.2 in 14 days |
| Total | £700 | 21 | £33.33 |
- The owner's diary shows 17 new customers who booked online during the fortnight.
Enough data to act on
Before any ad is compared with the target, two gates apply: has it spent enough to judge, and was the conversion recorded reliably throughout? Only then do learning status and the target come in. Supporting signals such as CTRShare of impressions that result in a click. and the click-to-booking CVRShare of visits or clicks that convert. explain a cost; they do not on their own justify a pause. And the report to the owner is built on the diary, not on the sum of the platforms.
Task
- For each ad, record whether it has met the minimum data rule.
- For the ads that have, compare cost per booking with the pause threshold and decide pause or keep.
- For the ads that have not, decide keep or escalate, and give the reason you would log.
- Comment on what the supporting signals suggest for each social ad.
- Reconcile the platform-reported bookings with the diary and work out the blended cost per new customer.
- Write the pause log entries, each with a reason and a review date.
- Write a short owner update: plan against actual, what you changed, what you deliberately left alone and what happens next.
Worked answer
Only two ads can be judged. Ads A and B passed the minimum spend with tracking healthy, and search has no learning issue here. Ad A beats the target and stays. Ad B's CPACost of each conversion. is well above the pause line, so it is paused, never deleted. Its low click-through and the price-led message suggest the "from" price attracted people looking for the cheapest groom.
The social ads are kept, for different reasons. Ads C and D are below the minimum and sit in an ad set that re-entered learning after a budget edit. Ad C's poor figure and ad D's good one are both too thin to act on, so neither is paused or scaled. Ad E is below the minimum too, but its frequency is high on a small audience and its cheap cost mostly reflects people who were already close to booking. Keep it, flag the frequency, and propose a cap.
Pause log and reconciliation
| Item | Value against target | Data | Decision | Reason | Review |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B | £80 vs £35 | £160 spend | Pause | Above £45.50 with enough data | Day 44 |
| C | £70 vs £35 | £140 spend, learning | Keep | Insufficient data; learning | Day 21 |
| D | £27.50 vs £35 | £110 spend, learning | Keep | Insufficient data; do not scale yet | Day 21 |
| E | £10 vs £35 | £50 spend, frequency 6.2 | Keep, escalate cap | Insufficient data; frequency high | Day 21 |
- Platforms reported 21 bookings; the diary shows 17, so the platforms over-claim by about a quarter.
- Blended cost per new customer: £700 ÷ 17 = £41.18, against a target of £35.
- Plan against actual: 17 of 20 planned customers on plan spend.
The owner update leads with the diary, says what changed and what was deliberately left alone, and ends with the next step.
The update sent to the owner
"In the first fortnight the ads brought 17 new customers against a plan of 20, at about £41 each against a £35 target. One search ad was costing far too much per booking and is paused; the other is on target. The social ads are still learning and have not spent enough to judge, so I have left them alone and will review them next week. I propose capping how often past visitors see the reminder ad."
Common mistakes
- Pausing ad C on its cost per booking. It has not met the minimum and its ad set is learning.
- Scaling ad D because it looks cheapest. A handful of bookings is not evidence of a winner.
- Reporting the platforms' total. Leading with platform figures overstates customers the owner can count in her diary.
- Judging ad E on its reported cost. Remarketing looks cheapest because many of those people would have booked anyway.
- No review dates. Paused and kept items are forgotten, and the same argument happens next week.
When your decisions match the reasoning, move on to the first performance campaign capstone, or return to the beginner performance marketing level.
