Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

SEO › Intermediate

Evaluating a Backlink Sample for Link Quality

Judge links the way a search engine is likely to, rather than by count or tool score. You score an invented cycling tour operator's backlink sample on relevance, source quality and anchor text, identify a pattern that looks manufactured, and choose the kinds of site its link programme should pursue next.
ExerciseIntermediate levelModule 3: Authority and reporting5 minUpdated

Why this matters

A Backlink is a reference whose weight depends on who gives it, where and in what words. Counting links, or sorting them by a third-party score, misses all three. The link quality and anchor text guide sets out the criteria and the documented position on risk and disavowing; the link building methods guide describes how the links worth having are earned. This exercise uses both to turn a raw export into decisions.

Summit Cycling Tours is an invented small business running guided cycling holidays in one upland region. Its owner exported a sample of referring links and mentioned that a freelancer "got some articles placed" two years ago. The tour pages are the ones the business needs to rank.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Summit Cycling Tours: backlink sample

RefLinking siteLinking pageAnchorPlacementAttributeTarget
1Regional tourism boardCycling holidays in the regionSummit Cycling ToursBody, resource listFollowedHomepage
2Local cycling club blogRide report from a club weekendour guided weekend with SummitBodyFollowedWeekend tour page
3National newspaper travel sectionFeature on UK cycling holidaysSummit Cycling ToursBodyNofollowHomepage
4Copy siteSame newspaper feature, republishedSummit Cycling ToursBodyFollowedHomepage
5General web directory"Travel" category, 400 listingscycling tours ukListingFollowedHomepage
6Cryptocurrency blog"Top tips for an active holiday"guided cycling holidays ukBodyFollowedTour page
7Fashion blog"Why active holidays are trending"guided cycling holidays ukBodyFollowedTour page
8Home improvement blog"Planning your next break"guided cycling holidays ukBodyFollowedTour page
9Bike hire shop (partner)Partners pageSummit Cycling ToursBodyFollowedHomepage
10Cycling forumThread asking for tour recommendationsthese guysBodyUGCTour page

Score every link on three criteria, each from nought to two:

  • Relevance: is the linking site or page about cycling, travel or the region? Unrelated sites score nought.
  • Source quality: is it an established site with its own readers, and is the link editorial, placed by an author in the body? Template listings, copies and sites that exist to link score low.
  • Anchor and attribute: does the anchor read as a natural reference (brand, descriptive phrase, a page title) rather than a commercial keyword the linker would never choose? Note nofollow and UGC attributes, but do not score them as worthless: the guide explains why such links still bring readers and discovery.

Then step back from the rows. A pattern across several links tells you more than any single score.

Task

  1. Score each link on the three criteria and total it.
  2. Identify any pattern across links that matches the spam policy examples in the guide.
  3. Decide what to do about that pattern, using the guide's decision table on disavowing.
  4. Note which pages receive the strongest links, and which pages need them.
  5. Name the two kinds of site the operator should seek links from next, and the method for each.
  6. Choose how you would track the programme's results.

Worked answer

Illustrative example — not a real result

Scores

RefRelevanceSource qualityAnchor and attributeTotal
12226
22125
32215
42013
50000
60000
70000
80000
92125
102114

The strong links are the tourism board, the club, the newspaper and the partner. They are relevant, editorial and carry the anchors their authors chose. The newspaper link is nofollow and still the most valuable reference in the sample for readers and reputation; it is exactly the kind of evidence of standing that E-E-A-T describes. The copy site adds nothing: one story republished is one reference.

The risky pattern is links six to eight: unrelated blogs, similar article titles, the same exact-match commercial anchor, all pointing at one tour page. Together with the owner's remark about placed articles, this is a known history of manufactured links. The guide's decision table applies: stop any such activity, document the set and disavow those domains. The directory listing is low value but not part of the pattern; leave it.

Where the links land. The best links point at the homepage, while the tour pages that need to rank have only the forum mention and the risky set. Internal links from the homepage to the tour pages matter, and new links should be earned for the tour pages directly.

Two kinds of site to pursue next:

  • Regional tourism, accommodation and visitor bodies, through resource pages and existing relationships with the hotels and guesthouses the tours use. They are relevant, trusted and already know the business.
  • Cycling clubs, route sites and cycling publications, through citable content: detailed route guides with elevation and café stops that riders reference, offered to the people who write about the region.

Tracking. Record each link earned to a target page as an input in the programme, and read the target pages' positions and clicks as the outcome, as the SEO KPIs and reporting guide sets out. For referral visits from the new links, use the Traffic acquisition report with session source as the dimension; the Google Analytics reports and dimensions guide explains why session scope is the right pairing.

Common mistakes

  • Scoring by tool authority alone. The newspaper's copy site may score well on a tool and adds nothing.
  • Dismissing nofollow links. Coverage in a publication people read is worth having.
  • Disavowing everything that looks weak. The directory is weak, not manipulative. Disavow known patterns.
  • Asking new linkers for keyword anchors, which recreates the pattern you just removed.
  • Ignoring where links land. Authority on the homepage does not rank a tour page by itself.

Compare your table with the worked scores, then return to the intermediate SEO level and move on to the SEO roadmap capstone.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related