Why this matters
A keyword list describes demand; a map turns it into a site plan. Without the map, a site grows pages that compete for the same query and leaves gaps nobody notices, which is how most SEOImproving visibility in unpaid search results. programmes on small sites stall. The keyword clustering guide gives the grouping rules, the keyword mapping tutorial gives the decisions per cluster, and the keyword cannibalisation guide explains how to resolve pages that compete. This exercise applies all three to one small, realistic set.
The keyword list and page inventory
Willowbrook Garden Centre is an invented, family-run garden centre with a café and an online shop, serving one market town. The owner has a keyword export, notes on each results page, and the site's pages with the queries they receive impressions for.
Willowbrook Garden Centre: keywords and results pages
| Keyword | Est. monthly searches | What the results page shows |
|---|---|---|
| garden centre near me | 2,400 | Local pack, garden centre homepages |
| willowbrook garden centre | 590 | Willowbrook's own pages, local pack |
| garden centre with cafe near me | 320 | Local pack weighted to cafés, café pages |
| buy fruit trees | 880 | Nursery category pages, product grids |
| fruit trees for sale | 720 | Same pages as "buy fruit trees" |
| when to plant fruit trees | 480 | Guides from gardening magazines and charities |
| best time to plant apple trees | 390 | Mostly the same guides as above |
| how to prune apple trees | 1,300 | Step-by-step guides, videos |
| apple tree pruning | 590 | Same guides and videos |
| raised garden beds | 1,600 | Product grids, retailer category pages |
| how to build a raised bed | 720 | DIY guides, videos |
| lawn feed | 1,000 | Product grids |
| best lawn feed | 880 | Comparison and review articles |
| Page | Type | Queries it receives impressions for (average position) |
|---|---|---|
| / | Homepage | garden centre near me (6), willowbrook garden centre (1) |
| /cafe | Café page | garden centre with cafe near me (9) |
| /plants/fruit-trees | Category | buy fruit trees (14), when to plant fruit trees (38) |
| /blog/pruning-apple-trees | Blog post | how to prune apple trees (alternates between 11 and 27) |
| /blog/apple-tree-care | Blog post | how to prune apple trees (alternates between 11 and 27) |
| /garden-furniture/raised-beds | Category | raised garden beds (19) |
| /lawn-care/feed | Category | lawn feed (12), best lawn feed (31) |
| /blog/spring-jobs | Blog post | none of the listed keywords |
Clustering and mapping
Cluster by asking one question of every pair: would one page rank for both? When the results pages largely share their URLs, the answer is yes; when the formats differ, the answer is no, however close the words are. Read each SERPThe page of results a search engine shows. note above with that question in mind. Intent is a hard boundary: a product grid and a buying guide never share a page.
Then map. Each cluster gets exactly one owner URL, existing or proposed, and each existing page gets a decision: keep, improve, consolidate, differentiate or create alongside. Two pages receiving impressions for the same query, with the ranking URL switching between them, is the signature of cannibalisation.
Task
- Group the keywords into clusters and name each cluster's head term.
- Label each cluster's intent and the format its results page rewards.
- Assign one owner URL per cluster, from the inventory or as a proposed new URL.
- Flag every pair of pages competing for one cluster and decide how to resolve it.
- List the new pages the map calls for, with a proposed URL and page type.
- Note any existing page that owns no cluster, and what you would do with it.
Worked answer
Clusters and owners.
- Garden centre near me (local): owned by the homepage, with the brand query as a variant. Improve with location detail and opening hours rather than a new page.
- Garden centre with café (local, café-weighted results): owned by /cafe. The results differ from the main local cluster, so it keeps its own page. Improve.
- Buy fruit trees, with "fruit trees for sale" (transactional, product grids): owned by /plants/fruit-trees. Keep and improve.
- When to plant fruit trees, with "best time to plant apple trees" (informational, guides): the results share most URLs, so one cluster. The category page receives impressions but is the wrong format. Create a guide at /guides/when-to-plant-fruit-trees and link it to and from the category.
- How to prune apple trees, with "apple tree pruning" (informational, guides and video): owned by /blog/pruning-apple-trees.
- Raised garden beds (transactional): owned by /garden-furniture/raised-beds. Keep.
- How to build a raised bed (informational, DIY guides): create /guides/how-to-build-a-raised-bed, linking to the raised beds category as its next step.
- Lawn feed (transactional): owned by /lawn-care/feed.
- Best lawn feed (commercial, comparisons): a different results page from "lawn feed", so a different cluster. Create /guides/best-lawn-feed as a buying guide; the category stops trying to rank for it.
Cannibalisation. The two apple tree posts swap positions for the same query, and the care post is mostly about pruning. Consolidate: merge its best sections into /blog/pruning-apple-trees, redirect the care post there, and update internal links so pruning anchors point only at the owner.
New pages: three guides, for planting fruit trees, building a raised bed and choosing lawn feed.
Unmapped page. /blog/spring-jobs owns no cluster. Keep it as seasonal content for the newsletter, link it to the new guides, and record on the map that it has no search target.
Topic clusters. The fruit tree category and its two guides form a natural group; the topic clusters framework shows how a pillar and its cluster pages are linked. The guides then go into the schedule set by the content pillars and calendar guide, sized to what the team can write.
Common mistakes
- Clustering by shared words. "Lawn feed" and "best lawn feed" share words and need different pages.
- One page per variant. "Fruit trees for sale" does not need its own page.
- Mapping a guide query to a category page because the category already gets impressions for it.
- Keeping both competing posts because each has a history. The reader needs one good answer.
Check your map against the worked answer, then return to the intermediate SEO level and take the keyword strategy checkpoint.
