What this checkpoint covers
Tinderbox Games is an invented board game publisher. It sells through its own site, specialist game shops and a large online marketplace, and it works with tabletop creators who film playthroughs, reviews and rules explainers. A new family game launches in the autumn. The questions draw on the creator return and incrementality guide, the contracts and disclosure guide and the comparison of influencer and affiliate marketing.
Task
Answer each question in a sentence or two and give the reason. Then compare with the explanations, count a right action with a wrong reason as a miss, and reread the linked guide behind every miss.
Questions
- The agency's launch report leads with a large earned media value and calls it the campaign's return. The founder is delighted. What do you tell her?
- Tinderbox wants to know whether its creator programme sells games at all, including in shops and on the marketplace. How would you design a test?
- One creator's discount code shows very few redemptions, yet the game sold out in shops near the convention where she demonstrated it. What can codes and links attribute, and what can they not?
- A playthrough video performs so well that Tinderbox wants to run it as an ad in two countries for a year. The agreement says only that the brand may share the post. What is needed?
- A creator received free copies and earns commission through a link. She says the platform's paid-partnership label is enough and that disclosure is her business anyway. Is she right?
- A respected reviewer and a family creator whose audience buys reliably both want to work with Tinderbox. Should they be offered the same deal?
- A creator on commission and a voucher site in the affiliate programme both claim the same orders. What is going wrong, and how do you fix it?
Answers explained
- It is not a return. Earned media value multiplies attention by vendor rates that differ between tools; it counts nothing that was sold and can double-count paid impressions. Report full-cost cost per new customer as the floor and a tested estimate of the effect above it. See earned media value and why to drop it.
- Compare exposed and unexposed groups on total sales. Where creators or paid amplification can be concentrated in some regions, compare those regions with comparable ones held out, using shop and site sales by region rather than codes. Size it for a question worth asking, run it long enough and set the decision rule first. See incrementality tests for creator campaigns.
- Codes count only the people who used them. They show which creators drive identifiable online orders, a floor useful for comparing like creators. They miss people who bought in shops or searched later, and they credit buyers who would have bought anyway, so the shop sell-out may be the bigger effect. See what links can and cannot show.
- A licence and authorisation. The creator owns the content; running it as an ad needs a licence naming paid use, the channels, the markets, the term and allowed edits, plus permission to run it through her handle if it will appear as a partnership ad. Expect paid usage to cost more than organic posting. See usage rights, licensing and paid amplification.
- No. Free product and commission are both benefits that must be disclosed, clearly and upfront, on every post and frame; platform labels help but are easily missed. The brand shares responsibility under regulators' guidance, so wording, placement and a correction right belong in the contract and the review. See disclosure: what the rules require.
- No; pay for the job. The reviewer's value is trust and reach, which a commission could compromise, so a flat fee for an honest review, with no say over the verdict, fits. The family creator's audience converts, so a hybrid of a smaller fee plus commission on tracked sales rewards it. Compare them on full-cost CPACost of each conversion. only alongside their different jobs. See hybrid creator-affiliate deals.
- The two programmes run in silos. The brand pays twice for one order, and the voucher site may be intercepting buyers the creator persuaded. Agree one attribution rule across both programmes, stop codes leaking to voucher sites, and review voucher commission on IncrementalityConversions caused by marketing.. See common mistakes.
Where to go next
If the measurement questions caught you out, redo the creator programme exercise for a hair care brand. Then move to the next module with the video retention exercise for a woodworking school. To revisit creator briefs and paid amplification, return to the intermediate social media level.
