Why this matters
Small businesses usually choose platforms by imitation and end up with several half-alive profiles. The guide to choosing social platforms replaces that habit with a weighted score, a veto and a capacity cap; the brand voice and cadence guide turns the chosen platforms into a rhythm, counting the inbox first. The social media marketing hub puts both decisions in context. Here you apply them to one business with two goals and little time.
The brewery and its audience
Hopwell Brewing is an invented craft brewery on an industrial estate outside a market town. It runs a taproom from Thursday to Sunday and sells cans and kegs to a handful of independent bottle shops and pubs. The owner wants more taproom visits on the quieter Thursday and Friday evenings, and more independent stockists nearby.
Hopwell Brewing: the inputs
| Input | Detail |
|---|---|
| Goals | More Thursday and Friday taproom visits; new independent stockists within a short drive |
| Team for social | Taproom manager, about 2 hours a week; part-time assistant, about 6 hours a week |
| Taproom survey | 120 visitors asked where they find out about events: 71 said Instagram, 38 said a local Facebook group or the brewery's Facebook page, 9 said TikTok, 2 said elsewhere |
| Stockist buyers | Current stockists first saw the beer at a local festival or on Instagram; none mention LinkedIn |
| Existing accounts | Instagram with about 1,400 followers, posted to irregularly; a Facebook page last updated five months ago; an unused TikTok handle |
| Content available | A photogenic brewhouse, a new beer most months, weekly quiz and food-van nights |
| On camera | The taproom manager is happy to film short clips once a week; nobody wants to film daily |
| Busiest month | December, when the taproom runs extra events and the assistant also covers the bar |
Separate the two goals before scoring. Taproom visitors are local drinkers deciding where to go this week. Stockist buyers are a small trade audience who check a brewery's feed after meeting the beer elsewhere; for them the profile is proof of an active brewery, and the sale happens through direct contact.
Scoring the platforms
Hopwell is two part-timers with a local audience, so audience presence and capacity carry most of the weight.
Hopwell's weights and scale
| Criterion | Weight | Why this weight |
|---|---|---|
| Audience presence | 3 | Local drinkers and trade buyers must be there in the right mindset |
| Format fit | 2 | The brewery has to produce the native format well |
| Team capacity | 3 | Eight hours a week in total, including replies |
| Paid role | 1 | Paid is not planned this year beyond boosting the odd event |
| Measurement | 1 | Taproom visits are hard to attribute, whatever the platform |
Each platform scores from 1 to 5 per criterion, so the maximum weighted total is 50. A score of 1 for audience presence is a veto.
The candidates are Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, LinkedIn, YouTube and X.
Task
- Score each candidate platform on the five criteria, write one line of evidence beside each score, and calculate the weighted totals.
- Apply the veto, then apply the capacity cap: decide how many platforms the team can run as primary or secondary.
- Give every platform a role: primary, secondary or listening only.
- Set the weekly cadence: subtract inbox and reporting time first, fill the rest with costed formats, and check it against the busiest month.
- Write one sentence for each platform left out, saying why it waits and what would change your mind.
Worked answer
Hopwell Brewing: scored platforms
| Platform | Audience | Format | Capacity | Paid | Measurement | Total | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 44 | Primary | |
| 4 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 37 | Secondary | |
| TikTok | 3 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 22 | Listening |
| 2 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 22 | Listening | |
| X | 1 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 18 | Vetoed; handle claimed |
| YouTube | 1 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 13 | Vetoed |
Arithmetic for Facebook: (4 × 3) + (3 × 2) + (4 × 3) + (4 × 1) + (3 × 1) = 37.
Primary: Instagram. The survey puts most event-seekers there, the brewhouse photographs well, stories suit event reminders, and trade buyers check the feed after tasting the beer. It gets the full cadence, a managed inbox and a monthly report.
Secondary: Facebook. Many locals find events through the page and local groups. It runs at a lower cadence with posts adapted from Instagram, because a dormant page is a liability as it stands.
The cap. Eight hours a week supports one primary and one secondary platform; everything else listens.
Hopwell's weekly cadence
| Item | Time per week |
|---|---|
| Hours available | 8 hours |
| Inbox and comments, both platforms | 2 hours |
| Monthly report, spread across the weeks | 30 minutes |
| Left for production | 5 hours 30 minutes |
| Instagram: 2 short videos at about 75 minutes each | 2 hours 30 minutes |
| Instagram: 2 photo or carousel posts at about 30 minutes each | 1 hour |
| Instagram: event stories on 5 days at about 10 minutes each | 50 minutes |
| Facebook: 2 adapted posts plus the week's event listing, about 10 minutes each | 30 minutes |
| Total production | 4 hours 50 minutes |
| Buffer | 40 minutes |
In December the assistant covers the bar, so December's videos are batch-filmed in November and the rest of the rhythm holds. Regularity matters more than volume, because the ranking and the audience both learn the pattern.
Why the rest wait.
- TikTok: the audience is partly there, but nobody can film the steady supply it needs; point the handle to Instagram and revisit if a third person joins.
- LinkedIn: stockist buyers do not look for beer there; festivals and direct contact do that job.
- X and YouTube: both fail the veto; claim the handles and post nothing.
Against the FunnelModel of the customer journey stages., social here mostly reminds people who already know the taproom. That is the right job for this team; write it down so the owner does not judge Instagram on ReachUnique people who saw an ad. among strangers.
Common mistakes
- Scoring audience from platform size. The taproom survey beats any national figure.
- Forgetting the inbox. A cadence that fits production alone breaks once people ask about events.
- Reviving every dormant account. Each needs feeding; the rest should point to the live account.
- Ignoring the busiest month. A cadence set in a quiet week collapses in December. The beginner level overview returns to this in the module checkpoint.
