Why this matters
Posting the same video everywhere fails predictably: each platform shows it to people in a different frame of mind, judges it on different signals and offers a different route onward. The idea can travel; the execution cannot.
Apply the module's reading: the guide to LinkedIn company pages (the page is the foundation, people carry the reach), the TikTok posting cadence and trends guide and the comparison of YouTube Shorts and long-form video.
The idea and the audiences
Pebblestone Deli is an invented delicatessen in a market town. It sells cheese, charcuterie and bread over the counter and delivers lunch platters to local offices. The owner wants more catering orders, which are worth far more than a counter sale. The campaign idea is "Lunch that arrives before the meeting does": the early-morning platter build, shown honestly, to make the point that a team lunch can be ordered once and forgotten.
Pebblestone Deli: accounts, capacity and catering facts
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Company page with 180 followers, last post four months ago; the owner's profile has 900 connections, many of them local business owners | |
| TikTok | Business account with 1,400 followers, built from counter videos; about 2 posts a week |
| YouTube | Channel with 60 subscribers and 3 old videos; no Shorts |
| Team time for social | About 4 hours a week, shared by the owner and one member of staff who films |
| Catering menu | Platters for 6, 10 or 20 people, from £9 per head; order by 3pm for next-day delivery |
| Typical catering order | £180, usually placed by an office manager through the website form |
Three audiences matter: office managers who place orders and are on LinkedIn at work; younger staff who suggest the deli and found it on TikTok; and people planning a one-off event who search for how catering works.
Adapting for each platform
For each version decide who it is for, the format and whose voice carries it, the opening as it will be read or heard, the length relative to that platform's norms, one call to action and where its link lives, and the signal that shows it worked, such as click-through (CTRShare of impressions that result in a click.) on a link or new viewers reached.
Task
- Write a one-line statement of the idea that every version must carry.
- For LinkedIn, decide whether the post runs from the company page, the owner's profile or both, and write its opening line, outline, format and call to action.
- For TikTok, write the hook, the shot sequence, the sound, the caption and the call to action, and say whether it belongs to a series.
- For YouTube, give a Short and a long-form video their roles, specify each, and say how they link.
- Fill in a comparison table of your decisions for all three platforms.
- Write a paragraph for the owner on why the versions differ and which should bring orders directly.
Worked answer
The idea in one line: order the team lunch once, and it is built fresh and delivered before the meeting starts.
LinkedIn. The post runs from the owner's profile, because a person reaches further than a small page, and the page reposts it with a sentence of its own. First repair the page: a complete about section, the order form as the custom button. The format is a short document carousel opening with the organiser's problem: "The hardest part of a team lunch isn't eating it. It's remembering to order it." The slides cover the cut-off, platter sizes and one photograph of a delivery being set out. The call to action is the order form, via a tagged link in the first comment.
TikTok. This version is for the people who will suggest the deli, so it entertains first. It opens on a dark shop and a whispered line, "It's early, and twenty people need lunch by noon", cuts through the build and ends on the van door closing, in original sound. It becomes a series, "Whose lunch is this?", one office per episode, filmed in a weekly batch so the account keeps its floor. The call to action is "Send this to whoever orders your office lunch"; the link lives in the profile. Success is ReachUnique people who saw an ad. beyond followers, shares and profile link taps.
YouTube. A long-form guide answers the planner's search, "How much food to order for an office lunch", with quantities, dietary labelling, chapters and a clickable order link in the description. A Short cut from the platter build, with its own opening, earns reach and names the guide in its closing seconds, attached as the related video.
The three versions side by side
| Decision | TikTok | YouTube | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Audience | Office managers who order | Office staff who suggest | Event planners who search |
| Format and voice | Carousel from the owner, reposted by the page | Vertical series, original sound | Long-form guide plus one Short |
| Opening | The organiser's problem | Dark shop, whispered deadline | The search question, answered at once |
| Call to action | Order form via tagged link | Share with whoever orders | Description link to the order form |
| Measure | Link clicks and enquiries | Reach, shares, profile taps | Search views, link clicks; Short viewed versus swiped |
If one tagged enquiry in five becomes an order at £180, then 10 enquiries a month are worth about £360; the owner can weigh the 4 hours a week against that.
For the owner: LinkedIn reaches the people who place orders, so it should bring orders directly. TikTok makes the deli the one people mention. YouTube catches people while they plan, for long after publishing.
Common mistakes
- Cross-posting one video everywhere. The opening, length and link route each belong to one platform.
- A hard sell on TikTok. That audience suggests rather than orders, so help them pass the post on.
- Expecting the Short to convert. Give it the reach job and route people to the long-form guide.
- Untagged links. Without tagging, the owner cannot see which version produced the orders.
Next, test your judgement in the platform playbooks checkpoint, or return to the intermediate social media level.
