Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Marketing Analytics › Attribution

Attribution Models Compared

Last click, first click, linear, time decay, position-based and data-driven attribution compared: what each credits, where each misleads, and how to choose.
Comparisonintermediate9 min readUpdated

What an attribution model decides

A conversion path is the sequence of recorded sessions or ad interactions for one converting person within the lookback window. The model answers one narrow question: given that this conversion happened and these touchpoints were observed, how should the credit be divided among them? Everything else is decided elsewhere. Tracking, consent and cross-device identity decide which touchpoints are recorded at all. The lookback window, a setting rather than a model, decides how far back a path can reach. The key event definition decides what counts as a conversion in the first place.

Three things people expect from a model that no model can deliver. It cannot tell you whether a touchpoint caused the conversion, because it only ever sees paths that happened and never the path that would have happened without the touch; that is the job of Incrementality testing. It cannot reconcile numbers across ad platforms, because each platform runs its own Attribution over the touchpoints it alone can see. And it cannot credit a channel it never recorded, which is why offline media, word of mouth and consent-declined visits are silently absent from every model's output.

In GA4 the model setting is narrower than most people assume. It changes the event-scoped attribution dimensions used in the Advertising reports and in key-event credit; the user acquisition report keeps a first-session view and the traffic acquisition report keeps a session-level view whatever the setting. The GA4 attribution settings guide covers the setting, the windows and the reports; this page covers the models themselves.

The models side by side

Rule-based attribution models vs Data-driven attribution

ModelCredit logicFavoursMisleads whenAvailable in
Last clickAll credit to the final recorded click before the conversionBrand search, retargeting, email, affiliate codesJourneys are long and demand was created upstreamNearly every ad platform within its own scope; most analytics tools
Paid and organic last click (GA4)Ignores direct arrivals and gives all credit to the last channel the person clicked throughThe same closing channels, with direct removed from the pictureReturning customers arrive direct after an earlier campaign touchGA4 reporting attribution setting
First clickAll credit to the first recorded touch in the windowProspecting display, paid social, content, referralThe first touch was incidental and the real work happened laterRetired from GA4 and Google Ads reporting; custom analysis on exported paths; some third-party tools
LinearAn equal share to every touch on the pathLong paths and whichever channel appears most oftenRepeated low-value touches, such as many retargeting sessions, swamp the pathRetired from GA4 and Google Ads reporting; third-party tools; custom analysis
Time decayMore credit the closer a touch sits to the conversionClosing channels, more gently than last clickConsideration is long and early touches did the persuadingRetired from GA4 and Google Ads reporting; third-party tools; custom analysis
Position-basedLarger fixed shares to the first and last touches, the remainder spread evenly across the middleBoth ends of the pathThe middle is where the decision was made, or paths are so short that it collapses into last clickRetired from GA4 and Google Ads reporting; third-party tools; custom analysis
Data-drivenCredit estimated from converting and non-converting paths by comparing paths with and without each touchWhatever the data shows shifts the chance of convertingVolume is low, history is short, or a channel's touches are not recordedDefault in GA4 and Google Ads; other platforms offer their own versions
Platform-scoped last clickLast click or qualifying view within one platform's own ads onlyThe platform doing the countingFigures from several platforms are added togetherEvery ad platform's own conversion reporting

The rule-based models

Rule-based models are easy to explain, cheap to compute and stable over time, which is exactly why they survive even where data-driven attribution is available. Their weakness is the same in every case: the rule is an assumption about how people decide, applied to everyone.

Single-touch models

Last click credits the final click. It is the oldest model, the one most ad platforms use inside their own reporting, and the one finance teams understand without explanation. It rewards channels that sit at the end of a journey, which is why brand search, retargeting and email look excellent under it and prospecting looks poor. Its advantage is consistency: because nearly every tool can produce a last-click figure, it is the natural baseline for reconciling platforms and analytics, and the platform versus analytics comparison leans on it for that reason.

GA4's version, paid and organic last click, removes direct arrivals from consideration: a person who clicked a paid social ad last week and typed the URL today is credited to paid social, not to direct. That is a sensible correction for a model that would otherwise reward the absence of tracking, but it also means that GA4 last click and a platform's last click are not the same rule.

First click is last click reversed. It rewards whatever introduced the person, which makes it a useful lens on demand creation and a poor one on closing. It is rarely the right reporting model but is a good question to ask of path data: which channels appear first, and does the mix of first touches change when prospecting spend changes?

Multi-touch rules

Linear splits credit equally. It sounds fair and is the least informative of the set, because it treats a single, decisive click and the eighth retargeting session identically. In practice a linear view mostly rewards channels that generate many sessions per converter.

Time decay gives more credit to touches closer to the conversion and less to earlier ones, which fits businesses with short consideration cycles and promotional calendars. For a long business-to-business evaluation it behaves much like last click with extra steps, since the decisive early demonstration is a long way from the signed contract.

Position-based gives the two ends a larger fixed share each and spreads the rest across the middle. It is the rule that most closely matches how marketers already think about introduction and closing, which is both its appeal and its risk: it confirms a story about the funnel rather than testing it. Google has retired these three rules from GA4 and Google Ads reporting, so where they still appear it is in third-party tools or in your own analysis of exported paths.

The tutorial on building an attribution model in SQL does that analysis on the GA4 BigQuery export, rebuilding last non-direct, first, linear and position-based credit with the weights and lookback window as parameters.

Data-driven in brief

Data-driven attribution replaces the fixed rule with an estimate learned from the property's data. Google documents that its model evaluates converting and non-converting paths, uses a counterfactual comparison of what happened against what could have happened to judge how each touchpoint changes the chance of a conversion, and takes account of factors such as the time between an interaction and the conversion, device type, the number of ad interactions, the order of exposure and the creative involved. Credit is then shared in proportion to the estimated contribution, which is why a channel's conversions appear as fractions rather than whole numbers.

Its strengths are real: the split reflects observed behaviour rather than a belief, and it adapts as the mix changes. Its limits are equally real. It still sees only recorded touchpoints, so an unseen channel cannot be credited. It is estimated from observational data, so a channel that reaches people who were already on their way to converting can still earn credit. And its output moves as the model is refreshed, so last month's credit may not match what the report showed last month. The data-driven attribution guide covers the mechanism, the data it needs and the cases where it is not the answer.

Illustrative example — not a real result

One path, six models

A furniture retailer exports a single converting path for a £900 sofa order: a paid social click on day 1, an organic search visit on day 4, a comparison-site referral on day 9, and a brand search click on day 12 that leads to the purchase. Last click gives the full £900 to brand search. First click gives all of it to paid social. Linear gives each of the four touches £225. Time decay, with a seven-day half-life, gives roughly £410 to brand search, £255 to the referral, £160 to organic and £75 to paid social. Position-based, in its common 40/20/40 configuration, gives £360 each to paid social and brand search and £90 each to the two middle touches. The property's data-driven model, trained on thousands of paths like this one, assigns £470 to the referral, £200 to paid social, £150 to brand search and £80 to organic, because in this property paths that include the comparison site convert far more often than paths that do not. Same order, same touches, six different reports: the model is a lens, not a measurement.

Choosing for a decision

The right model depends on what the number is for. The table is a starting point; the choosing an attribution approach guide turns it into a full decision framework that also covers experiments and mix modelling.

DecisionUseBecause
Comparing campaigns inside one ad platformThat platform's own model, usually data-drivenSame scope and rules for every campaign; it is also what automated bidding optimises towards
Reporting channel performance to the businessOne analytics model, held constant, with data-driven preferred where volume supports itEvery conversion is counted once and the series is comparable month to month
Reconciling platform figures with analyticsLast click on both sidesIt is the only rule every tool can produce in the same shape
Understanding which channels assist rather than closeModel comparison: data-driven or first click against last clickThe shift in credit between models is the assist signal
Moving budget between channelsAn incrementality test, informed by the modelAttribution cannot say what the conversions would have been without the channel
Judging conversion rate (CVR) by channelA fixed model with the denominator statedA fractional numerator over a session count only makes sense when the rule is known

Two practical rules follow. Keep one model constant for any series you report over time, and when you change it, restate history under the new model rather than splicing two rules together. And treat model differences as questions, not answers: a channel that gains credit under data-driven relative to last click is probably assisting, and the way to confirm that is to test it, as the budget allocation guide recommends before moving money. The attribution hub has an interactive comparator for trying paths against each rule.

Common mistakes

  • Searching for the true model. There is none; there is only the rule that fits the decision.
  • Reading data-driven credit as causation. It is a better description of observed paths, not a test.
  • Changing the model and keeping the old history. The series breaks at the change date.
  • Comparing a platform's last click with analytics last click. Different scopes, different direct handling.
  • Judging prospecting on last click and retargeting on first click. Each channel measured by the rule that flatters it.
  • Letting the model carry a budget decision alone. Confirm with an experiment first.

The data-driven attribution guide goes deeper on the one model that is not a rule, and the GA4 attribution settings guide shows where the model choice takes effect in the reports and where it does not.

Frequently asked questions

Which attribution model does GA4 use by default?

Data-driven attribution is the default reporting model for key events in a GA4 property, and the attribution settings let an administrator switch the property to paid and organic last click instead. The setting changes the event-scoped attribution dimensions used in the Advertising reports; the user acquisition and traffic acquisition reports keep their own first-session and session-level logic regardless of the setting.

Why did Google retire first click, linear, time decay and position-based attribution?

Google removed these rule-based models from GA4 and Google Ads reporting and kept data-driven attribution and last click, saying that few advertisers used the retired models and that data-driven attribution had become the default. The retired models remain useful as thinking tools, and anyone with exported conversion paths can still reproduce them in a spreadsheet or a warehouse.

Is there a correct attribution model?

No. Every model is a rule for dividing credit among observed touchpoints, and every rule embeds an assumption about which touches matter; the data cannot tell you which assumption is true because no model observes what would have happened without a touch. Choose the model that suits the decision, keep one model constant for reporting, and test the budget-moving conclusions with an incrementality experiment.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Part of these learning paths

Also related

Sources

  1. Google Analytics Help — Google Analytics Help

Related