Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Comparisons

Broad Match vs Exact Match

Broad match and exact match keywords compared as a strategy: what each hands to the system, how Smart Bidding shifts the trade-off, and running both.
Comparisonintermediate8 min readUpdated

Broad match and exact match at a glance

The keyword match types guide sets out the matching rules as Google documents them. Broad match can enter searches related to the keyword's meaning, including ones that share no words with it, and Google says it uses further signals such as the landing page and the other keywords in the ad group to interpret that meaning. Exact match enters searches with the same meaning or intent as the keyword, close variants included. Phrase match sits between the two. This page takes those rules as given and asks a strategic question: which end of that range should a keyword, an ad group or an account default to?

Seen as a strategy, broad match is a decision to let the system choose which searches the budget buys. That is a good decision when the system has a reason to be selective, which in practice means a conversion-based bid strategy and enough conversions to learn from. Google's Smart Bidding documentation describes bids set for each auction from signals available at that moment, including the search itself, which is what allows a related search that looks unlikely to convert to be bought cheaply or not at all.

Exact match is a decision to keep that choice. The advertiser names the query, writes the ad for it and sends it to the page built for it. That is the right decision when the query is already known to be valuable and the cost of showing the wrong message, or paying too much for an irrelevant search, outweighs the value of finding new ones. The comparison of manual and automated bidding covers the bidding side of the same trade.

Compare table

Broad match vs Exact match

Row labelBroad matchExact match
Queries reachedMany, including related searches that share no words with the keywordFew: searches with the same meaning or intent, close variants included
Control over spendLow at the keyword; the bid strategy decides how much each search is worthHigh: the advertiser chose the query the money is spent on
Dependence on biddingHigh: designed to work with a conversion-based Smart Bidding strategyLow: works under manual or automated bidding alike
Data needsSteady conversion volume, so the strategy can learn which related searches convertNone beyond knowing which queries are worth buying
Message relevanceLooser: one ad serves many different searchesTight: the ad and landing page can be written for the query
MaintenanceRegular search terms reviews and a growing negative listKeyword research to add new queries as they are found
Risk of wasteHigher, especially early or with thin dataLower, though volume is capped by the queries listed
Best-fit accountEstablished accounts with reliable conversion tracking and a wish to grow reachNew accounts, tight budgets, brand terms and proven high-value queries

The dependence-on-bidding row is the one that changed the debate. Under manual bidding, broad match bought every related search at the same bid, so it was mostly a source of waste. Under a conversion-based strategy with good data, the strategy can price each related search on its own merits, and the case for broad match becomes a case for discovery rather than for carelessness.

When to choose broad match

Choose broad match when the account has a conversion-based bid strategy and the data to feed it. A campaign that records conversions steadily, with values where they differ, gives the strategy something to learn from, and broad match then supplies the range of searches it can choose among. Without that, broad match spends on related searches with nothing to tell good from bad.

Choose it when finding new searches is the goal. People describe the same need in many ways, and many of those ways never appear in keyword research. Broad match on a few well-chosen themes is how an account learns which of them convert. The Search Terms Report is the output: it shows the searches the system bought, and the ones that convert become candidates for keywords of their own.

Choose it when the account would otherwise be fragmented. Long lists of narrow keywords, each with a handful of clicks, starve both the bid strategy and the analyst of data. A smaller set of broad keywords in well-defined ad groups gives the strategy fewer, larger pools to optimise.

Budget for the cost of learning. Early weeks of broad match usually include searches the business does not want, and the negative keywords guide covers how those are trimmed. A team that cannot review search terms regularly should not run broad match on a meaningful share of its budget.

When to choose exact match

Choose exact match for queries that are already proven. When a search has a track record of converting at an acceptable cost, the value of naming it as an exact keyword is control: its own ad, its own landing page and a bid strategy that sees it clearly rather than as one of many searches under a broad theme.

Choose it for brand terms and competitor names. Brand searches are precise and cheap, and broad match on them can wander into generic searches that belong in another campaign. Competitor terms carry obvious risks of mismatched messages; exact match keeps them narrow.

Choose it when data or budget is thin. A new account, or one with few conversions a month, gives a bid strategy little to learn from. Exact and phrase match let conversions build on searches the business chose, and broad match can be added once there is something for the strategy to work with.

Choose it when the message must fit the query. Regulated offers, specific products and services with several distinct meanings all benefit from an ad written for one known search. Remember that exact match is not a literal match: Google documents that it includes close variants, so the search terms report still matters.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A locksmith adds broad match beside its exact keywords

Rookhaven Locksmiths runs a city-wide Search campaign on twenty-two exact match keywords with a target CPA strategy. It spends £4,000 a month for 160 bookings, £25 each. With eight months of steady conversions, it adds a separate ad group with broad match on three themes and a £1,200 monthly budget at the same target. In the second month the broad match ad group brings 38 bookings at about £32 each. The search terms report shows bookings from searches no exact keyword covered, such as being locked out of a flat or a key snapped in a door, and £180 spent on lock-picking courses and locksmith jobs before those were added as negatives. The exact keywords keep their own searches and their £25 cost. Rookhaven adds six of the new converting searches as exact keywords and keeps the broad ad group running as its source of new queries.

Decision table

SituationChooseWhy
Established account, conversion-based bidding, steady conversion volumeBroad match on the best themes, alongside exactThe strategy can price related searches and find new ones
New account or very few conversions a monthExact and phrase matchThe strategy has too little data to be selective
Brand or competitor termsExact matchPrecise searches, and messages that must fit them
Manual bidding or a clicks-based strategyExact and phrase matchNothing would stop broad match buying cheap irrelevant searches
Proven high-value query with its own landing pageExact matchControl over message and cost on a known winner
Goal is to discover how buyers describe the needBroad match with a modest budgetThe search terms report becomes the research
Team cannot review search terms regularlyExact match by defaultBroad match without review accumulates waste

Running broad and exact side by side

The two match types work best as a loop rather than a choice. Exact match keywords hold the proven queries, each with its own ad and landing page. Broad match keywords, in their own ad groups or campaigns, explore the searches around them under a conversion-based strategy. Google documents that a search identical to an exact match keyword prefers that keyword, so the exact keywords keep their own traffic and broad match takes the related searches.

Harvest on a schedule. Review the search terms from the broad ad groups, promote searches that convert well to exact keywords where a dedicated ad and page would help, and add irrelevant searches to the negative lists. The broad ad groups keep finding; the exact list keeps growing; the waste keeps shrinking. When irrelevant searches still show up after that, the troubleshooting page for irrelevant searches works through the remaining causes. To judge what broad match is finding across hundreds of rare searches at once, the search term n-gram analysis totals cost and conversions by recurring word and phrase, showing both the waste and the phrases worth promoting to exact keywords.

Report the two separately. Broad match searches usually cost less per click and convert less often than exact ones, and a blended figure hides whether discovery is paying for itself. Compare cost per conversion for each, and judge the broad ad groups on the new converting searches they find as well as on their own cost.

Common mistakes

  • Turning on broad match under manual or clicks-based bidding, which buys every related search at the same price.
  • Adding broad match to a new account before there is conversion data for the strategy to learn from.
  • Assuming exact match is literal, and being surprised by close variants in the search terms report.
  • Never harvesting: running broad match for months without promoting converting searches or adding negatives.
  • Putting brand terms on broad match, so brand budget spills into generic searches.
  • Duplicating every keyword in every match type, which splits data without adding reach.
  • Reporting broad and exact together, so cheap discovery traffic and proven traffic hide each other.

Frequently asked questions

Should I switch every keyword to broad match because Google recommends it?

Not every keyword, and not before the conditions are in place. Google's documentation recommends broad match together with Smart Bidding, because a conversion-based strategy can bid down on related searches that look unlikely to convert. Without that strategy, or without enough conversion data for it to learn from, broad match hands the system reach without a reason to be selective. Widen the keywords with the strongest conversion history first and judge the result in the search terms report.

Does exact match still only show ads for the exact words I type?

No. Google documents that exact match enters searches with the same meaning or intent as the keyword, including close variants such as plurals, misspellings and reordered words. It is still the narrowest of the match types, but it is not a literal string match. The keyword match types guide sets out what counts as the same meaning and how close variants work.

If I have the same keyword in broad and exact, which one wins?

Google documents that when a search is identical to an exact match keyword, that keyword is preferred over broad and phrase versions of it, so the exact keyword takes its own searches and broad match takes the related ones. That is what makes running both side by side workable. Avoid duplicating keywords across match types without a reason, though, because it splits data and adds maintenance.

Terms used on this page

Where this page is used

Also related

Sources

  1. About keyword matching options — Google Ads Help
  2. About Smart Bidding — Google Ads Help

Related