Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Comparisons

Brand Tracker vs Social Listening

Brand trackers and social listening compared: when to survey category buyers about the brand and when to read what people say about it unprompted.
Comparisonintermediate11 min readUpdated

Brand trackers and social listening at a glance

The brand tracking survey tutorial builds a tracker as one questionnaire, put to a new sample of the category's buyers at every wave, so that movement in Brand Awareness, consideration and associations shows up over time. The people asked are the buyers the brand strategy aims at, defined broadly, rather than the brand's own customers. Almost all of the tracker's value is fixed at set-up, because a questionnaire that changes later breaks its own history.

The social listening tutorial treats listening as keeping up with the talk about a brand's products, its rivals and its category away from the brand's own accounts, and acting on it. The tutorial builds the work from questions that each have an owner to a monthly note that ends in actions.

The difference that matters is who is heard. A tracker hears a sample drawn to represent the buyers the brand needs, whether or not they ever talk about the category, and it hears them answer set questions in a fixed order. Listening hears whoever chose to post, in the sources the method covers, in their own words. The voice of the customer guide makes the same point about customer feedback in general: every source has a bias, and reading several together corrects for each one's blind spots. So the question that separates the two methods is whether the decision needs to know how widely a view is held among the people the brand must reach, or what is actually being said and by whom.

Compare table

Brand tracker vs Social listening

Row labelBrand trackerSocial listening
Who is heardA sample drawn to represent the category's buyers, not only the brand's customersWhoever posts publicly about the brand, its rivals or its category, in the sources covered
Asked or unaskedAsked: the same questions in the same order each wave, unaided (unprompted) questions before aided (prompted) onesUnasked: what people chose to say, in their own words
What it measuresUnaided and aided awareness, consideration, associations and recognition of brand assets, for the brand and each rival in its competitor setWhat is said and how it is changing: complaints, questions, praise, wishes, comparisons with rivals
How often it reportsIn waves, at a cadence set by how fast the measures can moveAs alerts fire for findings that need someone now, and in a monthly insight note
What a change meansA shift in what category buyers remember, read against the baseline and an intervalA shift in the conversation, which news, a promotion, a complaint or one post that travelled can cause
What it cannot seeAnything it did not ask, and why a measure movedPrivate messages, closed groups, sources the method does not cover, and people who never post
Cost and effortFieldwork for every wave, a fixed questionnaire and a supplier or panelTime to build and test queries and to read samples; a paid tool is optional at the start
Who acts on itWhoever funds the brand: budget, creative and media planCustomer service, PR, product, content and the crisis owner, each with their own findings
How it misleadsA movement inside the interval, or one with no baseline, reads as newsVolume read as sentiment or awareness; untested queries full of unrelated posts; a quiet month read as silence
Typical misuseSurveying customers instead of the category, or changing questions quietly between wavesStarting with a tool and a dashboard, with no questions and nobody to route findings to

Most choices turn on two rows: who is heard and what a change means. A movement in a tracker is a statement about the category's buyers, made with known uncertainty. A movement in listening is a statement about the conversation, and the conversation can move for reasons that have nothing to do with what most buyers remember.

When to choose a brand tracker

Choose a tracker when a decision depends on whether the brand is coming to mind for more of the people it needs to reach: the brand budget, the creative, the media plan. The brand awareness and lift guide explains why the figure to watch is unaided awareness among the category's buyers: it shows whether the brand is recalled at the moment a need appears. The tracker tutorial adds that platform dashboards and branded search only hint at it. The tracker also reads the brand against its Competitor Set, which is where movement starts to mean something.

It is the right tool whenever new activity will later be judged on brand measures. The measurement plan framework wants the question and its measure, a Baseline, a method and a date for review agreed before the activity starts, and the tracker tutorial runs the baseline wave before any new brand activity starts. Each later wave is read with a Confidence Interval, so that a small difference between waves is not reported as a result.

Be clear about what a tracker cannot do. It reports the size of a change and how sure the reading is, not what caused it or which campaign was responsible; the quarterly brand health report supplies the explanation by reading tracker results alongside reach, share of voice and the moves made by the brand and its rivals. Where the question is what a single campaign did on one platform, the brand lift versus conversion lift comparison covers the study designs that answer it.

A tracker costs fieldwork for every wave, chosen with a supplier or panel, and the professional codes of the MRS and ESOMAR, as the tracker tutorial reports them, require participation to be voluntary and informed and research never to be used as cover for selling. The awareness guide notes that a small firm can still run a pared-back tracker: a short questionnaire sent to an online panel. The tracker is the weaker choice when the team needs to know what to fix this month or what people are saying about a launch: it reports in waves and answers only what it asks.

When to choose social listening

Choose listening when the business needs to hear what people say without being asked: the complaints nobody passed on, the question that keeps coming up, the competitor that keeps being recommended, the wish nobody serves. Its value lies in routing: each finding goes to the person who can act on it, with spikes and safety issues going to the crisis owner under the social media crisis plan. A tracker can do none of that.

Listening also watches competitors and the category in the words customers use, which are often not the words the marketing team uses. The share of voice guide lists listening and media monitoring as the sources of earned Share of Voice, with the warning that volume is not sentiment and a product recall produces a large share; the media monitoring and coverage reporting guide names listening as one of the PR team's sources too.

It can start small. The listening tutorial notes that the questions, terms, exclusions, routing and monthly note are the same whether a tool or a person does the searching, and that doing it by hand first tells the team what to ask of a tool if it ever buys one. The monthly note follows the what, so what, now what shape, so every finding ends with an owner and an action. The posts, names and handles that listening gathers count as Personal Data, so the tutorial, citing the GDPR, asks for a lawful basis, for keeping only what the questions need and for advice from whoever handles data protection.

Listening is a poor fit for counting how many of the category's buyers have the brand in mind. It hears only the people who post, it is quiet in the sources it does not cover, and its counts can be small: the listening tutorial, following the guide to reading small numbers, warns against treating a rise from a few mentions to slightly more as a trend.

Decision table

SituationChooseWhy
Leadership asks whether brand investment is making more category buyers think of the brandBrand trackerOnly a survey of category buyers measures memory against a baseline
A campaign or sponsorship starts next quarter and will be judged on brand measuresBrand tracker, with the baseline wave firstWithout a reading before the activity there is nothing to compare with
Complaints, questions and comparisons with rivals are posted in public and nobody reads themSocial listeningIt routes each finding to the person who acts on it
A sudden rise in posts, or a mention of safety or personal data, needs the crisis owner straight awaySocial listening, with alerts routed under the crisis planA tracker reports in waves and only on what it asks
The team wants the words buyers use about the category before wording the tracker's association questionsListening first, then the tracker's association questions, fixed before the baselineListening surfaces buyers' words; the tracker measures how widely the strategy's associations are held
Little is said about the brand in public and the budget is smallListening by hand on a few sources, then a stripped-down tracker when a decision depends on awarenessSmall counts swing, and only a survey measures memory directly
A tracker measure moved and the brand health report has to explain whyBoth, read beside reach and share of voiceThe tracker gives the measure; the listening notes record what people said in the period

Reading the two together

A brand that can afford both should not merge them. They answer different halves of the same question: the tracker says how widely the brand is known, considered and associated with the right things among the people it needs, and listening says what people who talk about the category are saying and what has changed. Put on one chart, a mention count and an awareness figure invite a comparison between two populations that do not overlap in any known way.

The useful link runs through explanation. The monthly listening note records what people talked about in the period, which a tracker cannot see: the launch people noticed, the rival's promotion everyone discussed, the complaint that spread. Earned share of voice drawn from listening can sit in the brand health report beside paid share of voice.

The link also runs into design. Listening collects the category phrases customers actually use, and those make better candidates for the tracker's association questions than the brand team's own vocabulary. The timing matters: a new question goes in before the baseline, or follows the tracker tutorial's rules for changing a questionnaire, because a question added later has no history.

Two neighbouring pages are easy to confuse with this one. If the measure in question is search rather than conversation, the share of search tutorial shows how to build that trend; and if a report mixes a platform's auction measure with share of voice, the page comparing impression share with share of voice pulls the two apart.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A camping stove maker sets a tracker baseline and listens between waves

Vembrolt Stoves, an invented maker of camping stoves that sells online and through 30 outdoor shops, has budget for one new piece of brand measurement before its first spring video campaign. The marketing manager starts with listening because it costs time rather than money. For a month she searches the platforms for the brand, its two stove models and three rivals, and 38 of the month's posts turn out to be about the stoves. Reading all 38 by hand shows 11 complaints about a gas canister adapter, 6 questions about cooking in the wind and 2 posts recommending a rival's lighter model. The complaints go to customer service, the wind question becomes a help article, and the note lists what the method cannot see: closed hiking groups and private messages.

The board's question is different: will the campaign make more camping equipment buyers think of Vembrolt when they need a stove? A month of 38 posts cannot answer it. The team commissions a stripped-down tracker of 600 camping equipment buyers a wave from an online panel, with the same three rivals in the competitor set. The baseline wave in February records unaided awareness of 6%, give or take about 2 points. The May wave, after the campaign, records 10%, give or take about 2.5 points. The gain of 4 points carries a margin of about 3 points on each side, so it stands clear of zero.

Over the same months listening counts rise from 38 to 61 posts a month, 25 of them about the campaign's windshield demonstration. The quarterly brand health report leads with the tracker figure, explains it with the campaign's reach and share of voice, and quotes the listening note for what people said about the advert. The adapter complaints, routed in the first month, fall to 3 a month once a redesigned adapter ships.

Common mistakes

  • Reading mention volume as awareness. The conversation can grow because of news, a promotion or one post that travelled, while memory among category buyers stays where it was.
  • Skipping either method's basics. A tracker begun without a baseline or sent to customers, or listening run on untested queries with no routing, unchecked automatic sentiment and no written note of the sources it misses, undermines the method concerned; the two tutorials list these failures in full.
  • Changing the tracker to chase what listening found. Add association questions with care, log every change and, where a question has to be replaced, run old and new together, or the series breaks.

The comparison library lists the other pairs that are easy to confuse.

Frequently asked questions

Can social listening replace a brand tracking survey?

No, because the two hear different people. A listening tool hears only those who post publicly, in the sources it covers, and it cannot see private messages or closed groups. A tracker asks a sample drawn to represent the buyers of the category, including people who say nothing about it in public, and it keeps one questionnaire, in one fixed order, at every wave so that waves can be compared. Listening can tell a brand what is being said and help explain why a tracker measure moved; it cannot say how many of the people the brand needs to reach now think of it.

Is a rise in mentions a sign that brand awareness has grown?

Not on its own. Mentions rise with news, a promotion, a wave of complaints or a single post that travels, and automatic sentiment scores misread sarcasm and mixed posts, so volume says little until a sample has been read by a person. Awareness is a memory, measured by asking category buyers which brands come to mind before any list is shown. Branded search is a cheap early signal that something has changed, and even that supplements a survey rather than replacing it.

Which should a small brand start with?

Listening done by hand is the cheaper start, because it costs time rather than money: a handful of questions, the platforms' own search on a few sources, a sample read every month and findings sent to whoever can act on them. Add a stripped-down tracker, with a short questionnaire to a panel of category buyers, when a decision such as a first brand campaign depends on whether more people think of the brand, and run its first wave before the activity starts. A brand with very little public conversation should not try to measure awareness from it.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Also related

Sources

  1. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR) — EUR-Lex
  2. Market Research Society — MRS
  3. ESOMAR — ESOMAR

Related