Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Comparisons

Open Rate vs Click-Through Rate in Email

Email open rate and click rate compared: what each counts, why automated opens made open rates unreliable, and which belongs in tests and reporting.
Comparisonbeginner7 min readUpdated

Open rate and Click rate at a glance

Open rate is the share of delivered emails recorded as opened. Each message carries an image unique to the recipient, and the platform records an open when that image is requested. The open rate glossary entry explains why that was always an inference and why it is now less than that: some mail clients fetch every image on arrival whether or not anyone looks, inflating opens, while others strip tracking images, hiding real readers. The share of each kind of client on a list decides how far the figure drifts.

Click rate, which the site's metrics guides also call click-through and which shares its logic with the click-through rate used in advertising, is clicks on tracked links divided by delivered emails. It records a person choosing to act, which makes it the first honest signal of interest in the email. The email metrics and testing guide places both figures in the engagement layer of email measurement, between delivery and outcomes, and covers how to test and report each; this comparison is about what each figure can still be trusted for.

The two used to be read as consecutive steps: people opened, then some of them clicked. That reading has weakened, because the first step is now partly counted by machines. The relationship still holds in one direction, since a person who clicked almost certainly read the email, but an open no longer reliably means a reader.

Compare table

Open rate vs Click rate

Row labelOpen rateClick rate
What is countedDelivered emails whose tracking image loaded at least onceDelivered emails whose recipient clicked at least one tracked link
Tracking methodA unique image in each message, requested from the sender's serverTracked links that record the click and pass campaign parameters on
Effect of automated opensInflated by clients that load images on arrival; deflated by clients that block themLargely unaffected, because loading an image does not follow a link
Use in subject-line testsSecondary at best: a winner on opens may simply have reached more auto-loading clientsPrimary, alongside the conversions that follow
Use in content testsNot applicable: the content cannot affect whether the image loadedPrimary: it shows which content and calls to action earned action
Link to revenueWeak and indirectDirect: the click carries the visitor to where the conversion happens
Deliverability signalUseful as an alarm when it falls sharply across sends to one providerUseful as confirmation: clicks fall too when mail moves to spam
Reporting roleA trend-only diagnostic, labelled approximateThe main engagement metric beside outcomes such as revenue per email

The rows that matter most are the effect of automated opens and the link to revenue. Clicks are both more reliable and closer to the business result, which is why most email programmes have moved their scorecards onto them.

When to choose Open rate

Use open rate as an alarm. Within one list, a sudden fall in opens across every campaign, with no change in content, is often the first visible sign that messages are landing in spam folders at one mailbox provider, and the open figure shows it within hours of a send. Split by provider, it points to where the problem is, which the deliverability guide then helps to diagnose. Over months, opens across the whole list still track the broad shape of engagement.

Open rate can also act as a secondary read on subject lines, provided the comparison is within one audience, at the same time, and confirmed by clicks. A subject line that wins on both opens and clicks is a reasonably safe winner; one that wins on opens alone may have done nothing but reach more clients that load images automatically.

Where open rate misleads is as a goal, a test metric or a benchmark. It cannot be compared across senders or across long periods without knowing the mix of mail clients, and a flow that waits for an open before acting may be triggered by a machine. When the open rate drops suddenly, the diagnosis of a dropped open rate starts by checking clicks and provider splits before trusting the open figure at all.

When to choose Click rate

Use click rate as the primary engagement metric for every campaign, flow and test. It records a person choosing to act on the email, it is largely unaffected by automated image loading, and it connects directly to the outcome the email was sent for, because the click carries the visitor to the page where the order, booking or sign-up happens. Look at clicks by link as well as in total, and at unique clickers rather than total clicks, so one enthusiast clicking everything is not mistaken for a trend.

Click rate is also the right basis for content tests, which open rate cannot judge at all, since the body of the email has no effect on whether the tracking image loaded. And it is the natural bridge to Revenue per Email, the outcome figure that lets sends of different sizes be compared and connects the programme to the business.

The caution is that clicks are still engagement, not outcome. A click-bait subject line or a misleading button can raise click rate without raising orders, so the scorecard should carry the conversions and revenue that follow the click as well as the click itself.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A bookshop rebuilds its newsletter scorecard

Inkspindle Books, an independent online bookshop, sends a weekly newsletter delivered to about 25,000 subscribers. Its dashboard leads with open rate, which climbs from 31% to 52% over a season while orders from email stay flat at around 90 a week. Click rate holds at about 2.4%, or 600 clicks a send. The team's last three subject-line tests had been decided on opens, and two of the winners had the lower click rate. The scorecard is rebuilt: click rate on delivered emails and revenue per email lead, open rate moves to a deliverability panel split by mailbox provider with an alert on any sharp fall, and subject-line tests are judged on clicks with orders as a tie-break.

Decision table

SituationUseWhy
Choosing between two subject linesClick rate, with opens as a secondary readOpens can favour the variant that reached more auto-loading clients
Testing email content or layoutClick rate and the conversions that followContent cannot affect whether the tracking image loaded
Watching for spam-folder problemsOpen rate, split by mailbox providerA sharp fall at one provider is an early warning
Reporting email to the businessClick rate and revenue per emailThey connect the email to the outcome it was sent for
Triggering a re-engagement flowLack of clicks or site visitsA lack of opens can be a blocked image, and an open can be a machine
Comparing with other senders or industriesNeither, without great careLists differ in client mix and audience, so figures do not travel

Rebuilding an email scorecard around clicks

Moving a scorecard from opens to clicks is mostly a matter of reordering what is already reported. Put the outcome figures first: conversions, revenue per email and, where flows have holdouts, the incremental result. Put click rate on delivered emails next as the main engagement metric, with unique clickers and the click distribution by link beside it. Move open rate to a separate deliverability panel, split by mailbox provider where the platform allows, labelled as approximate and read only as a trend.

Then change the rules that depend on opens. Subject-line tests should be judged on clicks or conversions, which the email metrics and testing guide covers with the volumes needed. Re-engagement and sunset rules that trigger on a lack of opens should trigger on a lack of clicks or visits instead, so engaged readers whose clients block images are not removed and dormant addresses are not kept alive by machines. Comparisons of email with other owned channels, such as the email versus SMS comparison, are fairer on clicks and outcomes too, since each channel counts opens differently or not at all. The email's format matters too: a plain-text-only message carries no tracking image and records no opens at all, which the guide to plain-text and HTML email takes into account when comparing formats on clicks.

Common mistakes

  • Leading the dashboard with open rate, so a rise caused by mail clients reads as better emails.
  • Picking subject-line winners on opens alone, which can reward the variant that reached more auto-loading clients.
  • Using click-to-open rate as a persuasion measure, when its denominator now includes machine opens.
  • Triggering flows on opens, which keeps dormant addresses and removes readers whose clients block images.
  • Benchmarking open rate against other senders, whose mix of mail clients is unknown.
  • Treating clicks as the final result, without following them to conversions and revenue.
  • Counting total clicks rather than unique clickers, so one enthusiastic reader inflates the figure.

Frequently asked questions

Is open rate still worth reporting?

Yes, as a rough signal rather than a result. Within one list, a sharp fall in opens across every send with no change in content is often the first visible sign that mail is landing in spam at a provider, and opens across a whole list over months still track the broad shape of engagement. What opens can no longer do is act as a goal, a test metric or a benchmark against other senders, because the share of automated and blocked opens differs from list to list.

What is the difference between click rate and click-to-open rate?

Click rate divides clicks by delivered emails, so it measures how many recipients acted on the email. Click-to-open rate divides clicks by opens, so it was meant to measure how persuasive the email was to people who read it. Because the open figure now includes machine activity, the denominator of click-to-open rate is inflated by an amount that varies by list, which makes the ratio hard to trust. Click rate on delivered emails is the steadier figure.

How should subject lines be tested now?

Send the variants to comparable random groups at the same time and judge them on clicks, or better on the conversions that follow, rather than on opens. Opens can still be reported alongside as a secondary signal, but a winner chosen on opens can be the variant that happened to reach more mail clients that load images automatically. The email testing guide covers the method and the volume a test needs to give a readable answer.

Terms used on this page

Where this page is used

Also related

Related