Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Email Marketing › Email Campaigns

Plain-Text and HTML Email

When to send a designed HTML email, a plain letter-style one or something in between, and what each changes for reading, accessibility and measurement.
Guidebeginner10 min readUpdated

Three formats, not two

A designed HTML email is the format most marketing email uses: a template with a header, images, coloured blocks and buttons, built to look like the brand. The newsletter design and copy guide covers how to build one well.

A plain-text-only email contains text and nothing else: no images, no colour, no buttons, no formatting beyond line breaks. Links appear as written addresses. It looks like an email typed by a person because, in structure, it is one.

A letter-style email sits between them. It is HTML, so it can carry a link with descriptive words on it, a small logo or a signature, a readable font and a tracking image, but it is styled to look like a personal message: one column of text, little or no imagery, a greeting and a named sender. Many emails that readers would call plain text are in fact letter-style.

The distinction matters because the trade-offs people attribute to plain text often belong to one of the other two. A letter-style email keeps much of the personal feel of plain text while keeping descriptive links and the measurement of a designed email; a plain-text-only email gives up both. Choosing well starts with naming which of the three is meant.

What changes between them

The three formats differ along five lines. None is better on every line, which is why the choice depends on the job the email does.

Row labelDesigned HTMLLetter-style HTMLPlain text only
ImagesCentral to the design; the email must still make sense without themFew or none; a small logo or signature at mostNone
LinksButtons and descriptive text linksDescriptive text linksThe address itself, written out
Accessibility workText alternatives, contrast, headings and reading order all need careLess to get wrong; headings and link text still matterLittle markup to get wrong, but no headings or descriptive links
Brand presenceStrong: colour, type, imageryLight: sender name, signature, tone of voiceTone of voice only
Production effortTemplate build, images, testing across devices and dark modeWriting; a simple template built onceWriting only
Opens recordedYes, with the caveats in the metrics guideYes, with the same caveatsNo
Clicks recordedYes, on tracked linksYes, on tracked linksYes, on tracked links

Two rows deserve emphasis. Production effort is the quiet reason many teams move some emails to a lighter format: a letter takes a writer an hour, while a designed email takes a template, images and testing. And the opens row changes how the format can be measured, which the measurement section below covers.

Reading, images and accessibility

A designed email is built around images, and images in email are less dependable than on the web. The newsletter design guide explains that several mail clients block images until the reader allows them, some strip them, and screen readers cannot see what an image contains. A designed email therefore has to work with every image missing: headings and copy as live text, buttons made from styled text, and a text alternative on every image that carries meaning.

The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, listed in sources, set out the principles the newsletter guide applies: text alternatives for non-text content, sufficient contrast between text and background, link text that makes sense out of context, a reading order that holds when styling is removed, and real headings. Each format meets them differently. A designed email has the most to get right, because it has the most images, colours and layout. A letter-style email has less to get wrong, but its links still need descriptive words, and a long letter still benefits from headings. A plain-text email has no images to describe and no colours to contrast, yet it has no headings either, and its links are bare addresses that make little sense read aloud, so it is not automatically the accessible choice. Short paragraphs, a clear order and a link introduced by a sentence that says where it goes are what make it readable.

Whatever the main format, a designed email usually travels with a plain-text part. The newsletter guide's FAQ explains that most sending platforms generate a multipart message with both, and that the plain-text part should be reviewed rather than trusted. The email campaign QA checklist includes it: the same order of content, the same links, and no leftover template labels or image names.

Measurement in each format

An open is recorded when a small tracking image in the email loads, as the email metrics and testing guide explains, and that figure is already weakened by mail clients that fetch images on the reader's behalf or strip them. The format adds a further break. A plain-text-only email carries no image, so it records no opens at all. A letter-style email, being HTML, can carry the tracking image and records opens with the same caveats as a designed one.

Clicks survive in every format. Tracked links record a click whether the link is a button, a descriptive phrase or a written address, and the click carries the reader to the page where the outcome happens. The open rate versus click rate comparison explains why clicks are the more trustworthy engagement figure in any case; the format question makes the choice for you. Judge every format on click-through (CTR) on its main call to action and on the outcomes that follow, and treat the open rate as a diagnostic for the formats that record it.

This has practical consequences. A report that compares formats on opens will show a plain-text email as a failure, whatever its readers did. A re-engagement rule that triggers on a lack of opens will treat every recipient of a plain-text email as inactive. Before switching any email to plain text only, check which reports, flows and rules read opens from it. The CTR calculator turns clicks and deliveries into the rate to compare.

Deliverability claims to treat with care

Claims that plain-text email reaches the inbox more often, or that images send mail to spam, are common. The sources this site relies on do not make them, and this guide does not either.

Google's sender guidelines, listed in sources and summarised in the deliverability guide, set out what Google expects of senders to its users: authentication of the sending domain, a spam rate kept below a documented threshold, messages formatted according to the internet message format standard, and, for bulk senders, further requirements including one-click unsubscribe for marketing and subscribed messages alongside a clearly visible unsubscribe link. None of those requirements concerns whether a message is designed. Formatting to the internet message standard is about the message's structure, which any properly built email in any of the three formats should meet.

What the guidelines do weigh, complaints above all, depends on what recipients think of the mail, and that depends on whether they wanted it, not on its styling. Two points follow. A plain-text or letter-style marketing email still needs the visible unsubscribe link and the same handling as a designed one; dressing a promotion as a personal note does not change what it is. And a change of format is no fix for a deliverability problem, which the deliverability guide diagnoses through authentication, reputation and sending behaviour.

Matching the format to the email's job

Choose the format by asking what the email is for and who the reader expects it to be from.

  • Transactional messages need clarity first. The promotional versus transactional comparison puts the essential facts first and asks for consistent branding so the message is recognisably from the business. Either a designed or a letter-style template can do that, provided the facts are live text rather than part of an image.
  • Nurture and sales follow-ups often suit the letter-style or plain-text formats. The nurture sequences guide notes that plain-text messages from a named person do a different job from designed templates and belong at the evaluation stage, where the lead expects a human.
  • Founder letters and editorial newsletters are written to be read as a person's voice, and a letter-style format keeps that voice while keeping links readable. The guide to choosing a newsletter format covers the editorial letter as a format in its own right.
  • Product-led newsletters, launches and offers usually need the designed format, because the product has to be seen and the reader expects the brand.

A reader's expectation is the deciding test. A message that pretends to be personal while plainly being a broadcast loses trust; a message that arrives as a glossy campaign when the reader expected a reply from a person feels like being processed. The campaigns hub lists the campaign types most teams run, and each can be matched to a format with the same question.

Testing a format change

A change of format is a good candidate for an A/B test, provided it is judged on a metric both versions can record. Split the recipients at random into two groups, send both versions at the same time, and decide before sending that the test will be judged on clicks on the main call to action and, where volume allows, on the outcome that follows. Opens cannot be the metric, because a plain-text version records none and a letter-style version records them on different terms from a designed one.

Keep everything except the format the same: the sender name, the subject line, the copy where it can be, the one link that matters. The email subject line test sets out the design of a fair email test with full random halves, and the metrics guide explains why a small list needs a larger difference, or several sends pooled, before a result means anything. Read unsubscribes beside clicks, because a format that feels too personal for a broadcast can draw exits as well as replies.

Where a format is chosen for a whole stream rather than a single send, as for nurture follow-ups, run the test over several weeks of entrants rather than one send, and compare the outcome the stream exists for.

A conveyancing firm's two formats (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Deedlark Conveyancing tests a letter-style follow-up

Deedlark Conveyancing, an invented property law firm, sends two kinds of email to people who have agreed to hear from it: a designed monthly update on the housing market, and a follow-up to people who asked for a quote but have not booked a call. The follow-up has always used the monthly update's template. For one quarter the firm splits new enquirers at random between that designed follow-up and a letter-style version signed by a named conveyancer, with the same subject line and one link to book a call. Both are judged on clicks to the booking link and on bookings.

FormatRecipientsClicks on booking linkBookings
Designed follow-up4103714
Letter-style follow-up4055823
Monthly update (designed, unchanged)3,2001459

The letter-style follow-up draws more booking clicks and more bookings at this volume, and unsubscribes are the same in both halves at 3 each. The firm moves enquirer follow-ups to the letter-style format, keeps the monthly update designed because its readers expect market charts, and stops reporting opens for the follow-up stream.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the choice as two formats. Most emails described as plain text are letter-style HTML, with different measurement and accessibility.
  • Judging formats on opens. A plain-text email records none, so any comparison on opens is decided before it starts.
  • Switching to plain text to fix deliverability. The requirements the site cites concern authentication, complaints, message formatting and unsubscribes, not design.
  • Assuming plain text is automatically accessible. Bare addresses and missing headings make it harder to read aloud than a well-built letter-style email.
  • Dressing a broadcast as a personal note. Readers notice, and the marketing rules and unsubscribe link still apply.
  • Leaving the plain-text part unreviewed. The generated version of a designed email carries template labels and broken lines nobody checked.
  • Forgetting the rules that read opens. Re-engagement and sunset rules treat every plain-text recipient as inactive.
  • Testing format alongside other changes. A new subject line or offer in the same test leaves nobody able to say what the format did.

Frequently asked questions

Do plain-text emails have better deliverability than HTML emails?

The sources this site relies on do not say so. Google's sender guidelines, as the deliverability guide summarises them, set requirements on authentication, complaint rates, message formatting to the internet message standard and unsubscribe handling; they do not make the inbox depend on whether a message is designed. What recipients do with the mail, and whether the sender meets those requirements, matters in any format. Choose the format for the reader and the job, not in the hope of better placement.

Why does a plain-text email show no opens?

Because an open is recorded when a small tracking image in the email loads, as the email metrics guide explains, and a plain-text-only message carries no images. Tracked links still record clicks, so a plain-text email can be judged on clicks and on what happens after them, which is the better basis for every format. A letter-style email is HTML underneath and can carry the tracking image, so its open figure has the same caveats as a designed email's.

Should a designed email also have a plain-text version?

Yes. The newsletter design and copy guide explains that most sending platforms send a designed email as a multipart message with a plain-text part beside the HTML. That part is what some readers and tools see, so review it before each send: the same order of content, the same links, and no leftover template labels or empty lines where images were. The email campaign QA checklist includes the line.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Also related

Sources

  1. Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) — W3C
  2. Email sender guidelines — Google Workspace Admin Help

Related