Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Email Marketing › Email Campaigns

Choosing a Newsletter Format

How to choose a newsletter format a team can sustain: curated links, an editorial letter, a product digest or offers, what each needs and how to measure it.
Guidebeginner12 min readUpdated

The format decides the work

Most newsletters are started by picking a template. The template is the last decision, not the first. Before it come three questions the format answers: where the material for each issue comes from, who turns it into an email and how long that takes, and what a reader gets that makes the next issue worth opening. A newsletter whose format was never chosen drifts between all of them, a few links one week, a sale the next, a founder's reflection after that, and readers stop being able to say what it is for.

The format also sets the newsletter's place among the other mail a business sends. The campaigns hub separates the recurring newsletter from promotional sends and announcements, and the promotional versus transactional comparison draws the line between marketing and service mail. A newsletter in an offers-led format sits close to the promotional side, with the frequency and consent questions that follow; an editorial or curated newsletter sits further from it and earns its place by being read.

The newsletter design and copy guide asks for one sentence on what the newsletter is for before the first issue. Choosing a format is how that sentence gets written. Who it is for and what they get from it follow from the format; how often follows from what the format costs to produce.

Five common formats

Five formats cover most business newsletters. Each needs a different input, makes a different promise and is judged on something slightly different.

FormatWhat each issue containsWhat it needs from the teamThe promise it supportsJudge it on
Curated linksA short selection of other people's articles, tools or news, each with a line on why it mattersTime to read widely every week, and a point of view on what is worth a reader's time"The best of what we read on this subject, so you do not have to"Clicks spread across the links; replies; forwards where measurable
Editorial letterOne piece of writing with a point of view, often signed by a personA writer with something to say each issue, and the time to say it well"What we think about this subject, from people who do it"Replies; clicks on the one link the letter carries; unsubscribes per issue
Product or news digestWhat changed: new products, features, stock, events or articles from the business itselfA steady supply of real news, and someone who gathers it"Everything new from us, in one place"Clicks on the main call to action; the actions that follow on the site or in the product
Offers-led emailCurrent offers, launches and reasons to buy nowA promotional calendar and a margin that can carry it"Our offers first"Conversions and revenue from email; unsubscribes as a guardrail
Community or member updateNews of and for a group: members, volunteers, customers, an event's attendeesContributions from the community and someone who collects them"What is happening among us"Replies and contributions; attendance or participation

Two things stand out from the table. The formats differ less in their design than in their inputs: a curated email lives on reading time, an editorial letter on a writer's time, a digest on there being news. And each is judged on something the format is built to produce. An editorial letter judged on clicks will be pushed towards links it does not need; a community update judged on revenue will be pushed towards offers its readers did not join for.

Publishers whose newsletter is the product itself face a different set of choices, including subscriptions and advertising, which the media and publishing industry guide covers. The formats here are for businesses whose newsletter supports something else they sell or run.

Matching the format to the audience and the team

The audience narrows the choice first. Ask what the people on the list, or the people the business wants on it, need that they cannot easily get elsewhere. Professionals who are short of time often value a well-chosen curated selection or a digest; people who follow a craft or a field often value a point of view; customers who buy often value knowing what is new; members of a group value hearing about each other. The content strategy framework makes the same choice in the same order for content in general: goals and audience first, formats and channels after them.

The team narrows it second, and this is where most newsletter plans go wrong. Write down, honestly, how many hours a week the people who will produce the newsletter actually have, and what each format would ask of those hours. An editorial letter needs a person who can write and who will keep writing; when that person is busy or leaves, the format stops. A curated email needs someone reading widely every week, which is a real cost even if the reading would happen anyway. A digest needs a reliable feed of news; in a quiet month it has nothing to say. An offers-led email needs a promotional calendar and margin, which is a commercial decision rather than an editorial one.

The business's content plan narrows it third. The content pillars and calendar guide explains how a business chooses the few themes it wants to be known for, its content pillars, and sizes an editorial calendar to real capacity. A newsletter that draws on those pillars is cheaper to produce, because each issue can carry or summarise something the business has already made. The repurposing guide covers how one asset becomes a set of smaller pieces, and a newsletter section is a natural one. A business with a library of evergreen content can also run a digest that resurfaces older pieces when they become relevant again.

Where two formats fit, choose the one the team could still produce in its worst month. A newsletter that keeps its promise in a modest format earns more trust than an ambitious one that misses issues.

The promise at sign-up and the cadence

The format becomes a promise in the sentence beside the sign-up form. The list building and consent guide explains why that sentence matters: expectations are set there, and most unsubscribes trace back to a gap between what it said and what arrived. A vague line such as "get our newsletter" promises nothing in particular; a format makes a specific one possible, such as a curated selection on a named subject every other week, or new products and one recipe on the first Thursday of the month.

Each format also implies a cadence. A digest's cadence follows the business's news, so it should not be promised more often than news genuinely appears. A curated email can be weekly if someone reads every week. An editorial letter is usually less frequent, because writing takes longer than gathering. An offers-led email is the one most tempted to grow beyond its promise, and the campaigns hub's rule applies to it most: promotional sends sit inside the promised frequency rather than on top of it.

Choose the cadence for the team's capacity rather than for ambition, write it into the promise, and keep it. If the right frequency is genuinely uncertain, the email frequency test sets out how to compare cadences on the same list without guessing.

One newsletter or several

A business with more than one audience, or more than one thing to say, eventually asks whether to run several newsletters. The answer is usually one newsletter until there is a clear reason for a second, and the reason is that a group of readers wants something the main format cannot give them without changing it for everyone else.

When there is a second newsletter, run it as a preference stream rather than as a separate list. The segmentation guide treats topic, frequency and format as preferences that people state, and the list-building guide treats the preference centre as the place where those choices are made and changed. A subscriber who wants the product digest but not the editorial letter should be able to choose that from any issue, and the choice should be enforced automatically rather than remembered by whoever builds the send.

Three costs come with a second newsletter. Each one needs its own production time, its own promise and its own measurement. Readers who take both receive more mail, so the total frequency should still match what they agreed to. And a second format that is not sustained becomes a broken promise of its own. A lower-frequency option, such as a monthly digest beside a weekly letter, is often a better second stream than a new subject, because it keeps people who would otherwise leave. A newsletter published on LinkedIn is a different kind of second stream, reaching subscribers through the platform rather than the business's own list, and the guide to LinkedIn newsletters for pages and profiles covers when one is worth running and how it can feed the email list.

Measuring each format

Each format should be judged on what it is built to produce, with the same health checks underneath all of them. The common layer is the one the campaigns hub sets out for every newsletter: click-through on the main call to action, replies and unsubscribes per issue. Above it, each format has its own reading:

  • Curated links: the spread of clicks across links shows what readers value, and a run of issues where one kind of link draws the clicks says what to curate more of.
  • Editorial letter: replies and the clicks on the one link the letter carries; an editorial letter with no replies over many issues is not starting conversations.
  • Product or news digest: clicks on the main item and the actions that follow on the site or in the product, since the digest exists to move people towards what is new.
  • Offers-led email: conversions and revenue from email, read beside unsubscribes, because an offers-led newsletter can earn revenue while wearing out the list.
  • Community update: replies, contributions and participation in whatever the community does.

Read growth by source as well. List growth net of unsubscribes, split by the sign-up point each subscriber came from, shows whether the promise attracts the people the format serves. The newsletter growth loop case study follows an invented trade newsletter whose issue was rebuilt to be forwarded, which is one way a format can feed its own growth.

Compare each format with its own history rather than with figures from other lists. The email metrics and testing guide explains why opens are a weak measure and why a list's own past is the only fair comparison.

Changing format without losing readers

Formats need changing when the team's capacity changes, when the audience has moved, or when the measures above show the format is not doing its job. The risk in changing is that readers who joined for the old promise receive something else, which is exactly the gap the list-building guide says drives exits.

Change in three moves. First, announce the change in the issue before it happens: what is changing, why, and what the reader will get instead. Second, rewrite the sign-up promise on every form on the day the new format starts, so that new subscribers join for what they will receive. Third, give existing readers a choice where the change is large: stay for the new format, move to a lighter stream if one exists, or leave cleanly. The content distribution guide treats the newsletter as the one channel a business owns outright; a format change is one of the few moments when that audience can be lost in a single send.

After the change, read the first few issues against the old format's history on the same measures, accepting that the first issue of a new format is rarely typical. If exits concentrate among subscribers from one sign-up point, their promise was the one most changed, and they may need a word of their own.

A bike repair co-op's newsletter decision (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Spannerwhim Bike Co-op chooses a format

Spannerwhim Bike Co-op, an invented community bike repair workshop run by volunteers, has 1,900 subscribers and a monthly email that has drifted between workshop dates, links to cycling articles and donation appeals. Its coordinator lists three options against the volunteer time the co-op can count on, 3 hours a week in total:

OptionWeekly hours neededWhat it would promiseJudged on
Curated cycling links, weekly4The best repair and commuting reads of the weekClicks spread across links; replies
Monthly editorial letter from a mechanic2.5One repair lesson a month from the benchReplies; clicks on the workshop booking link
Fortnightly workshop digest with one editorial paragraph2Workshop dates, parts in stock and one fix of the fortnightBooking clicks; replies; unsubscribes per issue

The curated option needs more time than the co-op has. The letter depends on a single mechanic who is not always available. The co-op chooses the fortnightly digest, keeps one short editorial paragraph at the top so it has a voice, and rewrites its sign-up line to "Workshop dates, parts in stock and one fix of the fortnight, every other Monday". The issue before the switch announces the change and offers a monthly version; 140 subscribers choose it. After six issues the digest has gone out on time every fortnight, booking clicks have risen from about 60 to about 95 an issue, and 11 people have replied with their own fixes.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing a template before a format. The design is settled and nobody has decided what goes in it each issue.
  • Choosing the format the team admires rather than the one it can produce. An editorial letter with no writer becomes an irregular one, then a missing one.
  • Mixing lead formats issue to issue. Readers cannot predict what the email is for, and the sign-up promise stops describing it.
  • Promising a cadence the format cannot sustain. A weekly digest in a business with monthly news fills the gaps with filler.
  • Judging every format on the same number. An editorial letter judged on revenue, or an offers email judged on replies, is pushed away from what it does well.
  • Starting a second newsletter as a separate list. Run it as a preference stream so choices can be changed and total frequency stays visible.
  • Changing format without telling anyone. Readers who joined for the old promise leave together, and nobody connects the exits to the change.
  • Leaving the old sign-up wording live. New subscribers join for a newsletter that no longer exists.

Frequently asked questions

Which newsletter format works best?

There is no format that wins for every list, and no figure that would say so. The format that works is the one whose promise matches what the audience signed up for and whose production the team can sustain at the promised cadence. A curated email from a team with no time to read widely, or an editorial letter from a business with nothing to say, fails whatever the format's reputation. Choose on audience and capacity, then judge the result on your own list's clicks, replies and unsubscribes over several issues.

Can a newsletter mix formats?

Yes, and many do: a product digest with one short editorial paragraph at the top, or a curated email with a single offer at the end. The mix works when one format leads and the other plays a fixed, minor role in the same place every issue, so readers know what they are getting. It fails when the lead format changes from issue to issue, because readers can no longer predict what the email is for and the sign-up promise no longer describes it.

How often should a newsletter go out?

As often as the format can be produced well, for as long as the team can keep it up, and no more often than the sign-up form promised. The format sets the limit: a digest depends on there being news, a curated email on reading time, an editorial letter on the writer's week. Where the right cadence is genuinely uncertain, an email frequency test settles it on evidence rather than on ambition.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Also related

Related