Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Metric

List Growth Rate

Net change in an email list over a period as a share of its size at the start.
AnalyticsmetricUpdated

Formula

(New subscribers − Unsubscribes − Removals for bounces and complaints) ÷ List size at the start of the period × 100

Unit: % · higher is better

Definition

List growth rate measures net change. Count the new subscribers who joined during the period, subtract the subscribers who left or were removed in the same period, and divide by the number of contactable subscribers at the start. The period is usually a month or a quarter, and it has to be stated with the figure.

(New subscribers − Unsubscribes − Removals for bounces and complaints) ÷ List size at the start of the period × 100(%)

  • New subscribers are people who joined the marketing list during the period with a recorded consent basis. Where the list uses Double Opt-In, only confirmed addresses count; unconfirmed sign-ups are not yet subscribers.
  • Unsubscribes are subscribers who opted out during the period, by link, by one-click header or by reply.
  • Removals for bounces and complaints are addresses suppressed because they hard-bounced or because the recipient marked a message as spam. Whether addresses removed in a hygiene pass for long inactivity are subtracted as well is a choice to state with the figure, not to leave implicit.
  • List size at the start of the period is the count of contactable subscribers on the first day, excluding addresses already suppressed.

Gross growth and net growth

Gross growth counts only the new sign-ups over the starting list. It is easy to produce, it only ever goes up, and it is the figure most email platforms put on the dashboard. Net growth is the one in the formula above. The gap between them is the list's decay, and that gap is often larger than teams expect: a list can have a healthy gross figure and a net figure near zero, which means acquisition is only replacing the people lost. Reporting both, side by side, shows the decay as clearly as the acquisition.

Two kinds of addition never count as growth. Addresses that were bought, rented or scraped carry no consent from the people behind them and tend to bounce and complain, and an imported list of old contacts who never agreed to marketing is the same problem in a different form. The list building and consent guide explains why those sources damage the list they join.

How to interpret it

Higher is better, with conditions. The useful readings are:

  • By source. Sign-ups from a checkout opt-in, a content download, a competition and an event behave differently. A source that adds many addresses that unsubscribe or go silent within weeks contributes less than its gross count suggests, and can harm Deliverability for the whole list.
  • Against decay. Watching the removal side on its own shows whether the list is losing people faster than before, which usually points to frequency, relevance or a sign-up promise the mail does not keep.
  • Against engagement. A list that grows while the share of active subscribers falls is growing a mailing cost, not an audience. The email metrics and testing guide places net growth among the health measures read beside engagement and revenue.
  • Over a longer period. Monthly figures move with campaigns, seasons and hygiene passes; a quarter or a year shows the trend.

Where inactive removals are subtracted, a hygiene pass will make the rate drop sharply in the month it happens. That is the list becoming more accurate, not shrinking in any way that matters, and it should be annotated in the report rather than explained away later.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A board games café counts what it loses

Hollins Board Games Café started a month with 3,000 subscribers and celebrated 210 new sign-ups, a gross growth of 7%. Counting the other side changed the picture: 95 people unsubscribed, 60 addresses hard-bounced and were removed, and 15 were suppressed after spam complaints. Net growth was 40 subscribers, or 1.3%. Most new subscribers were only replacing those lost. The café then put a card on every table offering a free hot drink on the next visit for joining the list, with double opt-in, and stopped mailing a list of old event contacts it had imported. Three months later, starting from 3,100 subscribers, it added 380 confirmed sign-ups and lost 100 to unsubscribes and 55 to bounce and complaint removals. Net growth was 225 subscribers, or 7.3%.

What moves it

  • Sign-up placements and offers. Where the form appears and what it promises decide the volume and the quality of new subscribers; an offer relevant to the product attracts buyers, a prize attracts prize-seekers.
  • Consent practice. Clear consent and confirmation lower the number of complaints and dead addresses that later come off the list.
  • Frequency and relevance. Sending too often, or sending what the sign-up did not promise, raises unsubscribes and complaints.
  • Hygiene. Processing bounces and complaints after every send, and removing long-inactive addresses on a schedule, lowers the apparent rate in the short term and protects inbox placement for the rest. The email list hygiene SOP sets out that routine.
  • The welcome experience. People who receive what they signed up for, promptly, are less likely to leave in their first weeks.

What good looks like

There is no reliable universal benchmark, and the site does not cite one. A healthy rate depends on the business's sign-up sources, its sending frequency, its audience and how strictly it cleans the list, so a figure that is strong for one programme is weak for another. The useful comparisons are internal: the net rate against the same months last year, each sign-up source's net contribution against its gross, and the rate against what the business needs. That last test is arithmetic. If email produces a known share of revenue or leads and each subscriber is worth a known amount, the net growth required to reach next year's target can be calculated, which is a better target than any industry figure.

Unsubscribe Rate and Spam Complaint Rate are the two largest parts of the decay the formula subtracts; a rise in either shows up here as slower growth before it shows anywhere else. Deliverability depends on the quality of what is added, so a list growing through poor sources can grow its way into the spam folder. Double Opt-In lowers gross growth and usually raises net growth over time, because fewer bad addresses join. The email programme audit asks for list growth, bounces, complaints and unsubscribes by month, and the pages on online sales through email and lead generation through email show where list growth sits in the measures each objective tracks.

Common mistakes

  • Reporting gross sign-ups as growth, so the list's decay never appears.
  • Leaving bounce and complaint removals out of the formula, because the platform suppresses them quietly.
  • Counting unconfirmed sign-ups on a list that uses double opt-in.
  • Treating imported or bought lists as growth, which adds complaints and bounces, not subscribers.
  • Reading a hygiene month as a crisis, instead of annotating the clean-up.
  • Targeting growth without engagement, so the list grows while the share of people who read it falls.

More terms to look up

Where this term is used

Related