Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Glossary term

First-Price Auction

An auction in which the winner pays the amount it bid.
Ad TechconceptUpdated

Definition

Every impression sold in real-time bidding (RTB) goes to an auction. Two pricing rules have been common.

  • Second-price. The highest bidder wins but pays the second-highest bid, or a small increment above it. A buyer can bid its true value for the impression, knowing it will usually pay less.
  • First-price. The highest bidder wins and pays its own bid. Bidding the full value means paying the full value, even when nobody else came close.

The OpenRTB specification lets each bid request declare which rule applies, through its auction type field, so a bidder knows before it responds. The real-time bidding guide walks through the request and response in which that field sits.

Why programmatic moved to first price

Over time the major exchanges switched to first-price auctions, and Google documents that its Ad Manager runs a unified first-price auction for the demand competing in it. One practical property of the rule is that a bid means the same thing wherever it is made. Publishers commonly offer an impression to several supply-side platforms at once, and when each auction charges the winner its own bid, the prices coming back from different sources can be compared directly. The programmatic hub gives the wider picture of how buying and selling platforms connect.

Bid shading and floor prices

First price changes the bidder's problem. Bidding true value leaves money on the table whenever competition is light. Bid shading is the response: the demand-side platform (DSP) estimates, from its history of wins and losses on similar impressions, the lowest price likely to win, and bids somewhere between that estimate and the buyer's valuation. Most DSPs shade automatically in first-price auctions; whether a buyer can tune it varies by platform, which the DV360 bidding and pacing guide shows for that DSP.

Shading has side effects. Win rate falls a little, because some shaded bids lose auctions a full bid would have won. New line items, with little win history, tend to pay more at first because the model has less to learn from. And floor prices, the minimum a publisher will accept, carry more weight: with no runner-up price to anchor on, the floor is often what sets the price in a thin auction.

In practice: what it means for a buyer's CPM

Under first price, the price paid per thousand impressions (CPM) tracks the bid more closely, so a bid set at full value raises CPM directly. The practical habits follow: let shading work unless there is a reason not to, read win rate beside CPM, and compare prices across exchanges and deals rather than assuming a lower bid means a worse position. In a private marketplace (PMP) the same rule usually applies among invited buyers above the deal's floor, as the deal types guide explains, while a fixed-price deal involves no auction at all. The CPM calculator turns a change in price into a change in impressions for a set budget.

Search advertising is a separate case. Google Ads prices a click at what is needed to beat the ad ranked below, adjusted for quality, which is neither a pure first-price nor a pure second-price rule. The comparison of CPC and CPM buying sets out why the two models reward different things.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A language school's CPM jumps

Vowelthatch Language School buys display through a DSP with a fixed bid of £6.00 CPM, its full value for impressions reaching adults interested in learning Spanish, and a budget of £1,700 a month. Under second-price rules its average CPM was £3.70, buying about 460,000 impressions a month. When its main exchange moves to first-price auctions, the school pays its full bid on almost every win: average CPM rises to £5.85 and the same budget buys about 290,000 impressions. The team switches the line item to the DSP's automated strategy with bid shading. Average CPM settles at £4.10, win rate is slightly lower than before, and the budget buys roughly 415,000 impressions a month.

RTB is the process in which these auctions run. A DSP places bids and applies shading on the buyer's behalf. CPM is the price the auction rule most directly affects, and a PMP deal usually runs its own first-price auction among invited buyers.

Common confusions

  • First price means paying more. It means paying what you bid; with shading, prices can end close to where they were.
  • Bid shading is a discount. It is a prediction, and a wrong prediction loses the auction.
  • All ad auctions work this way. Search auctions price clicks by their own rules.
  • A lower bid always means fewer impressions. Under shading, a modest drop in bid can cost little volume.
  • Floors only matter in thin markets. Under first price they often set the price wherever competition is light.

More terms to look up

Calculators

Where this term is used

Sources

  1. OpenRTB specification — IAB Tech Lab

Related