Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Programmatic Advertising › How Programmatic Works

Open Auction, PMP and Programmatic Guaranteed

Open auction, private marketplace, preferred deals and programmatic guaranteed compared: how deal IDs work, pricing and priority, and when each fits.
Guideintermediate12 min readUpdated

Why deals exist alongside the open auction

The open auction is the purest form of programmatic: any connected buyer may bid on any impression the publisher offers, and the highest bid wins. It gives buyers reach and publishers demand, and for a large share of inventory it is the right mechanism. It also leaves both sides wanting things it cannot provide.

Publishers want to control who appears on their premium placements and at what price, to sell their best inventory before the auction sees it, to attach their own audience data without releasing it to the market, and to sell guaranteed volume to advertisers who will pay for certainty. None of that fits an open auction, where the publisher sets a floor and takes whoever bids above it. Before programmatic, these needs were met by a sales team selling insertion orders; deals bring the same relationship inside the programmatic pipes.

Buyers want things the open auction cannot promise either. Certainty about which sites and placements the ad will run on, rather than an inclusion list that the auction may or may not fill. Access to inventory that a publisher never releases to the open market, including homepage placements, premium video and logged-in audiences. A first look at an impression before competitors see it. A fixed price that can be planned around. And, for reach-driven campaigns, a guaranteed number of impressions on a named property, which is what a direct buy offered and what a guaranteed deal reproduces with the DSP's targeting, frequency control and ad serving intact.

Deals meet those needs without giving up the automation. The buyer still targets, caps frequency, serves from its own ad server and reports in one place; the publisher still yields its inventory through one system. The fundamentals hub shows where deals sit in the journey of an impression; the programmatic vs direct buying comparison weighs a guaranteed deal against the insertion order it replaces.

The four deal types

Google Ad Manager's help centre names the four transaction types that a publisher can offer: Open Auction, Private Auction, Preferred Deal and Programmatic Guaranteed. Other SSPs use the same vocabulary with minor variations, and "private marketplace" or "PMP" is used loosely for any deal that is not the open auction.

Deal typeWho can buyPriceVolumeHow the impression is allocatedTypical use
Open auctionAny buyer connected to the exchangeAuction; publisher sets a floorWhatever the buyer winsHighest eligible bid wins under first-price rulesReach at scale with inventory lists and verification as the controls
Private auction (PMP)Invited buyers only, identified by deal IDAuction among the invited; floor set per deal, usually above the open floorWhatever the buyer wins among invited competitorsInvited bids compete; depending on the publisher's settings they may also compete with open-auction demandPremium or packaged inventory where the buyer wants to know who else is bidding
Preferred dealOne buyer, by deal IDFixed, agreed in advanceNon-guaranteed; the buyer may take or decline each impressionBuyer gets a first look at eligible impressions before the auction, at the fixed priceAccess to specific inventory or publisher data with flexibility on volume
Programmatic guaranteedOne buyer, by deal IDFixed, agreed in advanceGuaranteed; the publisher commits to deliverReserved in the publisher's ad server like a direct-sold campaignPlanned reach on named properties, sponsorships, high-impact formats

Reading across the rows, the types move from open to closed, from uncertain to certain and, usually, from cheaper to dearer per thousand impressions (CPM). Reading down the price column, the first two are auctions and the last two are fixed prices, which matters for how the DSP bids: in an auction the DSP shades and competes, in a fixed-price deal it simply bids the agreed amount when the impression fits.

Deal IDs and how a deal is matched

A deal is created on the sell side. The publisher, in its ad server or supply-side platform (SSP), defines the inventory the deal covers, the price or floor, the dates, the buyer or buyers permitted, and any targeting the publisher applies; the system generates a deal ID, a string that identifies the deal in every message about it. The publisher shares the ID with the buyer, or, where the platforms support it, the buyer and seller negotiate inside a marketplace that exchanges the terms and the ID automatically.

On the buy side, the deal ID has to be attached to something that bids. In most DSPs that means creating an inventory source or deal object that holds the ID and then targeting it from a line item. The line item's own targeting still applies on top: geography, audience, frequency, creative sizes. If the deal offers inventory in one country and the line item targets another, nothing will ever match, and the deal will look broken when it is merely over-constrained.

When an impression that the deal covers becomes available, the SSP includes the deal in the bid request's imp.pmp object: a list of deal IDs the impression is eligible for, each with its own floor or fixed price and auction type, and a flag that says whether only the listed deals may bid or whether open-auction bids may compete too. The DSP sees the ID, recognises that a line item holds it, and returns a bid carrying the same ID in its response so the exchange can apply the deal's terms. A preferred or guaranteed deal is matched at its agreed price; a private auction deal is matched if the bid clears the deal's floor and beats the other invited bids.

Creatives matter here more than buyers expect. The exchange must have approved the creatives the line item will serve, and the sizes must match what the deal's placements accept. A deal for a single large format with a line item that holds only standard sizes produces requests, no bids and a confused conversation with the publisher. The real-time bidding guide covers the request and response messages in which all of this travels.

Pricing and priority

A deal's price and its priority in the publisher's ad server are set together, and the two explain most of what a buyer sees in delivery.

Google documents the order in which Ad Manager evaluates demand. Programmatic guaranteed deals are reserved inventory: the ad server treats them like guaranteed direct-sold line items, forecasts against them and protects their delivery, so a guaranteed deal takes its impressions before any auction is run. Preferred deals give the buyer a first look: when an eligible impression appears, the buyer may take it at the fixed price before it goes to auction, and if the buyer declines or bids below the fixed price the impression proceeds to the auction. Private auction and open auction bids then compete, in a unified first-price auction in Google's case, with each deal's floor applied to the bids made under it. Other publisher ad servers follow a similar ladder with their own names; the shape is what matters.

The buyer-side consequences are concrete. A guaranteed deal's price is the price, paid on every impression delivered, so it must be set against what the same inventory would cost in auction plus a premium for certainty. A preferred deal's fixed price is paid only on impressions the buyer accepts, which makes it a cheap way to gain access but a poor way to guarantee reach, since the publisher owes nothing. A private auction's floor is usually above the open floor, and bids under it compete against each other and sometimes against open demand, so the DSP shades them as it would any auction bid. And a buyer holding several deals with one publisher may find them competing with each other for the same impressions, with the higher-priority deal winning every time regardless of which the buyer would prefer.

Priority also interacts with the publisher's direct business. A direct-sold sponsorship can take impressions that a guaranteed deal expected, depending on how the publisher has set its priorities; delivery shortfalls on guaranteed deals are usually a priority conflict on the sell side, and the publisher can see it in its own forecasting.

Choosing the deal type

The choice follows from what the plan needs most: reach, certainty, access or price. The table is a starting point; the right mix for a campaign usually includes more than one row.

If the plan needsChooseBecauseWatch for
Broad reach at the lowest price with acceptable qualityOpen auction with inclusion lists and pre-bid verificationThe widest supply at auction prices; controls supply the qualitySpend drifting to a long tail; made-for-advertising sites; win rate falling as controls stack
The same reach on a curated set of publishersPrivate auctionKnown inventory and known competitors, still at auction pricesFloors above the open floor; the deal's volume forecast being optimistic
Access to inventory or data the open market never seesPreferred dealA first look at the publisher's price, with no obligation to take itThin delivery if the line item's targeting is narrow; no volume commitment
A planned number of impressions on named propertiesProgrammatic guaranteedThe publisher commits to volume; the ad server reserves itPaying the fixed price on impressions the DSP would have declined; priority conflicts with direct sales
Testing a publisher before committingPreferred deal, then guaranteedLearn the inventory's performance at a fixed price with no volume lock-inShort tests on narrow targeting produce little data
High-impact or sponsorship formatsProgrammatic guaranteedThese are rarely offered in auction and need reserved deliveryCreative specifications and approval lead times

Deal choice is one part of a media plan rather than the whole of it, and the media planning framework this guide draws on treats it as a sequencing decision: open auction to learn what the audience costs, deals to secure the inventory that proved to matter, and guaranteed volume only where the plan cannot tolerate uncertainty. Brand safety settings apply inside deals as well as in the open auction, and the brand safety and viewability guide explains why a deal with a trusted publisher reduces but does not remove the need for them.

Negotiating and troubleshooting deals

A deal is a negotiation before it is a configuration, and most deal problems were created in the conversation. The terms worth agreeing in writing are the inventory itself (sites, sections, placements, formats and sizes), the price and whether it is fixed or a floor, the dates and the publisher's volume estimate, what targeting the buyer may apply on top (a publisher offering a deal on its homepage may not expect the buyer to then target only a small audience segment), what data the publisher applies and whether it costs extra, the viewability and brand safety expectations, who approves creatives and how long that takes, and how the two sides will compare numbers. A deal negotiated without a volume estimate cannot be judged, and one negotiated without agreeing the counting source produces a dispute at the first invoice.

Once live, troubleshooting follows the chain the impression takes. Work down it in order and stop at the first stage that fails.

  1. No bid requests. The deal ID is not attached to a line item, the deal is not active on the publisher's side, the dates have not started, or the DSP is not listening to the exchange that carries it.
  2. Requests but no bids. The line item's targeting does not overlap the deal's inventory, the creatives are not approved on that exchange or do not match the deal's sizes, pacing is holding the line item back, or the line item's bid is below the deal's price so the DSP does not respond.
  3. Bids but no wins. Another deal with higher priority is taking the impressions, the private auction floor is above the bid, or responses are arriving after the deadline.
  4. Wins but few impressions. The creative is failing to render, or the ad server's count is lower than the DSP's for the usual reasons, which is a reconciliation question rather than a deal problem.
Illustrative example — not a real result

Three routes to the same travel publisher

A tour operator wants its spring campaign in front of a travel publisher's readers and compares three routes over a four-week test with £30,000 split evenly. In the open auction, with the publisher's domains on an inclusion list, the DSP wins 2.4 million impressions at an average CPM of £4.15, but a third of them land on the publisher's forum pages, and viewability measures 58 per cent. Through a private auction deal on the editorial sections only, with a £7.00 floor, it wins 1.3 million impressions at £7.60 with 71 per cent viewability. Through a programmatic guaranteed deal on the destination guides at a fixed £11.00 CPM, it receives the 900,000 impressions agreed, at 79 per cent viewability, with the publisher's logged-in audience data applied. Cost per engaged site visit, measured in the ad server, comes out at £2.90, £2.35 and £2.10 respectively. The operator keeps the guaranteed deal for the destination guides, moves the private auction budget to a preferred deal at £7.00 to keep access without the volume risk, and cuts the open-auction line item back to a remarketing role.

Where a deal and the open auction deliver similar results, the open auction usually wins on flexibility. Where the deal delivers something the auction cannot, access, data or certainty, the premium is the price of that thing, and the test above is the only way to know what it is worth.

To price deal types on the same footing, the impression calculator tutorial for programmatic deals adds fees to the media price and divides by viewability.

Because deals are created on the sell side and bought on the buy side, the DSP versus SSP comparison is a useful companion on what each platform controls.

Common mistakes

  • Buying a private marketplace for price. Deal floors usually sit above open-auction floors; the purchase is certainty and access, not a discount.
  • Attaching a deal ID and targeting it to nothing. Narrow line-item targeting on top of a narrow deal leaves no impressions that match both.
  • Forgetting creative approval and sizes. The commonest cause of a deal with requests and no bids.
  • Committing to guaranteed volume before an auction test. The fixed price is paid on every impression, including the ones the DSP would have declined.
  • Running several deals with one publisher without checking priority. The higher-priority deal takes the impressions whether or not it is the one the plan prefers.
  • Negotiating without a volume estimate or an agreed counting source. Neither delivery nor the invoice can then be judged.
  • Assuming a deal removes the need for brand safety and viewability controls. It narrows the inventory; it does not verify it.

Frequently asked questions

Is a private marketplace cheaper than the open auction?

Usually not per thousand impressions, and it is not meant to be. A private auction carries a floor the publisher sets for invited buyers, which is normally above the open-auction floor because the inventory is better described, better placed or paired with publisher data. What a private marketplace buys is certainty about where the ad runs and who else is competing; whether that certainty is worth the premium depends on what the open auction, with a strict inclusion list, would have delivered for the same money.

What is the difference between a preferred deal and programmatic guaranteed?

Both fix the price in advance. A preferred deal is non-guaranteed: the buyer gets a first look at each eligible impression at the agreed price and may decline it, and the publisher has promised no volume. Programmatic guaranteed reserves a stated number of impressions for the buyer at the agreed price, and the publisher's ad server treats them like a direct-sold campaign with the same obligation to deliver. Preferred deals suit a buyer who wants access and flexibility; guaranteed deals suit one who needs volume it can plan around.

Why is my deal not spending?

Work down the chain. If the DSP shows no bid requests for the deal, the deal ID is not attached to a line item, the deal has not been activated on the publisher's side, or the line item's targeting excludes everything the deal offers. If requests arrive but no bids are made, the creatives have not been approved by the exchange, the sizes do not match, or pacing is holding the line item back. If bids are made but nothing wins, the bid is below the deal's price or a higher-priority deal is taking the impressions. Each stage has its own report in most DSPs.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Part of these learning paths

Also related

Sources

  1. Google Ad Manager Help — Google
  2. Display & Video 360 Help — Google

Related