Definition
A free shipping threshold, also called a free delivery threshold or minimum order for free delivery, is a basket value set by an online store at or above which the standard delivery charge is waived. Orders below it pay the normal fee. It differs from free delivery on every order, which removes the fee entirely, and from a delivery discount code, which is usually temporary and limited to some customers. A threshold is a standing rule that applies to everyone, so it shapes basket behaviour on every order, every day.
It works on a quirk of perception that the average order value levers guide describes: a delivery fee feels like a penalty, while an extra product feels like value, even when the product costs more than the fee it replaces.
In practice: setting the level from the basket distribution
The level is set from the spread of basket values, not from the average. When many orders cluster a little below a round figure, a threshold placed just above that cluster gives those shoppers a target they can reach with one more item. When baskets are spread evenly, or sit far below any sensible line, the threshold mostly waives delivery on orders that would have happened at the same size anyway.
Three other inputs belong in the decision: what delivery actually costs the store per order, the margin on the items people tend to add, and whether those items come back. A threshold reached by adding a cheap filler that is later returned costs the store twice. Presentation matters too. A shopper has to know the line exists and how far away it is, which is why stores show the remaining amount in the basket and on the product page, where delivery cost is one of the questions shoppers want answered before they commit. The threshold is also part of the store's wider set of delivery promises, so the figure in an ad, on a product page and at checkout has to be the same.
Why it is judged on contribution, not order value
Raising a threshold almost always lifts average order value among the people who still buy. That is the misleading part. The same change can reduce how many people buy and increase the delivery cost the store absorbs, and neither shows up in the average. Contribution margin per visitor folds all three effects into one number: revenue, minus cost of goods, delivery paid by the store, payment fees and, where known, returns, divided by everyone who visited.
The contribution margin and break-even guide explains how to build that figure, and the break-even calculator helps check the cost assumptions behind it. The free shipping threshold test designs the comparison properly: one arm keeps the current line, the other moves it, each visitor stays in one arm across sessions, and checkout conversion and return rate act as guardrails while order value is kept as a diagnostic.
A pantry food shop raises its free delivery line
Wickerfen Pantry Foods charges £4.50 delivery and offers free delivery over £30. Most of its baskets fall between £32 and £38, so nearly every order already clears the line. It tests a threshold of £40 against the current one for four weeks, with 9,000 visitors in each arm. In the £40 arm, average order value rises from £36 to £41 and orders fall from 270 to 252. Delivery the shop pays for drops sharply, because many baskets now sit below the line and pay the fee. Contribution margin per visitor moves from £0.31 to £0.36. The shop keeps the new threshold, but watches returns of the small jars shoppers added to qualify.
Related terms
AOVAverage revenue per order. is the figure a threshold is designed to lift, and the one most likely to flatter it. Contribution MarginRevenue left after every cost that varies with each sale. is what decides whether the extra items covered the delivery given away. Cart Abandonment RateShare of shopping carts created that did not become an order. rises when a threshold is set out of reach or revealed too late, because an unexpected delivery fee at checkout is a familiar reason to leave. Revenue per VisitorRevenue divided by the number of visitors in the same period. combines conversion and order value in one figure, and is the closest revenue-only cousin of the margin measure a threshold should be read on.
Common confusions
- A higher average order means the threshold works. It can rise while fewer people buy and the store pays more delivery; read margin per visitor instead.
- The threshold should sit at the average basket. The useful level depends on where baskets cluster, which an average hides.
- Free delivery is free. The store still pays the carrier; the threshold only moves who pays and when.
- Once set, it stays right. Carrier costs, prices and the product range shift the basket distribution, so the level is rechecked when any of them change.
- A hidden threshold still helps. If shoppers cannot see it in the basket, it changes little except margin.
